BBC Home

Explore the BBC

11th July 2014
Accessibility help
Text only

BBC Homepage

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

reviews /  editor book review
editor content by: editor
art spiegelman 'the in theshadow of no towers' art spiegelman
in the shadow of no towers
real player to access audio and video on collective you need real player.
Comic-book artist Spiegelman responds to 9/11.

Art Spiegelman’s first comics work since the highly acclaimed, Pulitzer Prize-winning Holocaust narrative, MAUS, will inevitably elicit comparisons with that mighty work. Furthermore, the fact that it’s only 42 pages long, printed horizontally on thick cardboard pages with the main narrative only taking up 20 of them (the rest being a lengthy history of American newspaper cartoons and then examples of said strips featuring patriotic material) may further erode confidence. Best to avoid such impulses, really, as they will foster a disappointment that this book certainly doesn’t deserve.

Taken on its own, In The Shadow Of No Towers is an inventive, personal and undoubtedly powerful take on 9/11, built on two levels. Firstly, a fear-packed personal recollection of the day when Spiegelman and his wife frantically searched for their young daughter, schooled mere blocks from the Twin Towers, and secondly, a far more bitter and exasperated invective against the Bush administration, who, in Spiegelman’s eyes, ruthlessly and shamefully hijacked 9/11 for all manner of political wrong-doing.

Certainly, there are instances where Spiegelman’s bitterness forces him into unfocussed, in-vogue Bush-bashing where he fails to address the more widespread personal suffering. Mostly, though, he has clearly maintained his enthralling ability to mix irony, rage, resignation and deep tragedy within the comic-book format.

Danny Graydon 10 September 04 rating of 4 and 1/2
In The Shadow Of No Towers by Art Spiegelman, out now published by Viking.
Read members' comments.
  September 11, 2001
14 comments | last comment Oct 5, 2004

related info
note: The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites.
see also
mcsweeney's 13:
the comics issue

joe sacco
interview feature


art archive
Watch artist interviews and see images from British exhibitions.
radio 4
radio 4

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy