Comments for http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html en-gb 30 Sat 12 Jul 2014 21:01:30 GMT+1 A feed of user comments from the page found at http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html M Charlton http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=95#comment20 It looks like it is going to be the same again this year with Alonso. I think he is a one car team driver. It seems he can't get on with anyone as a team mate. As long as the other driver is way behind him that's ok with Alonso. I find him an arrogant man that has to be No1 in any walk of life. I pity Massa this year as he didn't show his best last year and all I can think of is he was bullied into being the second driver and let the No1 driver pass or else. Tue 01 Feb 2011 16:02:20 GMT+1 MGUK82 http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=90#comment19 Good to see another Brit on the grid but still hope Hulk can get a seat somewhere. Mon 31 Jan 2011 14:52:06 GMT+1 Ross Quinn http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=85#comment18 Andy RAC. Wow it is only Force India, who Ferrari stole a driver off the other season and have improved from 10th to 9th to 7th in their years in the sport.Also how many top current drivers started in the big teamsSeb - Sauber, Toro Rosso and Red BullMark - Minardi, Jaguar, Williams and Red BullLewis - McLarenJenson - Williams, Bennetton, Renault, BAR, Honda, Brawn and McLarenFernando - Minardi, Renault, McLaren, Renault & FerrariFelipe - Sauber, Ferrari (test), Sauber & FerrariScummy - Bennetton, Ferrari, Ferrari (test) & MercedesNico - Williams & MercedesRob - Renault (test), Sauber & RenaultVitaly - RenaultSo only two of the current drivers are at the one team throughout their career. The others have moved about and worked their way up and two of the top 6 started their careers at the 'joke' (I always liked them even if others didn't) Minardi. Fri 28 Jan 2011 21:34:35 GMT+1 Paul Baker http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=80#comment17 So pleased to hear the recent news about Paul Di Resta.Personally I think he'll do well as Friday practices in 2010 he did a good job. Also, he has a fab surname for an F1 driver - Di Resta. Keep saying to yourself and it just sounds better and better. I shall be watching his progress throughout the 2011 season. 7 weeks until 2011 season gets underway. Its been a quite a wait! Thu 27 Jan 2011 16:54:11 GMT+1 livpoksoc http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=76#comment16 Sorry, why are we all surprised by the whole sponsorship thing? We all know he was racing for Mercedes in DTM & we all know Force India race with Merc engines...so it is sponsorship & they've not lied...they have said it is because of the Merc tie in too.As for Liuzzi, he has had 2 stints in F1 and only had minor flashes of talent, still not up to match that of his peers. It is a shame that a contract hasn't been honoured but you have to consider this for Force India's POV, they slipped last season after losing a solid driver in Fisichella in 2009 & they need to move forward, Vijay cannot continue to pump money into a team now 6 years old if he's collecting the scraps at the end of the season!He needs quick drivers & he needs all the money he can save to run that team. It's a no brainer to settle with Liuzzi & replace him, also good for Merc to retain Hulkenberg too.As for DiResta needing a good seat for next year, there's a certain German Driver only contracted to Mercedes GP until the end of 2012 & a certain British driver only contracted at McLaren for the same period (yes McLarens engine deal ends in 2015 but that's still 2 years running with a front running team who supplies there engines).As for other drivers getting into F1, this is not a shame thing because there are very few drivers who get in without bringing something to the table in the past/present:Alonso - SantanderVettel - Red Bull (has been part of the Red Bull young driver program & tested for Sauber when Red Bull were sponsors)Button - Head & Shoulders, VodafoneLewis - TAG Heuer, VodafoneSchu - Deutsche weranbergatstungRosberg - SaboWebber - Yellow pagesMassa - Red Bull (originally)Petrov - LadaMaldano - Venezualan govt.All drivers have sponsorships, unless they happen to have £5m a year sat in the bank to pay for it themselves! It is F1, are we surprised?...should we be surprised?...No. Thu 27 Jan 2011 13:33:47 GMT+1 Bestyboy http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=71#comment15 @ No 8 - sorry to correct you, but, Di Resta was told specifically not to push too hard and crash the car, thats why he was generally a tenth or so slower, although on one occasion from the eight he drove he was actually quicker than Liuzzi, even with the "Do NOT bend the car!" orders.I think the general consensus of opinion is right, quick young driver, but would he have been given the chance in place of a contracted driver if he didnt have Mercedes backing ? - I dont think so.There's no doubt he belongs in F1 purely on talent, but so does Hulkenberg and look whats happened to him because he doesnt have a "sponsor". Personally, i think the likelyhood of Hulkenberg getting a race drive this year is high, he'll either replace Schumacher at Mercedes when he realises that it just isnt going to happen for him again, or replace Sutil at Force India when the team realise that he's just too inconsistent. I'll be watching Mr Di Resta with great interest to see how he goes. I have no doubt he'll show Sutil the way home a few times. Thu 27 Jan 2011 13:11:34 GMT+1 hackerjack http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=66#comment14 10. At 9:39pm on 26 Jan 2011, ShinyDavidHowell wrote:If the comments here are accurate, that's four sponsored rookies out of four in F1 this season.Forgive me for questioning the sport..-------------Don't be naive. Pretty much EVERY driver on the grid right now got their chance partly through sponsorship and partly through talent, none of them got there on pure speed alone.The quickest drivers have a better chance of attracting sponsors, which is how they can then afford to progress up the formulas in the first place. Hamilton was effectively sponsored by McLaren's PR machine because they really wanted a top Brit in the car, Alonso was sponsored by a bunch of companies that Flavio Briatore deals with as part of his stable of drivers as was Webber, Vettel was sponsred by the Red Bull driver program.The difference now from 15 years ago is drivers can no longer get there solely on sponsorship (HRT excepted), there has to be basic speed there as well. Also other than Hulkenberg (possibly Heidfeld but he's had is go) there really isn't anyone out there who is more talented and missing out. Thu 27 Jan 2011 07:39:33 GMT+1 Ginger http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=61#comment13 Good luck to him and the rest of the rookies, they will all need it especially with the changes in the aero and tyres. I suspect that Force India will be looking behind them this season not up the field.Shame they didn't get the win at Spa in 2009 and Kimi was allowed to take his slingshot approach to Eau Rouge! Thu 27 Jan 2011 00:22:11 GMT+1 matt-stone http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=57#comment12 If Di Resta is as good as Vettel and Hamilton have been, then we're in for a treat. Older drivers now need replacing in my view, not Alonso or Massa though, they're still in their prime, but Shumachker has seen his better days I think. Three Brits now fighting for the championship, can't be bad, though I don't know if Nigel Mansell thinks Di Resta is also manufactured like Hamilton and not natural ???? Thu 27 Jan 2011 00:21:52 GMT+1 Bart_E_Slartfast http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=52#comment11 It's good to see another Brit on the grid for 2011 but it's a shame we won't be able to discuss his progress amongst ourselves on 606. Wed 26 Jan 2011 23:29:48 GMT+1 smallvizier http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=47#comment10 I don't actually think sponsored drivers are intrinsically bad.In all sports, managers need to balance talent against its cost. Leeds fans could tell you a lot about losing control of salaries.Real Madrid buy superstars on huge wages, then make their money back on shirt sales. Ferrari are doing the same with Alonso: they pay him a lot, but they get a better deal from Santander with a Spaniard in their car."It's different," you cry, "Ferrari would admire Alonso even without Santander's sponsorship." But you know what? These rookies aren't talentless either. They've all seen success, whether in the junior formulae, or as test drivers. The 'extras' are really being used as tie-breakers:"I'll take *this* talented driver instead of *that* talented driver because of his sponsorship."It's about snapping up talented youngsters for pennies (like Arsenal), instead of paying a lot for established pros (Man City).You might wonder, if I think the teams are being reasonable, why I complained in comment #8 above. Well, what really gets me isn't the sponsorship, it's the double standards. Williams, Virgin and Sauber have been slated for hiring paid-for, talented unknowns instead of sticking with expensive, talented pros (their choice!). But the same media outlets are praising Force India for doing the same thing!I worry that we're giving di Resta an easy ride because he's British, he's familiar, he's called Paul instead of Pastor - and because his media manager (Hamilton's dad) gets on well with the reporters.Whatever you think of sponsorship, let's treat all the rookies the same, whether they're backed by Genii capital (Ambrosio) or Mercedes (di Resta). Wed 26 Jan 2011 23:06:56 GMT+1 ShinyDavidHowell http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=42#comment9 If the comments here are accurate, that's four sponsored rookies out of four in F1 this season.Forgive me for questioning the sport...Still, we'll see how he fares. Would love to see Liuzzi get back into F1 with another team and show Force India up for letting him go in a stitch-up. Wed 26 Jan 2011 21:39:22 GMT+1 hackerjack http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=38#comment8 What's all the not-sponsored rubbish? DiResta in a Mercedes protigee, who supplies engines to Force India again?He's a good driver and deserve his chance but dont try to pretend.He has his work cut out, first he needs to get near Sutil and consistently bring home the car, otherwise he could find himself out and Hulk in mid-season. If he can match or beat Sutil then he has a decent future ahead of him. Wed 26 Jan 2011 21:35:22 GMT+1 smallvizier http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=33#comment7 I'm a lot more worried by this than by the 'sponsored' drivers.The key differences here are- we already know he was slower than Liuzzi last year, in the same car- Liuzzi had a contract in place to race this year- Di Resta is backed by Force India's engine manufacturer.So it's sponsorship, but they're trying to hide it. Yay for less transparency! Yay for not honouring contracts!It seems to me that he's getting a free ride from the press (and the fans) because he's British. That's not right... Wed 26 Jan 2011 21:08:03 GMT+1 footballrevolution http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=28#comment6 It's good to see one of the middle order teams place so much faith with someone who is still, although well known, a new face to the formula one grid.The sports historic team traditions and values seem to be alive and well at Force India. Wed 26 Jan 2011 20:51:49 GMT+1 the real deal http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=23#comment5 Good to see another brit on the grid, hopefully he can do well and eventually get to show what hes made of in a team with a chance to win Wed 26 Jan 2011 16:53:11 GMT+1 Footula1 http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=19#comment4 Good to have another Brit on the grid, and even better he is Scottish. Hopefully see him work his way up through the ranks. Best of luck to him! Wed 26 Jan 2011 16:09:01 GMT+1 nibs http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=14#comment3 Di Resta recalled in a 2008 interview: "Sebastian was my team-mate in 2006. I definitely beat him on far more occasions than he ever beat me.I'm not saying that I'm a faster or better driver than him but you'd have to say there's at least parity between us."What the honourable gentleman doesn't tell us is that Vettel became Sauber's 3rd driver mid-season having to concentrate on f1 tests, Friday practices -topping them from the start-, flyaway races and pr from August onwards. Oh and that at the same time he took some part in the WSR championship of the same season winning on his debut.Also what the honourable gentleman doesn't tell us is that the season before with himself being one year more experienced and in a slightly better team he was thumped by Vettel who claimed best rookie. Wed 26 Jan 2011 15:55:13 GMT+1 AndyRAC http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=9#comment2 While I'm glad he's made it to F1 - it is only Force India. Would it have been better to stay in the DTM until a 'proper' seat came along? Probably not, there's nothing like seat time, and in the current era, with little testing, he's doing the right thing, hopefully. And with the backing of Mercedes/ Norbert Haug, he has the right backing. The boy is a talent - yet another in the family, following cousins Dario and Marino Franchitti. Wed 26 Jan 2011 15:31:04 GMT+1 DixieBean http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=4#comment1 Good to see Di Resta get a break and with a team that at times shows some great pace so I'm hopeful that he will deliver some string points finishes over the season. Shame Ant Davidson never quite got the same break but well done to PDR.If he can outpace Sutil then his stock will go up and I expect the Force India to be quite competitive with their Merc tie ins. Wed 26 Jan 2011 14:40:50 GMT+1 Ian P http://www.bbc.co.uk/blogs/sarahholt/2011/01/paul_di_resta_has_bumped.html?page=0#comment0 Great to see another talented young driver given a chance, albeit with a team that has had some significant difficulties in the past two years and may be in danger of slipping back down the field.Whilst it may be true that Paul diResta isn't paying for his drive per se, it is maybe slightly disengenuous to make it seem it's because he's just soooo good, when the might of ForceIndia's engine supplier, Mercedes-Benz is his backer. Who knows what deal has been done on engine costs, etc. to help oil the wheels of this move.However, you have to feel sorry for Tonio Luizzi, who despite having a race contract for 2011, has been dropped. What price a contract??? Wed 26 Jan 2011 14:33:27 GMT+1