Spill.com is my next go to. They mostly do podcasts and they have four reviewers who all have enough varying opinions that you get the full range of opinions of the film and can make an educated choice on whether or not you will like it. They have a really relaxed manner that is similar to yours and Simon's but they are from Austin.
Lastly (and probably the worst actual critic of my list) is Movie Bob of the Escapist Magazine (.com). He can let his own personal prejudices get in the way of his reviews but I still watch his stuff because he often has interesting things to say about the films he reviews and as a side show called The Big Picture where he can be really insightful about film (and some times comics and video games).