BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

2000 comments

user rating: 4 star

Sir David Beckham

International
by sportingpunter (U3362112) 06 March 2009
comment on the article

David Beckham seems to continue to polarise opinion but my admiration for him continues to grow. His willingness to dip in to his own pocket to pay for his Milan loan, purely to maximise his chances of repsenting England strikes a huge contrast with Ashley Cole being arrested for drunk and disorderly behaviour and swearing at police. Who would you prefer your kids to have as a role model?

Despite having the best cross from the right touchline I have ever seen in my life, he has continually been poorly treated by coaches in my view. Hoddle and Maclaren both unjustifiably dropped him from England and Capello did the same at Madrid. Yet each time, he just got his head down and forced his way back in by sheer performance and effort. We never had a sulk to the press, he always showed class.

Equally, he has never lived up to his celeb status on the pitch. He runs for ever, tracks back like a maniac, and he actually wants to play for England. Capello seems to have resolved the lack of effort problem but we could have done with a few more like him under Maclaren's reign.

Sure he has no speed but neither did Teddy Sheringham and he played on for years as well. The advantage of having no speed in the first place is that it hurts you less as you get old. The sad decline of Owen is the opposite case.

Why am I writing this? No idea other than I think praise is due here. If the criteria for a knighthood is honourable, committed, excellent, long performance for your country then Beckham should get one.


Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jun 12, 2009

in terms of createing your own luck

in individual sports totally- golf or snooker etc.

but not football.

in terms of a team battering a team that has parked a bus behind the gial line etc, and score by 3 deflections- then yes0 you have created your own luck.

when it is down to a ref judging instances how he sees it- NO YOU DO NOT CREATE YOUR OWN LUCK END OF story- never heard so much rubbish in all my life.

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

im bored, lets all laugh at the "best right foot in the world".

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ROvCTscV__s

oh, as if the portugual and france ones wernt enough, its so SATISFYING to see another "becks class of 2004" penalty kick. He should bring them all out on DVD, would be the comedy seller of the year.

------------

Ok your bored with this

is that why EVERY article you've ever written is about Beckham - nearly every comment you've ever posted is about Beckham - you not bored your obessed

And i kind find a youtube of Beckham scoring from the halfway line among other great goals - it wouldnt prove anything just like yours doenst mean anything

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

There is a lot of luck and the best team doesnt always win. Did Greece deserve to win the Euro? Didn't Holland deserve to win the World Cup in 74 and/or 78?

-----------

A team with better overrall quality can be beaten by a team using better or more suitable tactics - in a nutshell that is how Greece won Euro 2004. They weren't lucky as such, they just played spoiling tactics incredibly well and managed to take literally all of their chances.

It wasn't as though the referee was giving them dodgy decisions or their opponents suffered spates of injuries; Greece were just solid and their opponents had a series of off-days. I suppose that's lucky in a sense, but it's more good tactics tinged with luck in my opinion.

It's very hard for an inferior team to win PURELY based on luck, they need a good gameplan too, and that is what England lacked for me.

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

youre picking out ONE infamous mess up with those players finnaloid- none of them quite match the THREE consequetive penalty bottlers that your "becks" proved he had such a talent to hand us does it now?

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

Bit sad 5T
Did you also llaugh at Terry when he slipped taking that penalty last year? It happens.
And before you mention the one against Portugal, Beckham was the first to take a penalty in the shoot out and once the dodgy penalty spot was discovered every single other kick was taken to one side of the spot so the kicker didnt suffer the same problem.
If there are any genuine bad penalty kicks then I would be happy to acknowledge them.

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

i do agree we could have played better- but i believe we have conditioned ourselves into believeing we wernt good enough to win any of these cups,(when stast will tell you , the fact we only go out by pen shoot outs, all it takes is a filp off the coin a couple of times and we have won something) coz it makes us feel not cheated.

i think is a middle ground to be honest

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

when it is down to a ref judging instances how he sees it- NO YOU DO NOT CREATE YOUR OWN LUCK END OF story- never heard so much rubbish in all my life.

-------------

Let me draw you a picture:

The more a team forces the referee to make decisions (penalties, lbw's etc) the more chance there is of the referee getting one of them wrong.

Better teams get into better attacking positions, force the defending team to make more last ditch tackles and as such will statistically win more incorrect decisions from referees.

This is incredibly simple stuff, and has been accepted as near fact for many years, with the examples of Man United and Australia being the two most often-cited examples.

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

And before you mention the one against Portugal

How about the one against France in the same tournament? Or the poor one down the middle that he got away with V Argentina in 2002?

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

fillery
As I said, show me a bad one and I will acknowledge it.
A lot of people say great save by Bathez, but it was not a good kick - well hit with pace but at a saveable height. Still took a good save to get to it though.
And yes, the one v Argentina was lucky

complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2009

Those penalty foul-ups represented everything Beckham had turned himself into by that point. 2004 should finally have been his delivery year but he was nothing less than a complete clown.

complain about this comment

This article has now been closed to comments. Please visit another 606 thread or start a new one to continue the debate elsewhere.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 66.09%
    76 votes
  • 4 3.48%
    4 votes
  • 3 .87%
    1 votes
  • 2 .87%
    1 votes
  • 1 28.70%
    33 votes

average rating:
3.77 from 115 votes