BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

47 comments

user rating: 4 star

The maligned men

Championship QPR
comment on the article

After disappointing home results against Watford and Burnley, Paulo Sousa’s honeymoon period might be coming to an end.

Sousa has impressed me since taking over as coach, but it is his good fortune that Flavio Briatore was not at recent matches.

As Sousa’s predecessors – and that includes Gareth Ainsworth – have discovered, just one poor home performance in front of Briatore and friends is enough to turn the tide against the coach.

Another disappointment against Coventry this weekend and Sousa will be under pressure, just as Gigi De Canio and Iain Dowie were just weeks after being appointed.

Rangers have stuttered in recent games and some players are struggling more than others.

Peter Ramage hasn’t had the best of starts to his Rangers career and is now in danger of losing his place at right-back to Matt Connolly.

Ramage is a good lad, but for me the question ever since his move from Newcastle has been whether his plodding, unspectacular style, which helped him do a solid job for his hometown team, could be transferred to a very different club in the south.

Based on his first half-season at QPR, the answer is perhaps no.

For Newcastle – in a higher division – he had the look of a keen, honest young defender who lacked finesse but was dependable and could hold his own.

But playing in the same style for Rangers, he has looked slow and short of quality. He’s in different territory now.

Ramage is a better player than he has shown so far, and a better centre-back than right-back despite stating that he prefers the latter position.

The problem for Ramage is that there are still better centre-backs at the club, including Connolly, and there are also better right-backs - again including Connolly.

So while injuries and suspensions could yet lead to Ramage doing a job for Rangers at centre-back, at the moment he doesn’t warrant a place in the side.

Ramage is a good player, despite his poor form, but Connolly deserves a run at right-back and looks like he’s going to get one.

Damien Delaney is another much-maligned player this season. He has done well for Rangers in the past and still has the support of Sousa, who prefers him to Gary Borrowdale.

Borrowdale's permanent move was agreed when the initial loan deal went through, so Rangers had no choice but to sign him when the transfer window opened despite the fact that he is not Sousa's choice.

The loan was agreed before Sousa's appointment and the signing has understandably been linked by some to Dowie, who signed Borrowdale for Coventry and also knew him from his Crystal Palace days.

In fact the player was on QPR's radar even before Dowie took the QPR job.

De Canio's staff went to watch Borrowdale and Rangers made enquiries about him and Sheffield Wednesday's Tommy Spurr but could not agree a fee and eventually signed Delaney, who started well but has not been as impressive this season.

Gavin Mahon also has his critics.

I much prefer the less reliable but more mobile and dynamic Mikele Leigertwood, who may well get the nod ahead of Mahon against Coventry as Rangers look to tempt one of the clubs currently keeping tabs on Leigertwood to table a bid.

Leigertwood will be allowed to leave if an offer of around £1m comes in and another midfielder can be signed – especially now Damiano Tomassi’s departure, which had been on the cards, has been confirmed and Adam Bolder remains likely to join Millwall.

Tottenham’s Hossam Ghaly has been lined up as a possible signing but the more likely acquisition is Liam Miller.

Sunderland are willing to let Miller go and Rangers will begin talks to try and seal his signing early next week.

Regardless of who comes in, getting rid of Leigertwood would be a mistake, but Mahon is a good pro who knows the game and does a steady job for the team.

If Damion Stewart wins the player of the year award, he ought to thank Mahon in his acceptance speech because he is the main reason for the plaudits Stewart has received this season.

With Mahon constantly screening the centre of the defence, plus the absence of attacking full-backs, Stewart has been able to tackle and head his way through the season without being exposed.

More attacking full-backs or no midfielder sitting in front of him would require Stewart to read the game and make more decisions.

Stewart has won much praise of late and Mahon very little, but take Mahon out and Stewart’s time as flavour of the month would come to an abrupt end.

Another player who has struggled to convince is Samuel Di Carmine.

Like Dani Parejo, there are reasons not to like Di Carmine that are nothing to do with him or his ability as a player. Unfortunately for him, he has become a symbol of Briatore’s involvement in team affairs.

If, like Parejo, Di Carmine’s loan spell is cut short - which seems increasingly likely to happen - I suspect that, as with Parejo, few will be sorry to see him go.

As a player, I actually quite rate Di Carmine. He’s subtle, and I like that.

As I’ve said previously about him, regardless of his weaknesses the thing to watch out for with Di Carmine is how rarely he is marked.

If he plays for Rangers again, notice how time and time again he isn’t being picked up by a defender.

It’s his main strength. He moves across defenders and is constantly looking to pick up space. He’s very clever in the way he quietly gives defenders the slip and this is a great attribute for such a young forward to have.

He’s a typical Italian striker – a drifter - so will always attract criticism here because he will often seem to fade from games.

But he isn’t a goal threat, and other aspects of his game aren’t good enough for regular Championship football.

If he was QPR’s own player, he’d be well worth keeping and trying to develop. But he isn’t, and the best thing for both parties is that he goes back to Fiorentina sooner rather than later.

Angelo Balanta, Rangers’ own player, has serious potential and is already more developed than Di Carmine. He should be given a chance instead.

But one youngster I most definitely do not want to see go is Emmanuel Ledesma.

At most other clubs, a great start by a teenager on loan in a foreign country would be played down at every opportunity.

Good old Rangers, true to form and clearly learning nothing from the Nicky Ward debacle, did the opposite.

They even brought out a T-shirt of Ledesma and his “legendary” (after a handful of games!) celebration. His form inevitably then dipped.

Ledesma isn’t as good as he was cracked up to be at the start of the season and he isn’t as bad as he has seemed since.

He is the same prospect that showed such brilliant skill and charisma in August. He’s a terrific young player, with exceptional balance and ability, and Rangers should be as keen to sign him permanently now as they were initially.

Ledesma prefers playing on the right flank and it’s by far his best position.

He’ll slip further down the pecking order now Wayne Routledge has arrived to play there, and I expect the new man to be a huge hit and immediately become a crowd favourite. At Championship level, Routledge is a very exciting player.

But given the choice of paying £500,000 for Routledge or developing the potentially much better Ledesma, I know what I’d do.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jan 9, 2009

Number8 you do indeed say it how you see it...that is your opinion, like David M's opinion.

But, why does Flav have to prove anything to you, personally? I only ask because you say it so often, 'what has FLav done to prove me wrong so far'. Does Falv care about you, personally? No. What has Flav done so drastically wrong to make you, and, you call him respected I will call him plain old Daivd M, continue with this boring tirade of hate?

You becoming ever so slightly boring. Are you someone who goes to games but spends there time moaning and booing?

And please, dont start refering to ticket prices...lets hear a reason, something maybe with some hard evidence mr plod that actually makes sense for once.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 9, 2009

Guys,guys!! We're all meant to be on the same side here.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 9, 2009

Just because we are QPR fans does not mean we have to all get along and agree with each other. Im sure we all want success for QPR, but the way some people go on is sad, vary sad.

In truth, it just makes me laugh...and not with them.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 9, 2009

Wow! I've only just had a chance to read this thread.

Thorough article from David M - whether you agree or not, like it or not.

Thorough and varied comments from all my fellow 606-ers.

Personally, I think that the activities of the last few weeks has shown that Briatore has quite happily handed over control of the team & squad to Sousa. I.e. the return early of Parejo to Madrid and the cancellation of Tomassi's contract today.

I would not like to see Legs go unless he is replaced by someone of superior quality. With Big Dave's training ground injury this week going to surgery, I am not convinced that the Club wont go looking for another striker, after all - least ways, I hope so!

Sammy Di Carmine is intriguing - but maybe we just dont have the time to develop him, particularly if we're not going to keep him!

I have faith in Ledesma - but it's rumoured he's going back to Italy at the end of his contract. Shame, really. And alot of you seem to forget that he was injured for a while - that may not have helped his confidence, etc.

I think Ramage is a good defender - not played in the right position, but nevertheless an honest bloke who has not been our worst player this season, imo. Delaney . . . there's another story. Why has he gone so terribly off the boil? Or was it a false dawn under LDC last season?

We've all got our opinions - if you're reading this paragraph, you'll just have read mine! We can all express those opinions - and shouldn't get pilloried for doing so. Coz at the end of the day, all of us have one important thing in common - we love QPR and cant wait to see them succeed and get promotion.

So how bout we all exchange our opinions now and then, tomorrow, we all cheer & sing loudly - encourage players who aren't doing so well - and generally SUPPORT our team to help them get those all important 3 points!!

How about it?!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 9, 2009

82 Hoops.I get behind my team as passionatly as the next man and as Sandy crrectly states,i only want the best for my team.

I can also state that in 29 years of following QPR,i have never, repeat never booed my team or any player once.

In the hard financial times thugh i will not tolerate any player giving less than 100% for the over inflated wages they are on.

I think that is fair.

Also Flavio has proved how little he knows about football by his,yes his signings for the club.

NAME ONE SUCCESS STORY.
2 have departed with probably the others to follow.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 10, 2009

Akos Buzsaky

But I have no doubt, number8, that you will put that down to someone elses credit.

It seems all the "poor" signings are Flavs and the good ones someone elses. You can't have it all ways #8.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 10, 2009

no8 - NAME ONE SUCCESS STORY
-----------------------------------------

I have to say that I too am very sceptical about Flav's interest in the club, the spin we've been relentlessly fed, the misleading remarks about ticket prices (before they were ramped up extortionately), imposing players on managers and so on.

I have no way of really knowing, but I get the impression he has reigned back a little in recent weeks, especially after the allegations that he was picking the team (and even named more than 11 players to start!).

There have been PR disasters, lack of consideration of fans and general balls-ups, but name a success story - that's easy. In fact here are three...

He and Bernie did save the club; last January's signings; major sponsorship deals.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 10, 2009

When Ledesma arrived we had the option to sign him for 3m euros. At the time that translated to £2.2m approx. For that sort of money you need to get a fantastic game winning Championship midfielder.
The way the exchange rate has moved that fee is now nearer £2.8m. Ledesma has not done enough to justify nor shown enough potential to justify that size of fee, however promising.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 11, 2009

#8.. Name one success story...
Turning us from an 11th hour administration, relegation bound club into a top half championship club in 12 months!!!
That's not a bad start.
But for me.. so far our best signing has been Paulo Sousa! At last a young manager with vision, dedication, commitment, attention to detail, professionalism.
That to me is a huge success; and the best is yet to come as he gets to grips with the British game, and the rigours of the Championship itself!
There's no doubt that Flav has made his mistakes, but the way you pillory him solely is wrong in my opinion!
Let any man who has never made a mistake by all means criticise others! Flav is without doubt a successful businessman, that will translate into success for QPR. I don't know what will happen then, but this is far better than all fans have endured for the last 10 years!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 17, 2009

I want to throw my two cents in. As a group of message boarders we were all tremendously optimistic and togther in regards to the future even with Dowie at the helm. Number 8 and David M seems to want to rock this unity.

For some reason and whether this is just those who have a cynical side to them but there is this need for doom and disaster. We just won against Derby away, 8th in the league and a few points from being in the play-offs. Play-offs being a very important milestone for our development as a club.

It looks like David M's writing patterns have changed from insightful in's of QPR to an external portrayal of a need to criticize a club that he "supports". I get upset when our so called "supporters" do not support their club and in cicumstances boo... quite disgusting. These owners are putting their hands in their pockets now and in the future... Rome was not build in a day! The improvements to the stadium have not been seen since Jim Gregory revamped LR... who would have thought we would see a big screen at QPR.

We're experimenting with players and we are being shrewd, with a sensible application of evolution and splashing money.

I would like to see David M become involved again inside the R's and have some articles about the academy design, next phase of LR... rather than knocking the playing staff and feeling we need to know his thoughts on four key players of the R's squad!

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 83.33%
    5 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 16.67%
    1 votes

average rating:
4.33 from 6 votes