BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

920 comments

user rating: 4 star

To boo or not to boo?

International England
comment on the article

The world has booed its stage performers since the actors of ancient Greece and Roman gladiators fluffed their lines and dallied with whimpering lions.

You pay your money, you’re unhappy with the entertainment, so you hiss and boo. You’ve got a right to express your disapproval haven’t you?

Haven’t you?

Unless his missus had Girls Aloud pumping out of the kitchen this morning, Ashley Cole will have woken up with the taunts of England’s more vociferous supporters still ringing in his ears.

The Chelsea left back was in action at Wembley on Saturday. England may have scored five against lowly Kazakhstan, but it was Cole's blunder that led to the visitors’ only goal.

The England fans had been under strict instructions to get behind their team by manager Fabio Capello, but after Cole’s error some decided to jeer his every move.

England stand-in skipper Rio Ferdinand said those responsible should "be ashamed of themselves", while the Italian boss couldn’t understand it, saying it was “very important that the crowd help him and not boo him.”

Having scanned the 606 messageboards, it seems most, but certainly not all, punters are against Cole’s treatment.

“It just frustrates me when the crowd boo England, who is that going to help? It just heaps more pressure on the players and gives us even less of a chance of scoring,” 606 user LedleyKingofthelane said.

Another 606 punter taxidriver called booing the national team “a heinous crime” and said guilty fans “should be dealt with as aggressively as rioting.”

Perhaps the likes of Ferdinand and Capello are simply oblivious to the resentment felt in some corners of the football terraces – sorry stadia – across the country towards a player like Cole.

Controversy and strong opinion have followed him everywhere - his move to Chelsea and more recently his behaviour towards referee Mike Riley when booked against Spurs in March - have hardly boosted his PR campaign.

Would Rooney, Walcott, or even David James have received such a negative reception from the England fans had they made a similarly-sized clanger as Cole’s? I think not.

Can booing a sport star be ever justified? Fulham boss Roy Hogdson doesn’t think so and is “sad” about the increasing trend of fans venting their spleen.

Some football managers have come out recently with slightly different views.

Three weeks ago Birmingham lost to Blackpool and the fans let the players know exactly how they felt. Their manager’s response? “If I was a supporter I’d have booed as well,” Alex McLeish said.

Should anyone paying for a ticket to watch a sport or stage performance, have a free licence to express their opinions?

Everton crashed out of the Carling Cup to Blackburn recently and the vitriol followed. The losing manager David Moyes said: “The fans were entitled to their boos because we didn’t play well.”

Football Supporters' Federation international co-ordinator Kevin Miles was at Wembley and while he admitted it was only a minority booing Cole, he said: “There are two sides to it; people have obviously paid their money and have every right to express their opinion.”

This view has also got its fair share of support on 606.

“You can't eject people for having an opinion, they have paid their money, so who are we to tell them they can't boo the England side if they wish?” said user saintsince65.

While punter slyadams said fans had spent “a load of money following England around and have been served up a load of dross over the last few years. Their only real way of demonstrating their discontent is through either not going to games or booing.”

And booing in sport is not just something restricted to the football arena.

In the gentlemanly world of snooker, Ronnie O’Sullivan was on the wrong end of some booing at the Grand Prix three years ago. Some of the petrolheads even got in on the act this summer after booing Aussie Casie Stoner when he won the British MotoGP.

Last Christmas England’s cricketers will have been choking on their turkey after being booed for their poor showing in Sri Lanka three days before.

Alastair Cook said: "They're passionate cricket fans and they're entitled to have a go. They have travelled a long way to come here and they like to see us doing well.”

Even England skipper Michael Vaughan, after his team were booed off the field in Barbados last year, said: "I've been a supporter in a stadium, watched football teams that haven't produced, and done exactly the same.”

So should anyone paying for a ticket to watch a sport or stage performance have a free licence to express their opinions?

In theatre circles booing has been recently deemed unkind, demonstrating a lack of sophistication. But perhaps expressing disapproval could lead to improved players’ performances?

From the views expressed so far since the England players walked off the Wembley turf on Saturday night, it seems the nation is divided. Give us your thoughts.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Oct 13, 2008

I think most people are right that yes you do pay a lot for a ticket and have every right to boo whoever makes a right clanger like Cole did. I think where the problem lies is that they were prepared to boo him all match which can't be good for the team moral.
Yeah boo him for a bit but not for the rest of the match. That's why some people were clapping so they drowned out the boo boys. You can't drown the spirit of the team because of one player making a mistake. There were 10 other players on the pitch who would have been suffering too and it wasn't fair on them.
If something goes wrong with anything in life then you are entitled to complain but you wouldn't keep going back everytime to complain about the same thing. Would you?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 13, 2008

Do the neanderthal "fans" who boo think that a player who makes a mistake is going to play better when the crowd gets on their back?

No, they just want to jeer the very players they paid to support.

Why do teams play better at home than away? Simple, because encouragement (from the home crowd) creates confidence which improves performance.

If we want our boys to play well we need to cheer them on. The boo-boys just want to vent their frustration even if it means that ultimately the team play worse - then complain how bad their team is. That's the definition of stupidity.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 13, 2008

As a graduate Engineer, from a top University, who earns half, in a year, of what Ashley Cole rejected as a derisory weekly wage at Arsenal, I have no respect for the man whatsoever. In fact, I despise him utterly. Not only that, but he and his equally deluded, and self obsessed colleagues, seem to think that they are entitled to behave in a way that would not be tolerated in any other sport, let alone any other walk of life. With the exception of Steven Gerrard, they are mediocre in the extreme. After the Euro's debacle, I can no longer take any great interest in the England football team; I was actually wrapping Christmas presents while the latest dross was on; but watching the professionalism, personal pride, physical effort, determination, patriotism and sheer courage of our Olympians and Paralympians, has made me realise what a complete bunch of posing, uneducated, arrogant, overated neanderthals our 'premier' footballers are. All the time they view everyone else with contempt, they deserve all the boos they get.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 13, 2008

How about these so-called world class footballers grow a set. They are all overpaid, soft and mentally weak, which is the reason they crumble under the slightest pressure.

If you get paid astronomical wages, be prepared to accept astronomical pressure. You can't get one without the other, although on current evidence, it seems you can with the right agent.

Cole wasn't necessarily just booed because of the mistake - everything the public has seen of him sets him up in a negative light. He's made a poor image for himself through his poor decisions, and when someone like that, who courts media attention openly, makes a huge error, the vast majority of people will delight in that fact.

I'm proud to be English, but I don't care about this England team at all. How can I relate to any of them? I can never afford to go to a game, the only time you see them in public is when they've got a book to promote, and forget the Premier League.

Do you think Norman Hunter would have complained about a few boos? Ron Harris? Stuart Pearce? The best players are just that despite the outside influences of the crowd, because they have the mental strength and self belief to cope.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 14, 2008

I think booing at the act is fine but continuing it was not right. Does nobody seem to consider our stagnant captain pointing for the ball to be played back by Cole. Then not moving to cover a possible mistake, when do you think he came out in support of Cole straight after the game. If he is going to offer advice on the field for a player to pass back then he must not stand still and not cover a possible mistake. The funny thing is as an after thought he then runs towards the the attacking player. Please can Terry be fit soon, I am not a Chelsea fan but I can see that even with a bad back he is better than Ferdinand.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by fgrmont (U9780202)

posted Oct 14, 2008

Ashley Cole like many players are paid hundreds of thousands of pounds per year to play a simple game of football, when they make basic mistakes like putting the ball in toward your own penalty area (something we were taught at school not to do) with disastrous results they must pay the price.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 14, 2008

danny like most United fans you have a blinkered view and probally don't live anywhere near Manchester. Plus the fact you probally only really started supporting them 10 odd years ago. Open your eyes, he is a good player but not that good, thanks for the insult shows your mentality and knowledge of the game. Hope you don't cry to much when £600 million worth of debt and Ronaldo leaving in the Summer comes to haunt you.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 15, 2008

HalesVillian (U7664277)

To be perfectly honest i do live in manchester,

Stretford to be excact,

So Don't pull that one out,

Been United Fan for more than 20years,

Yeah we might have £600 million worth of debt and yeah Real might be chasing Ronnie again,

But to be honest i don't care shows how much mentallity of the game i have . . . . .

Your the one who is Trying to give grief to a United fan even though this aint anything to do with United its actualy England and Cashly cole,

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article


RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 57.35%
    39 votes
  • 4 7.35%
    5 votes
  • 3 8.82%
    6 votes
  • 2 2.94%
    2 votes
  • 1 23.53%
    16 votes

average rating:
3.72 from 68 votes