BBC Home

Explore the BBC

121 comments

user rating: 4 star

CLICHY

Premier League Arsenal
by ubadgunner (U7811550) 20 September 2008
comment on the article

Let all pray Clichy is not badly injured.

We are already paper thin squad strength wise

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Sep 22, 2008

Both Shearer and Lawerson said fair tackle

___________

Who is Lawerson, I've never heard of him.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

Some of the comments from Arsenal supporters defy belief.
Organised thuggery? Do not expect that Man U, Chelsea or Liverpool will allow you to pass the ball around unchallenged. Ferdinand, Vidic, Neville, Terry Mikel, Cole, Carragher
do I need to go on
expect tackes - it's part of the game.
7 pm Saturday nights BBC could be the place for you lot.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

Torotter4Now - your comments defy belief. Move on from the dark ages pal, certain tackles are not allowed simple as.

There is no pigskin and ankle high boots anymore. The Cold War has ended and we even managed to put men on the moon.

Aggressive tackles are outlawed, its one thing being committed for a tackle, thats fair play, but going in studs up is NOT allowed, hence Clichy's injury. He is a committed tackler and never pulls out of tackles, considering how slight he is, but he rarely gets injured, considering the number of games he plays.

I won't say Davies is a dirty player, I like him, but in this instance his tackle was over the top. Bolton are a bunch of dirty baskets, everybody knows.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

Looking over the tackle I do think Davies has been a little bit hard done by. Although he did have studs showing which is very dangerous and the way Clichy's leg was, it could have been a very bad situation. After making a challenge his foot goes over the ball and catches Clichy high. The vast majority of players are honest and are never going to look to break a fellow professional's leg. If he had done he would have felt extremely guilty.

His tackle was nothing like Guthrie's or anything, it wasn't assult. As far as I'm aware Clichy only seems to have bruising so I'm not going to overreact, it could have been a lot worse, both the tackle and the injury.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by Mortrid (U7371713)

posted Sep 22, 2008

I for one couldnt care less about the amount of English players in the Arsenal squad. Homegrown players who have come through the academy, yes, I would love to see more of them.. but it doesnt matter to me whether they are English or not. What makes me laugh is that poeple have been saying its teams like Arsenal's fault England are not very good, and evidently its true! As soon as an Arsenal player plays for England, they do well lol! But seriously, get over this whole English thing. We live in a multiculturalist society, with different values to those of 100, or even 20 years ago. If the Arsenal produced a fantastic academy player who was say... Spanish... would that make him any less of an Arsenal player than an English one?

On the subject of the post, studs up is NOT allowed according to the rules of the PROFESSIONAL game, I don't care what you do at the weekends.

Best wishes to Mr. Clichy, and I hope he recovers soon.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

I was interested in the first comment, that the lack of English players reflects the fact that football is not played in schools any more. I think that's right, and the Inner London Education Authority banned competitive sports if I remember rightly.

It's sad. And it ends up in the kind of view you get from someone like Mortrid, who doesn't care whether the players come from as long as his team wins.

In the old days, football clubs were linked to the community and in some parts of the world, and even in England, this is still the case. To me. it's sad that Arsenal don't have English players and that the fans are becoming $ky watchers, often living in places like Eastbourne, who care only about winning and nothing about the club as part of a community.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

The lack of english players reflects the increase in standards as the money in the EPL has gone up. Many of the Championship players would be getting a game in the EPL fifteen years ago.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

Laqlouq - why oh why oh why ???

Having gone to a school in the ILEA district I can tell you that until they (the ILEA) were abolished, there was no ban on competitive sports cos I played football for my school team to the 5th year and borough games were still being played too.

Whilst I agree with you that individuals 'should' have a connection with their local team often this is not the case - otherwise EVERYBODY in Islington would support Arsenal, Everybody north of Manor House would support Tottenham and everybody East of Walthamstow would support Leyton Orient. How boring would it be if everyone in your school for example supported the same team !

Some people, like myself, move from the area they were born and raised in, Eastbourne Gooner probably grew up in North London and moved away for work or family reasons. Your argument is so badly flawed that I can't see how you even thought of it as a sensible one <doh>.

I suggest you stay on your medication for a while cos it aint working.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 22, 2008

Some people, like myself, move from the area they were born and raised in, Eastbourne Gooner probably grew up in North London and moved away for work or family reasons.

____________________

Yes, I did grow up in north London, near Finsbury Park. Gradually moved south, and ended up here through work. <ok>

That anally retentive dumb plank probably has never been to a game in his life.

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 62.50%
    10 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 37.50%
    6 votes

average rating:
3.50 from 16 votes