BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

43 comments

user rating: 4 star

Evans can wait

Tour de France
comment on the article
Cadel Evans

Well, at least Spain’s Carlos Sastre attacked on the Alpe d’Huez, and like someone in his bedroom guarding his jewellery against burglars, Cadel Evans had his TV and DVD player nicked from the room next door.

Hats off to the Schleck brothers, Andy and Frank, for their selfless action in following team orders, but did Team CSC miss a trick in not sending the Spaniard away earlier?

If Sastre had attacked on the Croix De Fer, could he have established enough of an advantage to make Saturday’s time trial all but an irrelevance?

They didn't, he didn't, and instead we have the same question that has been hanging over the Tour for what seems like several weeks now: how much time can Evans take out of the rest against the clock?

The other question, which seems to have been attracting some debate on 606, is whether or not it would be a good thing if a ‘wheel-sucker’ (their words not mine) won the Tour. Whatever you think of Cadel, and he's been a taciturn, tetchy sort of bloke recently, the object of the Tour de France is to complete the course faster than anyone else, which he seems set to do.

When I was a young reporter working in the north east of England, our great athletics hero was Brendan Foster. He raced in the best possible way, attacking and attacking, trying to thin out the field so that no-one could use their kick-finish to beat him.

His bete noir was a policeman from Finland called Lasse Viren. Viren would sit on Brendan’s shoulder until the last possible moment, then just race past him and take the gold medal. We all thought that was a little unfair. Viren, by the way, also used to replace his blood after training at high altitude in order to give him an advantage.

You didn't get much high altitude if you were a Chemistry Teacher from Hebburn on Tyne, like Foster.

I do find Evans dull to watch. I've been impressed by plenty of other riders though. From the ever-optimistic escape artists like Sylvain Chavanel and Stefan Schumacher, to the marvellous Thomas Voeckler and those Schleck boys, there have been heroes enough on the Tour.

On the roadside we've had the lot; Basques and men in basques on Hautacam, two Elvises and a flock of wizards in the Alps, the mobile disco on Dutchman’s bend and half the population of Luxembourg cheering on their three amigos: there's been plenty of colour and passion.

It’s not over yet either. Thunderstorms forecast on Saturday mean that the time trial isn't a foregone conclusion, but ‘wheelsucker’ or not, the one word on everyone’s lips when asked for winner is Evans. We wait to see.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jul 25, 2008

If ever an article was written tongue in cheek to get a rise from our Aussie friends surely this one was! Us English love our little wind ups don't we?!

Everyone knows that when your the favourite in the TdF and isolated you are super vunerable and the only thing you can do is defend.
Evans seems to have lost his team from day 1 and been vunerable all the time, he's had a bad crash.
And yet what an awesome performance - in the context of how other legends performed when completely isolated - I have never seen better riding for the GC in the modern era.

I am now a big fan - every time I've seen Evans on decisive mountains he has been able to control.

What was that rubbish about the Croix de Feur? Did CSC not try and break him up it - I think so. Driving the pace and falling away. Look at the time gap with 3.5Km to go on the Alpe and tell me Evans didn't turn himself inside out getting up to limit his loss. All the time he had riders putting their rear wheel in his way to try and break his rhythm yet he looks like he'll do it Saturday.

GO CADEL!!!!

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by Froggy (U10436677)

posted Jul 25, 2008

I agree.
Evans deserves a better team.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by flyscot (U2120886)

posted Jul 25, 2008

Beethoven's Left..

Not Strine, a Scot; the Poms begin at Berwick, you know.
I think most of the useful arguments pro and con Evans have been aired. Interesting discussion. In Canada, we're fed the U.S. gospel on the Tour, and most of those commentators do glorify Team CSC (when they're not going on about Columbia or Garmin).
and in extolling the strengths of CSC, they tend to dwell upon, in what I consider an unseemly way, the gang-up tactics used to thwart any challenge to that tem's star du jour.
And returning to wheel sucking, thanks for the clarification from you experts. Tell me, it may not happen, but if Evans makes up the two minutes on Kohl in the time trial tomorrow, will that too be derided, or will some of the sceptical side be persuaded out of your "boredom".
Just because Evans is no sweetheart does not take away from his being the most complete rider...this year. qed.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 25, 2008

comment by AdelaideScot (U12750798)
posted Yesterday"
Okay, for all you people out there who appear to know nothing about cycling, I have one name: Miguel Indurain."

And Miguel responding to attack after attack by all the climbers in the 1992 Giro d'Italia was one of the most exciting races I've ever seen.

Armstrong's 2003 Tour win was a similar thriller.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 26, 2008

Cadel Evans isn't exactly Mr personality but you've got to give him respect in that his team has been non-existent and he has had to fight all the way against tremendous odds, CSC are so strong but they couldn't quite kill him off on the Alpe. A worthy a champion if he wins the time trial on saturday but for me this tour has been about Cavendish and putting whats been a brilliant year for british track and road cycling. Bring on the Olympics.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by flyscot (U2120886)

posted Jul 26, 2008

Oops; re my post yesterday. It's unlikely Evans will pass Kohl on the road...since he starts before him! Apologies; just over-developing the argument. It should be a great day. Best man and all that........

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 26, 2008

In the words of the Dutch tv commentator just now 'trying hard isn't the same as wanting to win'. Evans doesn't want to win, he just tries unbelievably hard not to lose. In the words of the article: 'like someone in his bedroom guarding his jewellery against burglars, Cadel Evans had his TV and DVD player nicked from the room next door'. That might sound reasonable on paper, but it's no way to win a Tour.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 26, 2008

Oh well, most of the posters in the anti-Cadel brigade must be happy that normal service DID NOT resume, and a combination of an indifferent ride by Evans and a decent ride by Sastre means he gets to keep the yellow and win the Tour. applause Fair dues to him, although as a Cadel-supporter, I'm a bit sad for the Aussie battler.

As ever, it never ceases to amaze me about this race...you ride for 21 days, and in the end the difference at the top is little more than 1 minute. Does my head in. biggrin

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 26, 2008


Wow, I'm happy with the results today but am really amazed Evans didn't have a good run today. 7th place when the yellow jersey was up for grabs? Very happy for Sastre though, he seemed to have found the right gear and put on a heroic performance when it counted most.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by wombat2 (U3296764)

posted Jul 27, 2008

I'm sick of theSpanish: first the French Open then Wimbledon then the European Cup and now this final insult theTde F.
If Sastre falls of his bike and does not finish the final leg in Paris does it mean he does not win the Tde F?

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 40.00%
    2 votes
  • 4 20.00%
    1 votes
  • 3 20.00%
    1 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 20.00%
    1 votes

average rating:
3.60 from 5 votes