BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in
Browse: Cycling

39 comments

user rating: not rated yet

Needle and the damage done...

comment on the article

It's an old Neil Young song, and I was thinking about it as the news of Riccardo Ricco's positive test for EPO surfaced on the road into Foix on Thursday.

Somehow, from the moment the Italian swept away from the field on Super-Besse, and then repeated the feat on the Col d'Aspin I had my doubts.

Then, when Cobo and Piepoli raced clear from the incredibly brave Frank Schleck on Hautacam I was convinced. The Saunier Duval team was guilty as charged.

All my debating powers, used up when Beltran tested positive, powers which weakened when that herbert from Barloworld decided to follow suit, had vanished.

So there I was, once again, having to defend an event I love on various BBC outlets.

Then along comes a clean, 23-year-old from the Isle Of Man, and everything changes. All those outlets are now interested in Mark Cavendish for his achievements.

Some of the questions are naive. Can he win the yellow jersey, how is this going to help him leap up the general classification, why is it that he doesn't ride over the mountains then comes back to win the sprints?

As my esteemed colleague Mr Graham Jones is quick to point out, whatever happenes to Cav he has to pedal over the high hills with everyone else, but at least other parts of the BBC are showing an interest.

So to use another song title, its been a Bittersweet Symphony this week, the bad news which people anticipated coupled with the good news which we wanted to bring you (see my first blog).

So here's the question, as I sit here in my hotel in Aix-En-Provence anticipating the Alpine stages.

As a British cycling fan, what's your lasting memory as the Tour De France enters its final week?

Are you happy for Mark Cavendish, or fed up with Saunier Duval for trying to make a fool out of the greatest single sporting event of the year?

I suspect I know the answer already. Keep the comments coming in, and don't forget we're live here on the BBC Sport website every day from 1500 BST and for five hours on Wednesday, Alpe d'Huez day. You can also hear us on the red button on your digital TV, and either live or in highlights on BBC Radio 5 Live SportsExtra.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jul 19, 2008

Well done to the 'Tour' for sticking their fingers up to the UCI. The UCI seem to accept the doping as the norm and hand out laughably inadequate fines.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 19, 2008

For those who are interested, latest edition (Sunday July 20) of Cyclingnews reports that both Duenas and Piepoli have now confessed to the use of EPO.

http://www.cyclingnews.com/news.php?id=news/2008/jul08/jul20news

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 19, 2008

Riders and teams come and go - as usual, the star of the show is the tour itself. An incredible discipline in a beautiful country.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by rkp5097 (U8558785)

posted Jul 20, 2008

I couldn't agree more. Why do journalists continue to praise athletes whom they know to be dirty.
Not just in cycling, but elsewhere. Go to You Tube and watch the extended clip of Flo-Jo breaking the 100m record. The whole thing, including the commentary and the interview with a gravel voiced Joyner afterwards, is like something from Monty Python.
Like the other commentator, I understand the necessity of libel laws and of obeying them, but those who report on sport have a greater inside knowledge of what's going on in it, they should stop playing silly games when it comes to the cheats.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by joeski (U1646011)

posted Jul 20, 2008

fredoski you talk nonsense, if cavendish was a drugs cheat he would have been caught by now, unlike a lot of the riders in tdf he competes on the world stage so will get tested at every event. if you think every rider is on drugs whats the point in watching?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 21, 2008

i would say the higl light of the tdf has to be cav to win 4 is grate. people in britain love to build someone up to just to put them down.

if cav was a drugs cheat he wouldn't be droped evey time they get to a hill and he wouldn't be droping out now knowing that he could win more stages after the Alpine stages.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by sjrm201 (U4329131)

posted Jul 21, 2008

that kind of comment is unconstructive fredoski. yes, cycling is a dirty sport. yes, I too have felt demoralised by all the positive tests but to say that they're all on drugs is a ridiculous generalisation. I believe Cav is clean. As I believe (maybe naively) that Lance Armstrong was clean, too. Look at David Millar, he's clean and he can still put in some good rides. Cycling's the toughest sport in the world: it's always going to be a temptation to dope but that doens't mean that EVERYONE does it!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 21, 2008

Mark Cavendish's performances have been a real breath of fresh air on this year's Tour. Not only is it great to see cycling consistently making the front pages of UK broadsheets, but it's also fantastic to see a home-grown talent really blossom on one of the sporting world's biggest stages. It's also good to see a cyclist who, based on his track profile and team's tough stance, is very likely to be clean.

A wider point regarding the whole drug situation, though. I'd never defend cheats but remember that some of these guys don't take drugs in order to win, but simply to survive (and thus save their careers) one of the world's toughest challenges. I therefore find their situations subtly different to, say, a 100m sprinter who only really has commercial success in their sights when they decide to cheat.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 21, 2008

Nice comment aboput the scenery etc...i have to say that has been the star of the tour so far, beautiful, amazing countryside and building...worth watching for that alone i think.

on road, best moment for me was piepoli and cobo ransacking the field.....and then the subsequent chucking out of ricco and piepoli. Go home you stupid losers. Then that god the best moment came yesterday, brilliant final 10k of the climb.

And btw, whatever you say about zidaneds butt or del piero and davids on epo...i know you want to defend your sport to the hilt, but cycling will not escape its problems unless it starts behaving with the vigilance and attitude of the most corrupt sport in the world. All this 'they started it' an 'oh look at football they are worse' name calling hlps absolutely no one. cycling needs to be the most militant testing sport, and it also need, yes NEEDS to have a constant stream of high profile cheats outed.

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5
    0 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1
    0 votes

average rating:
0 from 0 votes