BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

11 comments

user rating: not rated yet

Celtic hopefuls have more work to do

One-day internationals Scotland
comment on the article

The Lloyds TSB Tri-Series went as was expected. It was not necessarily the best advert for Associate cricket, with both Ireland and Scotland sustaining what many will see as predictably heavy defeats to New Zealand.

The tourists deserve immense credit for not treating this as an end of tour jolly, fielding virtually a full strength line-up in each of the ties while never once slipping below the standards established during the NatWest Series against England.

It vividly illustrated the chasm that remains, although – as Daniel Vettori pointed out – it is a gap that the Kiwis themselves took 30 years to bridge before they acquired a level of global respectability.

What next though for the Celts, other than their forthcoming Inter-Continental Cup ties, and August’s World Twenty20 qualifiers?

Richard Done, the ICC’s High Performance Manager, joined us in the commentary box during the Scotland v Ireland game to discuss the development of the Associates. Perfect timing in the week that the politicking over the cash that the sport’s governing bodies dishes out to its supposed lesser lights is taking place in Dubai.

“That’s why I came here, rather than being in Dubai, to get away from it,” joked Done, who took over what is a difficult job from the late Bob Woolmer, in his day a passionate advocate for expanding the game outside the big ten.

With the ICC’s board expected this week to sanction a tripling of the funding it doles out to the likes of the Scots and Irish to around £750,000 a year, Done admitted he would like to see some of the money utilised to provide professional contracts to leading players. A necessary step forward, he said.

It would means less of the absenteeism that blighted Ireland’s series, removing the county versus country dilemma that kept the likes of Will Porterfield, Eoin Morgan and (on other occasions) Kyle Coetzer away. When Scotland met Kenya in 1999, the honours were very much even. Since the Kenyans went full-time (aided, in no small manner, by the friendly exchange rate and low cost of living there), they have accelerated ahead.

Much of Done’s work involves providing assistance and support to the Associates to close the gap between haves and have-nots. There is a limit on what more can be accomplished, he argued, unless the ICC - and more significantly the ECB and its counties – buy into the programme. More money welcome. More support required.

Still, Gavin Hamilton’s terrific 115 against the Irish displayed a class which befitted a man who has had to battle his demons since he was cruelly dropped by England after that Johannesburg Test of 1999. Even 12 months ago, Hamilton looked spent. He took some time away from the game – and has found rejuvenation.

The only thing missing was his shirt. Thanks to the Mannofield cleaners who threw out a perfectly good ‘Hamilton’ jersey, leaving East Brierly’s finest to borrow Fraser Watts’ spare kit.
"I'll be wearing Fraser's stuff from now on," said Hamilton, who added another highlight with a brilliant catch on the square leg boundary from Andrew White.

"We get given our kit in bin-liners with our names on it, but I was the only one stupid enough to leave it in the dressing room.” Not that it mattered too much. Other than when the two Watts were briefly together at the crease.

New Zealand, fresh from a day on the golf course, would be a different matter. The risk of sunburn was diminished, for one. Fleeces a necessity.

Phil Goodlad, our intrepid presenter, ventured out without the protection of before Thursday’s start of play for a tour of the ground on the back of the groundsman’s golf cart. Chauffeur-driven, he looked like royalty. Or at least he told us he did.

New Zealand were the true Kings of Aberdeen on this occasion. As commanding on Thursday as they had been 48 hours earlier against the Irish, they underlined how far the Celts must yet travel on their journey.

On the field, over the two ties, there were some good performances from the hosts. On his ODI debut, Qasim Sheikh performed with a swagger against the Irish until he was needlessly dismissed but that he held up against New Zealand bodes well.

Evergreen Colin Smith, the hometown hero, took a record four catches against the Emerald Isle and surpassed his one-day best with a battling 59. Dewald Nel’s 4-25 was the best by a Scotland bowler. After being freed by Worcestershire at the end of last summer, he surely merits another look.

It was a shame that rain drenched Mannofield for much of the final day’s play. No shock that the tourists reigned supreme. For the aspirants, more work lies ahead.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jul 3, 2008

I don't know how they're meant to build upon it without more interest but the foundation is there.

I'm not saying anything about england also getting beat by new zealand because we're playing them soon and will undoubtedly get absolutely hammered.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 3, 2008

Ireland received $500,000 spread over 4 years from their participation in the WC.

For the same event the ICC decided to line Mugabes pockets with $11 million.

It speaks volumes on how the ICC genuinely care about developing the game.

Ireland vs NZ was an embarrasment for us but not suprising as we were missing the top 5 batsmen(and Ed Joyce) and our top four bowlers .... How would Eng, India or even Aus cope in the same circumstances?

If links with Zim are severed will the ICC try to recuop the money they gave away and distribute it to those who need it most?

I think not ... they dont really give a toss

run

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by BrucieB (U1681090)

posted Jul 3, 2008

From a kiwi perspective it is of course nice to see the BCs comprehensively beat both sides ... but why schedule this at the end of the tour? Better for all at the start - NZ could usefully use the games to sort line-up and get up to speed, and the Scots / Irish could reasonably expect to fare better before NZ are played in. Ditto any other tourists.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 4, 2008

Point proved today .... ICC members must be very proud

Absolute filth

run

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 5, 2008

I am going to the Scotland v England game this year and I am just hoping England bat first so we can all get some value for our £48.

These games are good for the SCU and ICU as they help somewhat to fill the funding gap left by the ICCs refusal to "properly" back the next tier.

From a purely cricketing point of view the Associates will learn much more playing against each other more often as well as playing the likes of Kenya and Bangladeshs full sides as well as some of the bigger nations 'A' Sides.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 5, 2008

From a purely cricketing point of view ireland would most benefit if it was able to field its players!!!!!!!!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 7, 2008

I'd like to see cricket do better in Scotland as well as rugby and fringe sports like tennis, ice hockey and basketball just because football alone is so boring, but cricket will never be big in Scotland because it is an outdoors sport which cannot be continued in bad weather and would be uncomfortable to watch all day exposed to the cold and rain.

And it rains all the time in Scotland.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 8, 2008

Cricket, like any other sport, should pay its way. If there is not enough interest, the weather is not kind enough, play something else.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 8, 2008

the rain definitely is a problem, I feel the money should be put into some sort of academy and youth scheme. Glasgow has one of the larger population concentrations in the UK, surely there is some talent that can be mined, give them the skills and oppertunities to make a living in county cricket, then from there see about contracting a team.

just now, they are either ending their cricket days and wanting to hang onto their day jobs, or young and unproven due to limited matches. you want to be making sure taking someone on full-time to train and prepare to represent us nationally is worth it and not just a lucky break for some plucky kid.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 9, 2008

The real issue here is finding a way to get players to stick with their associate nation instead of seeking to be English-qualified. If the Irish players put their country ahead of their countie they would by now have Will Porterfield, Ed Joyce, Eoin Morgan and Niall O'Brien still playing regularly, a very strong line-up for an associate team.

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5
    0 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1
    0 votes

average rating:
0 from 0 votes