BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

171 comments

user rating: 4 star

Does Johnson's arrival herald a new dawn?

comment on the article
Former England captain and new manager Martin Johnson

The future starts now.

On Tuesday, 1 July Martin Johnson formally assumes control of the England rugby team, and after recent disappointments many fans will be thinking ‘not a moment too soon’.

It is a pivotal occasion for the English game as Johnson will announce his first 32-man Elite Player Squad, while the new agreement between the Rugby Football Union and the clubs begins.

After years of club-v-country warfare the new deal finally gives England a realistic measure of control over their players and will hopefully pave the way for greater success on the field.

Johnson will now have total control over the players for three periods during the season, with clubs releasing their players 13 or 14 days before the autumn internationals, Six Nations and summer tours.

Johnson takes over with the team at a low on and off the pitch.

After their precipitous decline following the 2003 World Cup triumph, when the captain was some mono-browed behemoth with a wonderfully acute rugby brain - wonder whatever happened to him - England finally seem ready for a fresh dawn.

The Andy Robinson reign was painful, and while Brian Ashton’s achievement of reaching a World Cup final and coming second in the Six Nations was remarkable, it seemed to happen despite, rather than because of the system.

The way the RFU finally got rid of Ashton was typically inglorious, but now England fans finally have a figurehead they revere and a man who will command total support from across English rugby.

So what do English rugby fans want from Johnson’s first squad?

Some will demand a total clear out and chuck in the youngsters, others will preach evolution, not revolution, but all will demand a clear-sighted vision of both the short-term and long-term future.

As part of this there are changes afoot in the coaching structure.

Johnson is set to appoint London Irish boss Brian Smith as attack coach, while forwards coach Jon Wells and defence coach Mike Ford, who have both been the subject of criticism, retain their roles.

Johnson’s depth of understanding of the game and how it has evolved means anyone expecting England to play like Leicester of five years ago will surely be disappointed.

Smith’s London Irish team have produced some superb flowing rugby in recent times and his appointment strongly suggests England are committed to developing a range of styles rather than relying on a one-dimensional power game that can be negated by sides that can match them up front.

England will base their game on power, no doubt, but there will be plenty of pace and hopefully more footballing ability.

However, with Danny Cipriani currently hors de combat England’s much-maligned back play will have to be improved without the help of English rugby’s most sublime talent.

On Tuesday Johnson will make his first statement of intent about how he sees the immediate future of English rugby unfolding.

With England currently struggling in the second row and the midfield it will be fascinating to see who Johnson turns to there.

Looking at youngsters who may be given a call-up, will young giant Richard Blaze get the nod in the second row, or will veteran loose cannon Danny Grewcock be recalled?

Leicester number eight Jordan Crane impressed for England Saxons and may be ready to step up, and what about 20-year-old Worcester winger Miles Benjamin - he will surely play for England one day but is it too soon to introduce him to the full England set-up?

Personally I would like to see Gloucester fly-half Ryan Lamb given a chance with the big boys.

If England are to continue to improve they have to add more footballing skills to the power Johnson can undoubtedly call on, and with Cipriani injured Lamb appears to be the man to get the backline moving.

He may be small and have defensive frailties, but anyone who saw him dumping opposition players with relish at the Churchill Cup will know he is no turnstile and after all, just how many players can stop Alesana Tuilagi at full tilt anyway?

So how do you see it – it is a bright new dawn for England or just more of the same?

Can the iconic Johnson translate playing success into clear-sighted management?

Should he be picking young guns or wise old heads for his first England squad?

And what are the names you want to see in the squad at 1100 BST on Tuesday?

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jul 10, 2008

Of course it does and your demonstrating a sensible view, albeit a quite simple one, i'm sure Johnson has some innovative plans up his sleeve rather than rolling his sleeves up for some hard graft..

But people are giving this impression that Johnson hasn't been a World Cup winning captain and that in fact he's never seen a game in his life...

Give him more credit than that, past great Managers such as Sir Clive and actually, when you look at his record (By which i mean not actually coaching a senior side before S.A.) Jake White..

These guys had very little top level or indeed any real experience coming into the job...Yet look at them now..

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 11, 2008

Johnson is a great choice as manager he will bring his winning mentality to the team and will also tighten up on discipline and improve the work ethic, The fitness of the English players at the minute is a joke! Johnson will address and improve this. in fact he has appointed Paul Stridgeon from rugby league side warrington wolves as his new fitness coach. Given time england can only improve

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 13, 2008

9.ellis
10.cipriani (wilko while cipi is injured)
11.sackey (strettle on the bench)
12.hipkiss
13.tait
14.varndell
15.lewsey

best england back line

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 13, 2008

come on everyone get behind johnson he,s the main man i am 53yrs old i would go to war for this guy.he,s done it all and more.he has great experience from the coaches and management he has played for. he,s an intelligent man talks good motivates people.most of all he has lifted the web ellis cup. so get behind him one and all.maybe he will lift as a manager too.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by akko19 (U10018655)

posted Jul 14, 2008

I think its ridiculous for people to assume johnny is finished. He was injured for three years and brought back to a withering england team with expectations of his performance to the max as usual. As a fly half you always have choices but sometimes you can only pick from a list of bad ones and with the rest of the team struggling left him with those choices. Hes still a world class player and i think now that there are other fly halves biting at his ankles we will see the wilko we want in november.
Not only is he one of the best players england can hope for but the team morale always rises on his appearance.

I think david strettle should not have been dropped as he makes a bigger impact than Varndell.

The only other decision i found strange was that easter was dropped completely as just last year he scored 4 tries against wales and has since been a strong number 8 for the squad.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 15, 2008

akko19
Apparently there is some personal between Deano and Johnno. Perhaps this explains the omission of Easter and the dropping of Strettle (both quins) for a lesser Leicester player.

Hope this is not the case.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 15, 2008

I've not seen Stettle complete the first half of an international yet, but I have seen him make some amazing breaks. As for Easter I'm supprised, he's been a rock.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 15, 2008

Strettle is flaky and he's had enough opportunities at international level and MJ wants soemthing with substance. As for Easter, he's lethargic and a bit of a dinosaur and MJ needs dynamism and power not sludge. IF MJ had a personal problem with anyone he would not let that govern and of his decision making IMO.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 15, 2008

If the man is honest in what he writes and what he says in these video clips, I get the impression that letting personal feelings decide important issues would definitely be out of the question. Have a bit more faith in him than that. The fat lady aint sung yet so, lets wait and see. roseroserose

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jul 17, 2008

What are the required attributes of a world class no 15?

Courage and reliability under the high ball; strong; explosive pace; aggression; two footed side step; reads the game; a bit of arrogance and self belief; can tackle, kick and score tries.

Ben Foden is your man, the best fullback in the premiership last season!

PS: He can play pretty much anywhere else in the backs too.

Here's the controversial bit: he's better than Tait and Lewsey and certainly Brown or Balshaw.

cracker

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article


RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 66.67%
    8 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 33.33%
    4 votes

average rating:
3.67 from 12 votes