BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

129 comments

user rating: 3 star

Ince deserves Premier League chance

Premier League Blackburn Rovers
comment on the article

Blackburn Rovers have taken a gamble on a young - in managerial terms - English talent in handing Paul Ince the reins at Ewood Park.

Ince brings no guarantee of success with him, but he has the priceless virtue of having actually served a good old-fashioned apprenticeship at his job after quitting as a player.

And for someone who had a reputation for having an ego on the field, the self-styled "Guv'nor" lest we forget, he has shown a refreshing willingness to put that on one side and go in at the bottom to learn his new trade.

Ince helped Macclesfield preserve their Football League status before polishing his profile further by guiding MK Dons to the League Two title and the Johnstone's Paint Trophy last season.

Of course Ince has not got his Uefa pro licence yet, but this now appears as meaningless in reality as it is to the average football fan in the street.

Give me a manager who has actually managed but does not have Uefa's so-called seal of approval rather than someone who has the licence but has actually never done the job.

Ince has got his hands dirty at the wrong end of the league, and having been a success it is a natural progression that he now moves up the ladder to take charge in the top flight.

The licence can wait. Ince has proper managerial work to do.

It has been a regular cry that up-and-coming British managers who have served time in the lower leagues are passed over in favour of more fashionable foreign names.

Blackburn have ignored this route and for that alone deserve credit.

Ince has certainly had the opportunity to learn from some of the game's most experienced managers, from Sir Alex Ferguson at Manchester United to Roy Hodgson at Inter Milan as well as Gerard Houllier at Liverpool - although the less said about that relationship the better.

He has also had a vastly-experienced and astute assistant in Ray Mathias at MK Dons and it would be no surprise if that partnership is revived at Blackburn.

Ince joins Blackburn at a challenging time, with David Bentley deciding he now needs a bigger stage than Ewood Park and admirers circling the much-coveted Roque Santa Cruz.

Bentley looks to be a lost cause, but Ince will surely launch a charm offensive to keep Santa Cruz.

Ince also has the benefit of taking over at a club that appears to be superbly well-organised under the chairmanship of John Williams.

Of course, the former England star regards himself as a winner and will target silverware, but he may have to set his sights a little lower in his new job.

Blackburn will regard a cup as a bonus, and for Ince success will be taking the club back into Europe after missing out last season.

And it will be just like old times for the former Liverpool captain when he starts his reign on the opening day of the season - at Everton.

Ince will be guaranteed an interesting reception at Goodison Park, but he will relish the chance to put his fighting spirit to the test at the top.

It seems strange to call the appointment of an emerging English manager without any of Uefa's certificates to his name a bold move, but this is what it is and Blackburn will hope to be well-rewarded.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jun 23, 2008

paul ince did a great job for mk dons and deserves the blackburn job and the uefa pro license thing is a big joke. roeder, southgate, pearce, and avram grant were given dispensation so ince should be aloud aswell

good luck ince

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 23, 2008

Mate, I see your point as well as others but the fact of the matter is he is now manager.

If he's good he'll stay if he's crap he'll be sacked.

End of.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 23, 2008

Can you can answers these questions honestly and still say its simply down to 'numbers'?
........

Yes, of course. I'll try again to show you why I say that. If, for example, coloured English players only make up 1% of the total no. of English players making the grade as a professional footballer ... why would you expect, say 15% of the England team to be black? Doesn't make numerical sense ... Otherwise, you're going down a ' quota system ' which does nobody, of any colour, any favours ...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 24, 2008

i think rovers have made a crackin choice.
good experience in lower divisions, a great record of acheivement as a player, nevermind official badges etc, he has gained valuable experience, which is worth 10 times any certificate.

the one sticking point is the BBC, constant references to him being the first "black" premier league manager?
totally unacceptable BBC!

the colour of a person's skin is totally irrelevant, and should not be mentioned in every report, if his team loses a match, does he not hurt the same as other managers?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 24, 2008

The real problem for Ince will be following in Hughes footsteps.

Ince is good, Hughes was very good.

How will the fans take, say, 10th place?

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by GawnaB (U11553033)

posted Jun 24, 2008

Gr8 job ince,yuh deserve dat and that's what england need...and beside dat i'v feeln he's gonna be good manager...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 25, 2008

and *that's* what england need
*****
you slipped up and missed a ' dat's ' out mate ... laugh

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 25, 2008

Phil Mcnulty with a name like that not sure if you have natural ENGLISH ROOTS OR IRISH....my point being why should Paul Ince not aim highrer that just getiing a European spot. The British mentality of playing it safe is no wonder Engalnd failed to qulaify for Euro2008.

Aiming HIGH i s better than amiming LOW. I would love it If he wins a cup in his first season.

As for his colour well the less said the better...Blackburn have made their choice and a
good one too.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 25, 2008

my point being why should Paul Ince not aim highrer that just getiing a European spot.

*****

Well, one reason might be that by aiming for the impossible, you then become a failure when you don't acheive that aim ... why should Ince put more pressure on himself by making ' Pie in the sky ' predictions?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 27, 2008

Really hoping he does a good job, and that this isn“t a case of too much, too soon.

Good luck to the lad, would be great to see him taking on the England mantle at some point.

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 45.00%
    18 votes
  • 4 15.00%
    6 votes
  • 3 10.00%
    4 votes
  • 2 2.50%
    1 votes
  • 1 27.50%
    11 votes

average rating:
3.48 from 40 votes