BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

50 comments

user rating: 5 star

Should Pacman Jones be reinstated?

comment on the article

Following a drawn out transfer saga which culminated in the Dallas Cowboys signing Adam ‘Pacman’ Jones from the Tennessee Titans, it is still unknown whether anyone will ever see him take the field at Texas Stadium.

The 24-year-old missed the whole of last season after being suspended for off-the-field conduct detrimental to the league. It is fair to say that Pacman is the quintessential sporting bad boy; he’s been arrested six times since joining the NFL and was implicated in a triple shooting at a Las Vegas strip club in 2007. Despite the fact that Jones was charged in June last year with two counts of felony coercion, the Cowboys were very keen to bring the player to the franchise.

Looking around the various Cowboy blogs on the net, it appears as though the fans have mixed opinions as to whether or not they believe that Pacman should represent Dallas in the NFL. There are two very distinct camps: the people who say, ‘We’ve just signed one of the best players in the league,' and the others who exclaim, ‘Oh dear, why have we signed this extremely troubled individual to play for our team!’.

The problem that the anti-Jones camp is facing is the fact that despite his various off the field issues, when Pacman does take to the pitch he is a player of immense quality. Add to that the fact that the Cowboys lost backups Nathan Jones and Jacques Reeves and it is quite clear why the franchise felt the need to add depth at the cornerback position. If you don’t like stats (I’ve yet to find an NFL fan that doesn’t), look away now…

•In 30 games (28 starts) over two years with the Titans, Jones deflected 18 passes, intercepted four and finished with 115 tackles (94 solo).

•His contributions in the return game were a major reason why the Cowboys made this deal. He returned 20 kicks in 2006, averaging 26.1 yards for a total of 521 yards. Punt returns were where he really excelled as he totaled 440 yards on 34 punts, while reaching the end zone three times in 2006.

•His kick-return average was sixth in the league for players with at least 20 attempts that year, while his punt-return average was tops among players with at least 20 returns.

With stats like these, it is unsurprising that the Cowboys officials are so keen to attempt to keep him on the straight and narrow and are keen to bring his talent to Dallas. Cowboys fans should be optimistic that if Pacman is indeed reinstated, he’ll be working alongside two players whose troubled careers have been turned around by the Cowboys franchise: Terrell Owens and Tank Johnson.

Of course, it is the moral side of the debate which will ultimately be decisive in the matter, however talented Pacman may be. Will Commissioner Roger Goodell be keen to avoid another Michael Vick type scenario which brought such negative headlines to the NFL? It might be that he does not want what he perceives to be a negative influence on the NFL and its audience play in the league again. Given the severity of Pacman’s problems, this would not be all that surprising.

Do you think Pacman should be reinstated, or does his troubled life off the field bring too much baggage and bad publicity to the NFL? Cowboys fans, do you want to see Pacman represent your team?

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted May 14, 2008

He might well be sweating with optimism, but he isn't the man who'll decide Pacman's fate... So, do you think Goodell will reinstate him?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 14, 2008

I think that they should give packman one more opportunity. If he messes that up... Then give him the boot.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 14, 2008

Stevecan, I just saw your comment, very interesting stuff. Tell us more about the damage Pacman did to the Titans, it would be great to get the perspective from a fan who supports the team he played for. You say there was relief when he left Tennessee- do you think the Cowboys will regret signing him? What is the impact that a 'bad-boy' player can have on a football team and the city it represents?

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by Higgie3 (U1703732)

posted May 14, 2008

Is this the pacman that appeared on TNA for a while??

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 14, 2008

It is indeed, here is the promo for his first appearance on it:

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=dNjEjIiKWiQ

Suitably ridiculous! For those of who who are unaware, Pacman appeared on 'Total Nonstop Wrestling Action' against the wishes of the NFL. I assume there was a lot of money in it, hard to understand why else he would take part...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 14, 2008

Pacman should get reinstated - yes he has off the field issues but he was told the length of his ban and he has served it.

Pacman was effectively punished for bringing the game into disrepute but I do not see how what he has done negatively impacts on the image of the nfl any more than what Bill Belicheat has done. Surely what the Pats did was worse for the image of the game.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 14, 2008

Stevecan, I just saw your comment, very interesting stuff. Tell us more about the damage Pacman did to the Titans, it would be great to get the perspective from a fan who supports the team he played for. You say there was relief when he left Tennessee- do you think the Cowboys will regret signing him? What is the impact that a 'bad-boy' player can have on a football team and the city it represents?
add comment | complain about

Tim, I’m just a normal fan, but to me, one of the most apparent, and ugly, ramifications of the PacMan experience was the blatantly racial divide that it both created and exposed among Tennessee Titans fans. As evidence, go to the discussion boards on the Nashville Tennessean web site, http://www.tennessean.com/apps/pbcs.dll/frontpage. As a BBC writer, you are probably aware of the fact that American publications’ web site are subject to much less “moderation” than BBC boards. Unlike discussions regarding the other Titans players, both black and white, virtually every discussion regarding Jones devolved into the most blatant white racist versus black racist tirades (again, more freedom of speech here of course). I don’t know about in Britain, but here in the US, it is an ugly fact that many teams have been damaged by teammates taking sides on the basis of racial battle lines. My personal belief was that it was due almost completely to the “thug” image that PacMan proudly carried since before he set foot in Nashville, which was accompanied by the requisite “me first” playing attitude. I have no idea how he will work out with the Cowboys, but his coach in Tennessee, Jeff Fisher has a reputation as being one of the most player-friendly coaches in the league. It’s hard to believe that laid back Wade Phillips will have any more success turning Pacman into a good Cowboy team player than Jeff did with him in Nashville. At least our team doesn’t have to be distracted by all of the pacman media coverage this year – the Cowboys can have that as well.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 15, 2008

Thanks Steve, fascinating stuff. The racial divide is intriguing and not something that is apparent in sports teams over here (at least not that we know about anyway). That's a very ugly side of sport in the States if that is the case.

A lot of Pacman's success or lack of it will come down to his own attitude. I feel that there is little JJ, Wade Phillips or anyone else if he doesn't want to change. I guess the situation is pretty similar to Michael Vick's, and look what Atlanta had to do to turn the page on the chapter? Draft in a new QB. Perhaps Tennessee won't have to do anything like that, but as you say, it will be great for the team not to have the negative media attention.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 17, 2008

Please god reinstate him...that way TNA won't be able to bring him back.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 19, 2008

I don't know, I quite want to see him back in TNA. It's one of the funniest/most ridiculous things I have ever seen!

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.