BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

68 comments

user rating: 4 star

Munster: An apology!

European Wales
comment on the article

In this column last week, and on numerous previous occasions during this season’s Heineken Cup, I stated my belief that Munster are no longer a force in European Rugby. My rationale related to a feeling that their pack was ageing and no longer able to dominate the opposition, and in that event they lacked any depth to their play to employ an alternative strategy. I wish to make it clear and state the for the record that not only were these allegations manifestly false, they amounted to little more than the ramblings of moron unable to learn the lessons that history has taught. I hereby undertake a solemn promise to never again knowingly understate Munster’s ability at this level.

There I said it, and contrary to what many members (notably Munster_by_grace of_God & Jimchris) of this website may believe, the words did not stick in my throat, or more accurately, my keyboard. I have no axe to grind with Munster, after all my great grandfather was from Cork! No I just got it wrong, plain and simple, and I am happy to put my hands up and admit it. In reality my predictions this season have been pathetic. If Alan Sugar was running a bookies and I was his rugby odds setter, he’d have fired me during the group stages.

I will stop short of admitting the laziness I was accused of last week, but I will confess to extrapolating Ireland’s loss of form in the past 12 months and projecting their failings on to Munster. There is evidence that the Province have built their reputation with a 10 man game, and as a consequence I doubted their ability to realise their aspirations to width. Even more embarrassingly I had largely dismissed the presence of Doug Howlett , Liefiemi Mafi and Rua Tipoki as baubles on an oak tree, my philosophy being that having a Ferrari F1 car on your drive doesn’t make you Kimmi Raikonnen.

Munster were as they have so often have been, imperious and had the game on a string within half an hour. It may be true that Chris Paterson had been kidnapped and replaced with a clone that couldn’t kick a barn door if he was holding the handle, but as the Munster took control their midfield neutered the precocious Ryan Lamb and suffocated his colleagues beyond. Ian Dowling was outstanding in this aspect but as the usual suspects delivered huge performances upfront , it was for me Alan Quinlan that turned in a performance that drew awe inspired admiration. I just wish I could have played one game like that just to know what it feels like to earn that level of respect. It is a constant source of wonder that these blokes do it so often.

As I was clearing the egg off my face, my prediction of a canter for the Ospreys rose up majestically to bite me in the ass. I felt a little less foolish in this as it caught most people out. As you can imagine there has been much wailing and wringing of hands in the Principality. The cruel observers believe the Ospreys humped “Sarries” in the EDF because the Welsh boys were still under influence of Gatland, and that 2 weeks with Lyn Jones had returned them to their old flat ways. The fact of the matter is they did not adapt well to the small pitch, and tried to go wide before they had committed sufficient defenders, where Quinlan had gone at Kingsholm so went Hill, Vyvyan and Chesney at Vicarage Road enabling Saracens to hunt out wide where they enjoyed many kills.

The major worry for The Ospreys ahead of this weekends EDF final was the way Cobus Visagie turned in an old style tight head’s master class that emasculated The Osprey’s pack and brought Duncan Jones not only to his knees, but often his toes. This alone should have prompted Marcel Llofreda to dispatch the Leicester forwards to the scrummage machines for a week. If he did then Leicester may well inflict on the field, the kind of pressure that is building on The Ospreys off the field, as a season that promised so much threatens to deliver the square root of chuff all. Ospreys by 7, see I just can’t help myself.......

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Apr 11, 2008

I agree that Munster are probably the most predictable team around: They generally win

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

I hope that this defense of Munster Rugby doesnt come across as us being arrogant! Munster is the home of Rugby in Ireland and Munster people are generally very knowledgable if not a little biased when it comes to Rugby!

Rugby means a huge amount to us as evidenced by the extraordinary efforts we make to travel around Europe supporting our team in the Heineken Cup (and to a lessor degree the ML's


add comment | complain about this comment

comment by JJBB777 (U6743263)

posted Apr 11, 2008

bluemuff, having had the pleasure of sitting amongst Munster fans a few times I would agree about your support. You managed to turn Welford into a near home tie with the amount of support and singing a few years ago .

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

This is hillarious, so many people have taken the WUM that is Blues Brother. It is either a WUM, a severe lack of knowledge or a few mental issues.

Munster are not an elite European team was a start but then to claim that Clermont were beter than Munster (never won anything), Leinster also ahead of Munster as an Elite team considering their record & that Cardiff are only 1 place behind Munster.

I think Blues Brother thinks he is on a board for Elite Holiday Destinations & I would admit that France, London, Leicester & Wales is probably a better holiday destination but bloody hell if he he thinks that Munster are that far down the list for Elite Rugby Teams I would worry more about him than anything else. cool

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

Don't listen to that blue lad, he has his own opinion and you aren't going to change it,

I CONSIDER ULSTER IN THE ELITE LEAGUE IN THE EUROPEAN CUP AS WE WON IT IN 1999

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

After tonight I can see Connacht becoming a major force in European Rugby too winkeye What do you reckon Ulsterrugger????

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

Haha well you all make some good points but again I have to disagree. I have my opinion and you have yours. I have been listening to Johnny Cash a bit today and so in his words:

'I won't back down,
No I won't back down,
You can stand my up at the gates of hell but I won't back down,
I'm gonna stand my ground
and won't be turned around and i'll keep these Munster fans from dragging me down and no I won't back down!!'

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

Whys is it always always always a Cardiff Blues fan tell me that?

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by akadau (U3740513)

posted Apr 11, 2008

Blues brother; just want to point out as Glos fan that Munster played the ref very well and it was the Gloster boys job to sort out the problem they didnt, Munsters defence was excellent and Gloster didnt really look like scoring. Vaniakolo made two beginers errors that contribued to the two tries but all in all Munster are far more street wise than Glos. Glos need at least one more season to compete with the best. I include munster amongst the best of europe (great pedigree)always perform consistently well in europe. I hope we get the chance to play them again because there appears to be a great raport amongst the fans and the rugby is always interesting. I think the more we play them the more we can learn from them. Well done Munster you are still the side to beat.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 11, 2008

Good article Rick.Nice to see Quinlan's contributions being recognised.As for some of the comments--How can anyone question Munster's european pedigree?I think that all will be revealed when next seasons seedings are published.

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 69.23%
    9 votes
  • 4 15.38%
    2 votes
  • 3 7.69%
    1 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 7.69%
    1 votes

average rating:
4.38 from 13 votes