BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

33 comments

user rating: 3 star

shoiab ban, justified or.................

Pakistan
by censure (U10746450) 06 April 2008
comment on the article

After listing to both interview's of Shoaib on Capital talk, and Dr. Naseem Ashraf on Geo tv, I would like to give my fair opinion. First of all many people in or outside Pakistan thinking it is a personality clash between Dr Nassem & Shoaib are wrong.
It is PCB board officials unanimous decision to ban him for his ill discipline, enough is enough how many chances and how lengthy probationary periods he required? Naseem rightly said in his interview that he is a habitual offender. There is nobody greater then respect of pakistan & pakistan cricket.
Another thing which I must point out that shoaib is very emotional personality in his interview he is describing he always play for pakistan wholeheartedly, in his interview he also disclosed that in past & presently he been offer a lot of money by bookmaker's to under perform as a main strike bowler, my question is to shoaib why did not he inform about it to PCB/ICC anti corruption's team's, why he is keeping it to himself for so long?
But naa this Shoaib when he is hurt, he is throwing his toy's out of his pram and crying loud & loud. These statements and mud slinging is like opening a can of worm's and now ICC have to investigate it. This whole saga is giving bad name to Pakistan cricket. I seriously think Shoaib has fair chance in Bollywood film's in emotional/sentimental characters, he will be a hit on box office.
There is no doubt he was a brilliant cricketer, but his attitude towards game and to his fellow cricketers was the biggest hurdle in his progress to a long and successful International carrier, he has been given many chances to get it right but all in vain. I personally still want to thank him for the very few victories he contributed for his country, PCB has taken a bold decision.




Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted May 4, 2008

Shoaib is a showman - nothing else - his main skills are chasing women (instead of ball on field) - he is idolized by Punjabis and Indians on Pakistan border of India and Bollywood, for he can be an advertisement for Hindi films in MiddleEast and Pakistan, a source of foreign excahnge for India

As for cricket, Shoaib has never been a force, let alone spent force - I do not think he is exciting - Brett Lee is - fast furious and terrific - So is Flintoff

Sachin's appearance can reduce Shoaib to pedestrian class - the walloping shoaib got from Sachin has shut him off for ever - Before the Perth Test, Shoaib mouthed off saying Shaun tait will damage Sachin's confidence - so savage was sachin's batting at Perth Shaun tait opted to quit as the youngest cricketer, in Tests, begging for a surcease from the bludgeoning from India's Fab 5

OOOOOOOOOOOOh, Shoiab, bring him on Shah Ruk Khan, we can smash his bowling to shreds

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 6, 2008

In light of Asif found with hard drugs , Shoaib should be let off . Shoaib is a cricket superstar who has been damaged by the Pcb

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 8, 2008

I think a five year ban is way too long for a cricketer (unless they did something crazy like kill or seriously injure somebody). A cricketer can only ply their trade for 15-20 years and probably for the first few years most cricketers won't earn much so it's like 10-15 years for another job.

If he broke the law e.g. slander, he should go to a civil court. It shouldn't really affect his right to do his job.

Even if Pakistan banned him from playing for the country and banned him from getting a contract that'd be one thing but I think it's too much to ban him for basically all forms of cricket (except I suppose the renegade ICL but they won't have to offer him much if they know he's banned from elsewhere).

I think it wouldn't happen in a lot of democracies.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 9, 2008

I only have one thing to say to people who want the PCB to be lenient in case of Shoaib. A player should not be bigger then the Game. If you start to bend or be lenient to your star players or special players then the integrity of the game is gone. He needs to be punished and punished fairly. That will have to be the guide lines of ICC or PCB.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 10, 2008

asia home of cricket --- I don't care about players Ego's in fac tthey need Ego's to compete . If Shoaib's Ego helps him destroy every batting line up on the planet then by all means he can crown himself the King of Punjab all I care .

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 14, 2008

Makes the pcb look a bunch of despots. Understand that the guy is not the flavour of the month but the wrong vibes are being sent out by the pcb. Perhaps the pcb should be renamed the tpcb where the t stands for taleban maybe totalitarian....judge is out.....oooops bad call on the judge thing LOL

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 14, 2008

Guys like this live on the edge.Huge ego.Huge talent.Huge problem.Enigma.Dodgy?

Has he illegally enhanced his body and is his famous fiery temperament the side effect of illicit or prescriptive performance enhancing drugs.Partially??? Why does he keep taking on authority? Because ghe can,I saw him in the IPL...devestating...destroyed a team in 4 overs.Ceratianly can bowl but is he beyond RESPONABLE behaviour or just all this is the by product of his ability.Is he a cheat.HIstory will tell

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 16, 2008

How good a player is should make no difference to the standards expected of him. The PCB have repeatedly backed him and he has repeatedely offended. Its favouritism that hes been allowed to keep playing this long, not the reverse.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by ebd253 (U1981530)

posted Jun 16, 2008

This news just goes to show how spineless the PCB are!

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article


RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 40.00%
    2 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2 20.00%
    1 votes
  • 1 40.00%
    2 votes

average rating:
2.80 from 5 votes