Ireland v Scotland player ratingsSix Nations Ireland by Rob Hodgetts - BBC Sport (U1654754) 23 February 2008 Ireland made it two wins out of three in this year's competition with an ultimately impressive 34-13 over Scotland, capped by a fine display from rejuvenated full-back Geordan Murphy. Latest 10 commentsRead members' comments or add your own
comment by
TheDude_001 (U11137271) posted Feb 25, 2008 There are so so many things I could post but ultimately all I want to say is EOS has to go and soon. He needs to be bought out of his contract, because I think he has stifled Irish rugby for the past 2 -3 years. I mean, yes we played against Scotland but EOS hand was forced to make all the changes that mattered… he is finally playing the players in their positions not because he wants to but because the Irish public demand it. Why is he still in the job, because the executive decisions are clearly not been made by him! If he had his way, EOS would still be playing the lack-luster first-team that bombed out in the world-cup. He proved this by effectively playing the same first team against Italy at the start of the six nations.
comment by
ross-bal4 (U6441837) posted Feb 26, 2008 I love how the irish contingent are still adment it was Eddies fault at the world cup!!!
comment by
peachlegs (U6722972) posted Feb 26, 2008 im sorry ros but ur wrong!in no uncertain terms u are wrong!u go through the argentina team and the irish team and u will see baring the front row, contemponi and hernandes, the irish players were far superior, played together more often and trained together more often!so why did they not win?the coaching staff picked players not on form, the players seemed to not be any less motivated and Osullivan has only made changes to the 6 nations team coz he was forced to due to injury. are u sayin if we did not have a warren gatland, jake white or nick mallet we would not have gone further....rubbish course we would because we have a very talented bunch of players who needed pointing in the right direction. for dear sakes we scraped past namibia and nearly got beaten by georgia!!!!!!!!with no changes following those dismal performances!!!so in closing u r wrong, just plain wrong....sorry
comment by
ross-bal4 (U6441837) posted Feb 26, 2008 So are you trying to tell me that 5 argentineans won them 3rd place!!! Think your the one that is wrong mate!!! Corletto, Pichot, Todeschini, the Lobbe brothers, Leguizamon etc etc even manuel contepomi. All these guys played briliantly at the WC!!! You all love O'driscoll yet he aint been on form for 2years!! Argentina beat you twice before the WC then at the WC!!! Before you go ranting that it was a 2nd string before the WC the same can be said about the Argentinean team!!! Argentina outplayed you in all departments on the pitch so I don't get why you all still harp on about the WC, you were the 3rd best team in that group no arguements!!! And by arguing that your players were "superior, played together more often and trained together more often" (your exact words) is stupid cause if that was the case you would have won!!! Really you've just turned round and praised argentina for being less skilled, hardly played together and hardly trained together yet they beat you!!! Good arguement you idiot!!!
comment by
Ireland's Finest Export (U10881686) posted Feb 26, 2008 no hes right ross-bal4 (mostly), you're wrong!
comment by
ross-bal4 (U6441837) posted Feb 26, 2008 davemim are you saying i'm mostly correct??
comment by
Ireland's Finest Export (U10881686) posted Feb 26, 2008 Totally agree with you regarding Argentina, I was v tempted at placing a wee bet on Argentina prior to the WC, v much under-rated at the time.
comment by
peachlegs (U6722972) posted Feb 26, 2008 ros i was trying to make my point about osullivan and u inadvertently supported me in many ways!!!we have better preparation, training and in many departments better players therefore osullivans coaching has to come into question!!!!i am not getting at argentina they played with passion which i love to see but i am focusin on osullivan and ur silly comment that it doesnt matter which coach u had u still would of finished 3rd....what a load of bull!!!osullivan has killed off what should have been the most succesful years of irish rugby, looking at our backline with the likes of ogara odriscol darcy horgan hickie- dear god that backline has phenomal talent!!!and yet failed miserably at the WC!!conservative mr osullivan ruined this backline which had talent brimming from every pore!!are u saying another coach could not of got more out of them...well u did and ur wrong in saying that, im focusin on osullivan not argentinas brilliant progress and WC campaign.
comment by
ross-bal4 (U6441837) posted Feb 27, 2008 All I am saying is that it was a tough group and I don't think another coach would have made a big difference as I think Argentina were always destined to win that group!!! You may have challanged france for the 2nd slot but if you had turned up with jake white and Gatlan I don't think it would have made a massive difference!!
comment by
Ireland's Finest Export (U10881686) posted Feb 27, 2008 you see thats where you're wrong ross, i really think it would have made a difference Comment on this article |