BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

379 comments

user rating: 3 star

Is Keegan right to return to Newcastle?

Premier League Newcastle United
comment on the article

Kevin Keegan vowed never to return to management after quitting Manchester City in March 2005 - but the old romantic has found the call of the Tyne impossible to ignore.

It was only in October that Keegan told BBC One's Inside Sport that he had no plans to return, and that his life had moved in a different direction.

The "different direction" Keegan referred to was running a soccer circus in Glasgow, which may actually prove the perfect grounding for returning to Newcastle United as manager.

Keegan has ignored the old warning about "never go back" and is the stunning appointment as manager of a club where he is treated like a messiah.

Alan Shearer was the people's choice, but only because people never seriously believed Keegan, a man rarely known to change his mind, would come back to St James' Park.

Now all Tyneside is in ecstasy after owner Mike Ashley and chairman Chris Mort pulled off the coup that will be a perfect vote-catcher among Newcastle fans.

Keegan was the man who captained Newcastle into the first division as a player, then came off a golf course in Spain to oversee a reign of glorious football, superstar signings, and one of the most-publicised late collapses in title history.

He left in 1997, but the panache he brought to Newcastle has ensured he has remained a much-loved figure in the city.

So will Keegan - who admits he has not watched a game of football in the flesh since leaving Manchester City - cheat the old adage about never returning to the scene of previous triumphs?

Keegan will arrive on a sea of goodwill throughout football, a decent, honest man who is an advocate of an attacking game. Few, if any, will want to see his return play out as a failure.

But the doubters will suggest Keegan's appointment is a panic measure from an owner whose first choice, Harry Redknapp, turned him down.

Keegan at least knows the monster he is being asked to tame at Newcastle.

He knows the supporters want attacking football, but this time he will have to deliver silverware as well. He will not find it as easy to force Newcastle into title contention as he did first time around.

Keegan's name alone will attract quality players to Newcastle. He will unite Newcastle's fans behind him in a way recent appointments never did.

He knows the huge weight of expectation that is the price on the ticket for this job. And he knows the disappointments Newcastle fans have suffered.

And if any man is almost pre-ordained to end Newcastle's 39-year wait for a trophy, it is Keegan.

One thing is certain. It will not be a dull ride because Keegan has never dealt in anything other than pure entertainment as a player and manager, winning or losing.

This is the romantic, emotional aspect of Keegan's appointment - but questions will rightly be asked about the wisdom of his return.

Is this a populist appointment by Ashley and Mort, with no footballing logic based on recent form?

Have they gone with the roar of the crowd rather than a sound long-term strategy? Has Ashley made the mistake of listening to fans rather than follow his own plan?

Keegan was a disillusioned, beaten man when he walked away from Manchester City. And his love of the game appeared to have evaporated as he cut all ties with top-flight football.

He will also have to show he is not just an off-the-cuff manager. Keegan has been accused of being more cheerleader than strategist, a failing he virtually admitted when he resigned as England coach in 2000.

Keegan will need to choose his backroom staff carefully to provide the tactical know-how to complement his man-management and inspirational skills.

And the revival of Newcastle will not be a quick-fix. It will take years after the damage inflicted in recent years. Is Keegan a manager for the long haul?

It will be one of football saddest sights if Keegan fails and damages a reputation that still shimmers among Newcastle fans.

Can he get the best out of Michael Owen? And can he cure defensive problems that dogged his own reign in charge?

All these questions and more will be answered. And what fun it will be to find out.

Keegan has always loved a gamble, but he has taken few bigger than this.

He will bring a force of personality and presence that can only enhance the Premiership, but there is a real element of a punt about this appointment.

Newcastle have provided entertainment, in a variety of forms and often for opposition fans, in recent times. Keegan will guarantee more, but there is no guarantee this gamble will succeed.

So, is this a romantic, unrealistic panic appointment or will Keegan revive the glory days and bring trophies to Newcastle?

Let us know your thoughts.




Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jan 18, 2008

Keegan was there for five years & won nothing. Newcastle fans have allowed their hearts to rule their heads. Keegan hasn't won anything as a manager, so what makes the fans think he can do so this time at Newcastle? They'll be struggling to beat the drop next season.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 18, 2008

I for one welcome the return of Keegan to Newcastle. I look forward to terrific attacking football and some awfull defending. I am not a Newcastle fan, but my heart leapt to see him return and for him to be given the funding to create a decent attack. Good Luck Newcastle I will enjoy watching you provide me with many hours of superb entertainment. The league needed another character, once Mourinho had left. Keegan returns great news.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 18, 2008

Keegan is an excellent manager and Newcastle will do much better now he is back. Succesful with Newcastle, Fulham and Man. City...

One thing is for sure he is a much better manager than Jose ever was...or will be!!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 18, 2008

am sure keegan will pull his weight

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 18, 2008

The old rule says never go back and it is difficult to imagine the same degree of success can return to Newcastle as when Keegan reigned previously. I am an old Sunderland supporter, but one of those who was brought-up to engage in good-natured two-way banter between ourseslves and the Toon (which flowed with gusto both ways). But that's as far as it went and when we were not opponents on the field, we supported each other against all the rest. In the three Cup-winning seasons in the fifties, the roars from the houses of fans listening to the cup finals on the radios (not everyone had TVs) were as loud in Sunderland as they were in Newcastle. A far cry from the sick, moronic bile that flows from certain sections of both sets of modern fans today. But, I sincerely hope that Keegan's return works well for him and Newcastle. Even though we often directed plenty of laughs at those who played at Sid James Park, I remember well, that in my mind, KK's Newcastle were the most exciting team to watch since way back for maybe twenty or thirty years and I couldn't wait for them to be on TV so I could enjoy their football again. No, they didn't win anything with him, but I always felt royally entertained and it strangely seemed to feel better than winning. After all the problems they have had recently, and the problems we down the road have also been experiencing, it sure would be nice if these two magnificent sets of supporters again had something to really cheer about. Even with the present state of afffairs, the attendances remain excellent at both grounds. So come on Kevin, treat us to some more of that great free-flowing sunny football we so much enjoyed before.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 18, 2008

If Keegan is successful, then I will hold on to hope that I will once again, go out with my ex who I have been lost without since we broke up (3 years ago). I still hold hope to this day that going back doesn't neccesarily mean doom. Come on Kev, do it for me and my love :D

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 19, 2008

Here in Oz I am now looking forward to the rest of the season where we can now start playing some exciting, attacking football.Let us not get too ambitous and think that KK can wave his magic wand and start winning every game.Yes he can start his tactical techniques but he is only as good as his squad will allow him to play. So I do not see a lot of changes too his squad till end of season when he will discard the chaff and keep the corn.I for one always thought highly of big Sam for what he did at Bolton but he went down in my estimation when he signed Mark Viduka So come on Kev get the ball rolling and get up in the top 8 and perhaps next year we will be ready with an improved style of play and a few new players who can play attacking soccer

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 20, 2008

WAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAAA

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 22, 2008

andy wasnt saying he put newcastle in a bad position i was saying he runs away when pressure gets to him but hes had the help of a big bank balance everywhere he went not many have i hope newcastle do succeed but kk for me is not the man

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by U5664915

posted Jan 26, 2008

Keegan has a tough job in his hands!

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 37.63%
    35 votes
  • 4 19.35%
    18 votes
  • 3 9.68%
    9 votes
  • 2 3.23%
    3 votes
  • 1 30.11%
    28 votes

average rating:
3.31 from 93 votes