BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

122 comments

user rating: 4 star

We've Heard this Toon Before

Newcastle United
by Robbo Robson (U5722413) 11 January 2008
comment on the article
Derek 'Robbo' Robson

Well, you couldn't say it wasn't coming but nothing that happens at Newcastle will surprise any of us anymore.

Chris Mort (that's French for 'dead' isn't it?) made all the right noises about longevity and long-term plans and to be fair eight months is a good run on Tyneside these days.

Big Sam couldn't lose entertainingly. That was his major failing. But surely someone sometime has got to stand up and stick with a certain someone till he's had a chance to really prove himself.

Since Freddie Shepherd took his ball home you'd have thought there was the prospect of a bit more stability but the next victim, sorry, candidate will make it eight bosses in 11 years at St James'.

Since King Kev they've ditched the good (Robson), the bad (Souness), the ugly (Allardyce), the greedy (Dalglish), the needy (Gullit) and the weedy (Roeder). Who the hell's next?

It's hard to really care. You feel like starting off with that snide remark our wonderful MPs always begin with when their rivals are in some sort of bother: "Much as I don't want to intrude into private grief..."

But to be honest, I haven't met a Geordie in the last couple of days who isn't as gobsmacked as the rest of us by the whole blinking farce.

And, as a Boro fan who does his best to ignore the fact that a quarter of the Riverside season tickets are owned by empty seats, the faithful, bursting-at-the-seams Gallowgate end deserves a bit more than this.

Granted, you Geordies do get ahead of yourselves rather too often. Frankly 11th is not far below where you should be, given the squad. But loyalty ought to have brought some reward in the last 30 years.

Even the Boro bagged a Mickey Mouse tinpot trophy that Spurs or Everton would pocket right now if they could.

A Phoenix-like return from KK? The fans'd just love it LOVE IT!Derek 'Robbo' Robson

Still it feeds the tabloid hacks, if no one else - and here's my guess as to who the likeliest candidates might be.

Harry Redknapp: Has already proved that he has what it takes to manage a club like Newcastle. He's won nowt and his team can't score at home. Bournemouth to North Shields, though... Too cold for the man, unless he takes full advantage of Mr Ashley's private jet.

Alan Shearer: Prefers the home comforts of the Match of the Day studio - and who can blame him?

Jose Mourinho: Unless the Special One has started smoking the Special Cigarettes, never in a million years.

Mark Hughes: Again he's won nowt but his teams can play when they forget about clogging and he'd have the overpaid nitwits working for each other.

Terry Venables: England No. 1, then England No. 2, then Newcastle gaffer. It's not looking good as a career path, Tel. Maybe wait a couple of years for St James's and give yourself a more prestigious job in the meantime - Port Vale could do with someone new.

Amy Winehouse: Unstable, unpredictable, liable to fall apart any moment, doesn't know owt about football, should suit Newcastle United down to the ground.

Steve McClaren: Free, relatively local, and whatever happens he'll keep smiling.

Fabio Capello: No chance. He's just delighted to find out that when people told him he had the toughest job in football they were lying.

J K Rowling: Writes fantasy books about boys with magical powers, maybe she could inject some creativity into the midfield pairing of Butt and Smith.

Kevin Keegan: A Phoenix-like return from KK? The fans'd just love it LOVE IT! if that happened. And at least he'd walk before you sacked him.

Paul Gascoigne: All right, his first attempt at management didn't work out so well but this is a challenge that could just suit him down to the ground - and don't forget this is a club that only recently entrusted the job to Glenn Roeder.

Ant 'n' Dec: Local lads made good. I can't see them getting their hands dirty. It's more likely to turn into some deathly reality show called summat like 'I'm a Non-Entity - Get Me Out Of Here' (first contestant to be voted out - Rozendal).

Robson Greene: That Wire in the Blood series is pretty nasty stuff but nothing compared with the carnage of the 4-1 trouncing against Pompey. Might have the stomach for it.

Tony Blair: Famously used to watch Jackie Milburn on the terraces before he was born. A true Toon Army soldier, he could raise a bit of finance by (a) getting his banking buddies involved, or (b) spending a bit of his own dosh.

The Toon Army themselves: Ebbsfleet Mark II. Since Ashley spends most of his time in amongst the fans in his barely credible one-of-the-lads charade, why doesn't he just let them have a proper say? Could it be any worse?

If all else fails, I'll have a bash. Obviously they're near-neighbours and deadly rivals so I'll do me best to bring the club to its knees as soon as possible. Though whether I'll do a better job at that than Ashley or Shepherd is very hard to imagine.

Seriously though, my money's on Mark Hughes being the next mug. I give him a fortnight.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Jan 12, 2008

Its quite refreshing to see so many Chelsea fans commenting about loyalty, coz there were sooooo many before Roman Abramovich took over.

Newcastle fans are loyal to their club, and quite rightly, our loyalty should be rewarded with football worth spending our money on. And is you had invested £350 million of your money in a club, would you want your money in the hands of someone you didnt want thiere, or would you want your own man in charge?

I dont think he should have been sacked until Febuary, when he have gotten some new players for us, and we have a legitimate reason to kick him out for getting us knocked out of the FA cup by Stoke. As it is, we have no manager, no newe players, a game at old trafford, and a crucial game at stoke.

Bring the next manager in quick, and leave him there with enough money to replace the aging and average players that we have got.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by kasbah (U3254321)

posted Jan 12, 2008

Newcastle do not stick with a manager long enough to actually make anything work - look at fergie, was manager of Man Utd for 5 years before he won anything, now look at them. Granted allardyce was not the choice of the new chairman, but i hope for newcastles case that he sticks with the next man for a few years and lets him build something.

As for newcastle being a big club - they haven't won anything except the inter toto cup in the last 40 years, not exactly the history of a top club is it? Liverpool are desparate for the premier league title - but at least their expectations to win the league are based on winning numerous other trophies since their last trophy. Newcastles expectations of success is built upon 50,000 turning up each week. answer this - are newcastle in a worse position this season under sam than they were 12 months ago under roeder? if i notice rightly newcastle are in no real danger of relegation unlike some times in recent years under previous managers.

Even my team, Leicester, have won more trophies in the last 40 years than newcastle.

As for Shearer - why would he risk his golden reputation by trying to manage newcastle? he is a legend at st james, why manage the club and risk being viewed as the legend he rightly is? also, what makes anyone think he can do it?! he has never managed another club, deciding instead to sit comfy on his MOTD sofa making wooden pre-scripted jokes with hansen and lineker.

somehow i think newcastle fans will not be happy until shearer is at the helm, no matter who the next manager is.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by kasbah (U3254321)

posted Jan 12, 2008

"would you want your money in the hands of someone you didnt want thiere, or would you want your own man in charge?

I dont think he should have been sacked until Febuary, when he have gotten some new players for us"

so if you were chairman you would give 10-20 million to the manager and then sack him immediately? leaving the new manager with a bunch of players who he doesn't want but who the club have only just bought?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 12, 2008

@kasbah, err i think newcastle will beat leicester trophies collection IF they play in the same league.

go leicester!

22 in the championship is a superb place to be!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 12, 2008

opps, my bad.

21st place in championship.

my point is - let newcastle do what they want, let the fan say what they want what they think because at the end of the day, they are the one who pay for the ticket.

fans of other team, just focus on supporting yr team. as much as you dont like people to talk abt your team, i guess the newcastle fan also appreciate the same sentiment.

and btw, if you are a sports journalist it's best not to take side - you need to be as neutral as possible.

cheers to all.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 13, 2008

I think Amy Winehouse is a good idea. She could also sing at the next newcastle Xmas do, so they would save a few quid on the entertainment as well.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 13, 2008

I'm not a Newcastle supporter but I can see they are a certainly big club in the true sense of the word. It's not just about winning trophies, ask Forest or Villa fans. Newcastle are in the top twenty clubs in Europe for annual revenue. That makes them very BIG.

The problem any Toon manager will face is persuading the overpaid tarts that play football these days that coming to the North East might not be like being sent to Siberia.

Initially I thought that Shearer would be a stupid appointment, no experience. But then how much experience did Mark Hughes have before taking over at Blackburn? At least giving Big Al the job would clear the air for his successor if he failed. But I think he might just succeed, given the backing he would get from the club and the crowd. Probably less of a risk than Sparky, in fact.

Whatever happens I hope they leave Harry Redknapp alone now. He's said no, that should be an end to it.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 13, 2008

Why should sports journalists be neutral? They're not writing the Times editorial but offering their OPINIONS, so by definition they are subjective not neutral.

And a little gentle ribbing never hurt anyone. If Newcastle fans can't take a little stick then maybe they should join the legion of Glory Hunters who decide to support ManU. I suspect quite a few already have after yesterday's debacle.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 14, 2008

Personally, I'd like to see Keegan back in action...

But then again, I'd love a surprise swoop for Carlos Quieroz! The guy knows his stuff, and is too good to remain in SAF's shadow.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 16, 2008

Kev ? Bev? bev ? kev ?

Bev ? kev ? Kev bev ?

Hmmmm We used to have a football club like that !

I'd Love it ; Just Love it !

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 61.70%
    58 votes
  • 4 10.64%
    10 votes
  • 3 5.32%
    5 votes
  • 2 5.32%
    5 votes
  • 1 17.02%
    16 votes

average rating:
3.95 from 94 votes