posted Jan 4, 2008

Great article Rick, glad someone can shed some light on who this fella is. I just hope he can deliver.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 4, 2008

This appointment looks excellent. We have too many ex Rugby greats who are poor managers in positions of authority. Maw's lack of a Rugby background also means there will be no conflict with Gatland on how to play Ruby.
good article

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 4, 2008

I love the way people knock this guy before he hasn't even started his job properly.. it's typical welsh narrow mindedness. Its good to see the WRU thinking outside the box and giving it to a neutral and not a 'yes man'.

Let's judge him on what happens in the future and give the bloke a chance.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 4, 2008

If he keeps the 'elite' players out of the pubs, we may have a chance this year. Drug and alcohol councillor's we need just as much as anything else!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 4, 2008

The background on Mr Maw was useful and time alone will tell if the WRU have made the right appointment.I expect many objective observers of the Welsh team-that excludes most of us in Wales-will have seen a decline in comparative fitness and skill levels or is it simply that other nations have got their acts together and overtaken us?If Mr Maw can arrest and reverse this decline I for one will be singing again,but it is an indictment of the running of the game in Wales if ex-internationals are so critical of the basic skills of the current crop of players,where has it all gone wrong and what does it say about the organisation of the professional game which has been in place for quite a few years now?
Has anyone actually seen the job description for the EPD post?
Despite my present gloom I wish Messers Gatland and Maw and the Welsh team every success for the next 6 Nations

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 4, 2008

So sad to hear Devereux & Hadley on Scrum 5 last night.The only surprise today is that our National Newspaper has yet to join the criticism.It can only be a matter of time!

Good Luck Graham - but watch your back.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 5, 2008

Good article, your iron man telephone call shed a bit more light on his credentials than I'd seen before. I feel optimistic about the appointment, lets just support the man and let him get on with his job. Getting an outsider (and true professional) in to cut through the bias and b/s will be a good thing.

I'm slightly more worried about Nigel Davies being kept on...is he supposed to be senior to Gatland in any way? If not, why is he there? If he is senior, err... Anyway, not sure what job Nigel Davies will actually be doing, but I wish him well.

As for Maw, I wish some former players would just give him a chance. When I was a kid, Hadley and Devereux were players I looked up to (until they went north, at which point I lost all interest, of course). Nowadays I'm not really interested in hearing their negative drivel, or that of Jonathan Davies. Just as excellent former players often fail as coaches / managers, it seems to me they often fail as pundits.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 5, 2008

I have to agree with Rick this can't be bad for Wales what we must not do though is expect this guy to be the be all and end all of our problems in Welsh rugby. I never believed in the need for this appointment but now it's here let's hope it works.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 5, 2008

Have to agree witrh Hanriverking regarding former players.Even Jonathan has become too cocky and was caught out badly on Scrum 5 with his comments on Andrew Hoare.It will take him a long time to live down that episode.

Anyway Maw looks like an inspired appointment and now that he is in the job everybody (former players included)need to get behind him and stop the sniping.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 7, 2008

Good article Rick. It is a shame that there is so much negativity about this appointment coming from the press and former players. We need to do something different and bring in new skills to gain an advantage over other nations.

Good to get some more background and the more I learn about Maw and the role the more I think it is a great appointment. Would be good if former players and the press took the time to do a bit more research about the man and the role instead of ridiculing him/it.

With Gatland and the other names being mentioned for the coaching team, it seems that we might finally be getting the right people in place to deliver some long-term success. Here’s hoping anyway!!

add comment | complain about this comment