BBC Home

Explore the BBC

1295 comments

user rating: 4 star

Capello fits bill perfectly for England

World Cup England
by philmcnultybbcsport (U1816352) 14 December 2007
comment on the article

Fabio Capello's appointment as England coach has been met with a predictable mixture of delight and despair.

Delight, not least within the Football Association, that the "world-class coach" promised after the Steve McClaren fiasco has been delivered so spectacularly.

Despair because that coach is Italian not English - a signal of the paucity of home-grown candidates suitable for the job.

Let's start with Capello before moving on to the latest bleatings of the "Little England" brigade.

Capello is a superb alternative to the popular choice Jose Mourinho, who prefers a return to club football as opposed to the international stage.

The FA has been criticised heavily here in the past - but this time credit is due for a brilliant appointment.

The much-decorated Italian will pursue success ruthlessly.

He has, gloriously, no time for the star system that has dragged England down, and has huge respect from peers such as Sir Alex Ferguson, Arsene Wenger and Rafael Benitez.

Capello will instil that respect, and no little fear, into an England squad who have lived in the comfort zone too long.

If England fail again, let fingers be pointed solely in the direction of their so-called stars because no-one can doubt the coach's knowledge and credentials.

Does it matter that he is not English? Should it matter that he is not English?

No and no.

If the identi-kit English candidate was in front of FA chief executive Brian Barwick's nose, he would undoubtedly have chosen him.

But where is he?

Steve Coppell, Gareth Southgate and Paul Ince have led the complaints, but the words sound hollow.

Who would they have?

Alan Curbishley and Sam Allardyce have no track record of winning trophies, while Ince even suggested Glenn Hoddle could be England coach, which only proves the old "Guv'nor" has a very short memory.

And then there is Harry Redknapp.

The same Redknapp who is doing brilliantly at Portsmouth, but who also claimed only two of the Croatian players that twice outshone England comprehensively would actually make this country's team.

If that is Redknapp's considered judgement on that particular episode, then he is best kept out of England affairs.

Redknapp is a superb juggler of playing talent at club level, but an England manager?

He would never have seriously registered on the FA's radar.

The naysayers also forget England have just had an English coach in Steve McClaren, nurtured as right-hand man to the previous incumbent, with predictably disastrous results.

Capello will apparently have an English coach on his staff. If this is a token gesture, then it must not happen.

This coach, as yet unknown, should not come in if Capello does not know him or want him.

It is only playing to the gallery and would be a waste of time and money.

Capello has a list of successes any potential English candidates can only dream about.

He is an outstanding choice - and it should also be stressed the FA, led by Barwick, has handled the succession to McClaren almost without fault.

The lack of up-and-coming English candidates is another matter.

And it is one that is hopefully being dealt with in the "root and branch" examination announced with such gravitas by FA chairman Geoff Thompson.

Let's hope one move is to reactivate the moth-balled Burton project as a training ground for emerging coaches and players.

Maybe Capello himself can be persuaded to spread some of his expertise around the English coaching community.

For now, however, the FA has appointed the best man for the job once Mourinho ruled himself out and the usual blizzard of mixed messages emerged about Martin O'Neill from various quarters in the Midlands.

Barwick would have appointed an Englishman had there been one out there worthy of the job.

There isn't - so the complaints must stop.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Dec 18, 2007

Exactly the major qualifiers ain till September 08 so he has plenty of time to learn & study our national league.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 18, 2007

Capello has in the past quickly learned the Spanish language. I know little English football, but if FA decided to take Capello will have good reasons.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by Ta5 (U5739538)

posted Dec 19, 2007

but if FA decided to take Capello will have good reasons.


**********

you give the FA way too much credit there.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 20, 2007

you give the FA way too much credit there.

*************

If I look at the results obtained by the national English in recent years, perhaps I should give you reason.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 20, 2007

I rlly can't believe some people are seriously suggesting glenn hoddle, steve coppell or paul ince over a manager who in his time has won more trophies than any of the potential english managers put together. who cares if he can't speak english yet? he wil lbe able to in a month or two. why not just get behind him? this is the problem with england, theres always something to complain about even when we've got a world class manager some supporters still aren't happy.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 10, 2009

Some of these comments look hilarious now.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by U8659606

posted Sep 10, 2009

This is what I posted. I have wisdom beyond my years winkeye

"It's very simple and should reflect any business - you appoint the best man available for the job. England have tried to do that and have a man with a fantastic record.

There are no Englishmen even close to being appointed in my view and I would be amazed if an Englishman made the shortlist. Not one English manager has won anything of significance recently (or even anything!!). No use blaming the 'lack of opportunities' either. If an Englishman could prove himself then he would be given the job at a top Premiership team I have no doubt. Ferguson had to work miracles at Aberdeen before getting the United job. So far Harry is the closest to being given a chance at a 'big club' but even then he would need to be extremely successful in order to make the shortlist.

That is the benchmark for the shortlist to become England boss. How on earth does finishing midtable with Newcastle (big Sam), midtable with West Ham (Curbs), never having managed before!!! (Shearer) and getting sacked from Man City (Pearce) get you considered!!"

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Oct 4, 2009

Just thought I would say well done and give you the gratification you seek. winkeye

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by U11846789

posted Aug 7, 2010

So here we are.

3 years on.

There has been no "root and branch" upheaval of the FA. The same old duffers still run it. Still pocket the cash.

Capello failed at the WC. He fell back on the same useless 11 players (more or less) that McUmbrella failed with.

The Sun - once again - bigged us up and rubbished everyone else. And - once again - got it totally wrong.

Wonder where we will be in 3 more years....












add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 58.33%
    105 votes
  • 4 9.44%
    17 votes
  • 3 3.89%
    7 votes
  • 2 2.78%
    5 votes
  • 1 25.56%
    46 votes

average rating:
3.72 from 180 votes