BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

639 comments

user rating: 3 star

Benitez playing dangerous game

Premier League Liverpool
comment on the article

Rafael Benitez's relationship with Liverpool owners George Gillett and Tom Hicks has been strained before - now it is close to breaking point.

Benitez delivered an extraordinary, exasperated performance at his media briefing before Liverpool's visit to Newcastle on Saturday.

He responded to questioning on a variety of topics by repeating that he was "focused on training and coaching my team" no fewer than 25 times.

Benitez was so agitated that he was even happy to link himself with the newly-vacated England job - a sure sign of any man's discontent.

So what is the truth behind the apparent breakdown in relations between Benitez and Anfield's American owners?

My understanding is that Hicks and Gillett were furious with Benitez's outburst, which they regard as unwarranted and undeserved.

And, contrary to reports, his incendiary reaction was not a response to a telephone call with the Americans shortly before the press conference.

Benitez has been told within the last three weeks that no transfer business - in or out - or any potential funding, will be discussed until Hicks and Gillett return to Merseyside from America in mid-December.

He has clearly stewed on this information and the lid came off at Liverpool's Melwood training headquarters in almost surreal circumstances.

Hicks and Gillett were similarly infuriated and mystified when Benitez, in an apparent fit of pique, launched an attack on them in the wake of the Champions League final defeat against AC Milan in Athens in May.

I believe that was forgiven, if not exactly forgotten, and even Thursday's outburst has not put his job in immediate jeopardy.

But if it was designed to shake the Americans off course from their original strategy of formulating all their transfer plans in December, it has backfired.

Benitez's very public show of petulance will not persuade Hicks or Gillett to shift their stance one inch.

There will be no discussions until mid-December whether Benitez likes it or not.

If that has made him question his position, so be it.

The ball is now firmly back in his court, but he can be in no doubt that he has not pleased his employers and they are sure to take a dim view if he delivers any more public criticism.

Hicks and Gillett believe they gave Benitez everything he wanted in the transfer market in the summer, even though it was a stretch on their planned transfer budget.

They feel the arrival of Fernando Torres, Yossi Benayoun and Ryan Babel demonstrated their commitment.

This is a point for debate among Liverpool supporters, with some suggesting he recouped plenty back from sales, but this is the view across the Atlantic.

Benitez has since come up with a number of transfer targets that he wishes to pursue and has expressed fears to the Anfield hierarchy that he could miss out.

Hicks and Gillett want to sit down in December and formulate a clear plan. There will be no scatter-gun spending.

Rather than back down in the face of increasing and regular pressure from Benitez, I am told his latest broadside left the American pair almost having to be scraped off the ceiling in rage.

Their message to Benitez was to stay silent and get on with the business of coaching and winning games between now and December - then they will talk business.

They feel their request that Benitez waits until December to discuss matters further is perfectly reasonable - a view clearly not shared by their manager.

Benitez is no stranger to the politicking of football. He had similar problems at Valencia over transfer targets.

But I understand the Americans will not be budged, leaving Benitez to either bite his tongue and wait or continue to publicly berate the club's owners.

If he fails to take the hint, it may well be that Benitez might pursue his ambitions elsewhere.

Benitez, despite his benign public image, is a ruthless, single-minded, sore loser - no problem with that.

He also remains a highly-popular figure with Liverpool fans, although that might alter if they fail to reach the Champions League knockout phase.

But Hicks and Gillett feel they have played fair with Benitez, a feeling not reciprocated by the Spanish manager.

Benitez may have the last word, but a major diplomatic incident has been sparked by his criticism and he needs results more than ever as Liverpool enter a crucial phase of their campaign.



Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Nov 25, 2007

"However, I am surprised that Benitez perseveres with some of his squad. Both full backs are relatively static and, in a tight game at least, they provide little or no support to the mid-field or attack."

Six goals conceded, none from headers...which you need crosses to score.

Yup. Our full-backs are a LIABILITY.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 25, 2007

This is a deliberate ploy by Rafa so he can leave before Liverpool are inevitably knocked out of Europe next week.

He's bottled it.

Stupid child.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 25, 2007

Six goals conceded, none from headers...which you need crosses to score.
Yup. Our full-backs are a LIABILITY.
-----------------------------------------------
Except Hyypia. Time for him to retire.
He was miserable against Everton and the other day against spurs, he let Berbatov gift Keane with two vicious headers that led to two lethal goals.

Rafa's issue is very critical for LFC,cos if he quits now after just another "misunderstanding" of that kind with the owners, it would mean only one thing, Rick parry and co have never seriously committed themselves to LFC's future. DIC would've been better in that case.One billion dollars would've been just peanuts for them...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 25, 2007

I have it on good authority that Fat Rafa will resign in the morning and be announced as the next Birmingham manager by the end of the week.

You gotta feel sorry for Birmingham fans. Their season just goes from bad to worse.laugh

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by boz0413 (U6815901)

posted Nov 25, 2007

I agree with the point of view that the media have got wind of this story and blown it up bigtime.

It just adds to the list of monotonous garbage they have reported about Liverpool recently. Do the phrases 'rotation policy', 'Gerrard and Rafa rift', 'Gerrard on the right', 'zonal marking' ring any bells?

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by U8754772

posted Nov 26, 2007

Phil McNumpty - you have had another shocker.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 26, 2007

You Liverpool fans should have a bit more patience. At the end of the day, Hicks and Gillett didn't appoint Benitez, so straight away the relationship is gonna be tested. From what I can see Liverpool have a very good squad. I struggle to understand what major improvements your squad needs. The owners have got you some good players and backed Benitez. You've got Torres and Babel amongst others. You're also getting a brand new stadium, which from the design, I'm very impressed with. So have a bit of patience. Surely you'd rather have Hicks and Gillett than sulky, never-speaks-to-the-press Abramovich. You underestimate how popular football is becoming in the states. Most games get 18,000 on average. With LA and New York getting 30,000 sometimes. Which for a sport considered comparable to Netball over here is pretty good. If my team was taken over my foreign owners I'd like them to be American. At least they speak english as a first language.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 26, 2007

Outsider looking in -

Rafa never seems to be happy with his squad. What does he hope to do? He seems to just keep buying in players in the hope that bingo he'll find a player that will make the difference. He cant even keep the squad the same over a season (ok few dont but its within reason) never mind a settled starting 11.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 26, 2007

£7m for Gerrard?!? One bad game doesn't make you a bad player, I think Saturday showed that.
I would imagine that every premiership manager would find a place in their midfield for him, but bad luck, he is staying where he is for the rest of his career!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Nov 26, 2007

LoyalRed,I think you have failed to understand what the whole thread is about!

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article


RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 34.21%
    39 votes
  • 4 10.53%
    12 votes
  • 3 11.40%
    13 votes
  • 2 6.14%
    7 votes
  • 1 37.72%
    43 votes

average rating:
2.97 from 114 votes