posted Sep 26, 2007

If you want proper cricket - a real, thoughtful, evolving, strategic game, you've got Test Cricket which is and must remain the pinnacle of the game. If you want fast, action-packed, cheap thrill cricket you've got 20-20.

So what is the point of the 50 over game?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

As a fairly newish cricket fan I think the 50 over ODI's are more entertaining for genuine sport fans.

20-20 is all about the entertainment factor, Im sure it has it's place but to me games always looked in the balance no matter who appeared well on top.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

Let's say that in a 50 over game the team batting first scores 300 runs. The team batting second lose early wickets, say 50 - 4. Ninety-nine times out of a hundred it's game over with hours and hours of play to go. And the chances of a tie are miniscule. There are certainly examples of teams fighting back from these sorts of positions, I can think of England and New Zealand doing it recently. But so often games are one and lost with only half the play gone. The recent England/India series was great, but I honestly can't remember the last time I saw a genuinely competitive ODI series before that.

In a twenty over game, even if it is hopelessly one sided (Sri Lanka vs Kenya anyone...) it's still all over in 2 1/2 hours. And most of the time because it is only 20 overs long one side can never really get an 'un-chaseable' score.

Test cricket will always remain the pinnacle of the game, but give it a few years a Twenty20 will be it's main currency and cricket's best chance of breaking into new countries.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

I agree 100%.

T20 is good. But please stop all the nonsense about it replacing one-day cricket.

The ODI World Cup was badly managed. No fault of the ODI format.

Let all the three formats co-exist.

To each his own.

For me, it will always be first Tests, then ODI and then finally T20.

You cannot ask people who love the game to give up tests or ODI just so that aliens in China or US pick up the game.

I love my cricket and no one should take away my choice.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

20/20 is rank. I was violently sick off it once and the thought of it now turns me pale. As for its place in cricket, it can only be a good thing. For instance Michael Vaughen would be a lot more intersting if he was mashed up on 20/20 big styley.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

Aquaticjay

The world so far has learnt to play cricket without the need for 20/20; countries in South America, North America, Africa, Europe, Asia, Australasia. So it's already a world game - where were you?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

Excellent column in the Guardian

http://blogs.guardian.co.uk/sport/2007/09/26/great_win_but_easy_on_the_ches.html

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

"S Burrito" hehe, lol addicted_7

"...up and down the hills and so on - for about a day chasing an inflated pig's bladder. The shortened version has become more popular."
- Audiern that's simply hillarious

Nice article M-P, packed with cracking quotes...

"Pakistunned" "Karachi Captured"
clearly they've recruited some hacks from The Sun.

"...self-congratulatory air, chest-thumping patriotism and a nouveau-riche swagger that would shame Chelsea FC evoke disturbing comparisons with another country across the Atlantic that thinks the world begins and ends within its borders"

so, exactly the same demeanour that OZi, SAF or ENG would adopt had they won!

"..they strung together four back-to-back victories - against clueless England and then the three best teams in the competition, South Africa, Australia and Pakistan"

clueless England !! lololo on careful reflection we really did suck the big burrito!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 26, 2007

Schrodinger's Beretta

you are in a jolly mood! Welcome on the article enjoyed it too


ok I will bite,

is the Schrodinger in your monicker from German physicist Schrodinger as in Schrodinger's Equations?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Sep 27, 2007

good this make cricket fans to get a chnace to share their fellings about cricket and about their favourite team

add comment | complain about this comment