McLaren - to appeal or not?Formula One by Arkimsa (U3871417) 20 September 2007 In an ideal world, McLaren should appeal the size of their penalty. Yes Coughlan had the document but info like when Kimi was pitting didn't come from that document.It was just F1 as usual - as PDLR explained. That should not be punishable. Latest 10 commentsRead members' comments or add your own
comment by
Massirati (U8718377) posted Sep 28, 2007 Ajroldi! That is why I spelt it wrong in the first place! If you were italian as you claim to be you would have known what I was referring to - hence my theory that you had to ask someone and couldn't get a online translation to know what this means!
comment by
CycloneArmageddon (U6455759) posted Oct 1, 2007 If Ron Dennis thought the team was innocent he would appeal. If he thought they were guilty he would accept the verdict and pay the $100M. Which did he do?
comment by
nobleSusannah (U9289311) posted Oct 1, 2007 Mclaren did NOT spy! They were GIVEN a document! IF they used information from this what did they do wrong? Nothing I perceive. If you were handed the answers to a test paper in advance how many of you would NOT look at it? Honest answers only please!!
comment by
akaPhantomOfTheOpera (U9747373) posted Oct 2, 2007 nobleSusannah >> you either have the innocence of a child or you are being disingenious
comment by
akaPhantomOfTheOpera (U9747373) posted Oct 2, 2007 there must be zero tolerance to cheats/spying/infringement of rules irrespective of which team is at fault
comment by
zanyzannad (U9107098) posted Oct 3, 2007 Many Macca fans still don't realize the gravity and the impact of the recent spystory scandal.
comment by
chrisc_w (U1955210) posted Oct 5, 2007 Lest the BBC appear to be approving of the increasing obviously wrong and biased decision to penalise McLaren when it is clear that Ferrari had the same access to confidential McLaren information PLEASE in the constructors standings can you show the points McLaren actually won on the track. The fact is they are the best team and silly tantrums byt the FIA cannot change that fact.
comment by
zanyzannad (U9107098) posted Oct 6, 2007 "when it is clear that Ferrari had the same access to confidential McLaren information"
comment by
oversteer27 (U10244423) posted Nov 8, 2007 Having read the transcript of the case, nothing was proven in the case against McLaren. The fine and exclusion was based on circumstancial evidence and was too severe in my opinion. Comment on this article |