BBC Home

Explore the BBC

Browse: Boxing

111 comments

user rating: 4 star

'Super fight' fails to match hype

by bendirs (U1657561) 07 May 2007
comment on the article

Floyd Mayweather delivered, in his words, a "masterpiece of boxing" in defeating Oscar de la Hoya in Las Vegas on Saturday.

But while the purists were drooling over "Pretty Boy's" technical proficiency, the sporting hoi polloi must have been wondering what all the fuss was about.

For boxing didn't need an under-stated Monet at the MGM Grand, what it needed was a riotous Tracey Emin, something to get those all-important crossover fans buzzing about the sport again.

To blame Mayweather for the fight not living up to the hype, as many pundits have decided to do, is a little harsh.

True, Mayweather spent the four months leading up to the bout promising a "toe-to-toe war", but anyone who had seen him fight previously should have known that was unlikely to transpire.

Boxing is always a war of sorts, but why volunteer for shelling on the front line when you can safely conduct the battle from range?

Mayweather, like Roy Jones before him, is too good for his own good, able to win fights without getting his senses scrambled.

But it is that defensive bent that will prevent him going down alongside the two Sugar Rays, who he name checks so often, as one of the all-time greats.

Both Robinson and Leonard knew that entertainment was part of the deal.

Stand and fight and the crowds will love you. Skirmish on the periphery and they will always be suspicious.

What now, then, for both fighters? Mayweather has reiterated his intention to retire, but most think it unlikely he will stick to his word.

Only 30 and steeped in the sport from birth, it is inconceivable that he'll be gone for long, bored of his inactivity and vexed by the myriad gauntlets that are sure to be scattered about his feet.

De la Hoya is undecided about his future, but it is difficult to see what he has to gain from remaining in the sport.

A six-weight world champion, he has upwards of £75m in the bank and nothing left to prove, unless, of course, a rematch with Mayweather can be negotiated.

The frightening part for boxing is that for perhaps the first time in the sport's history, without De la Hoya, there are no genuine "super-fights" to make.

The big beasts in the heavyweight division have gone for now, and like some exotic animal on the brink of extinction, he is the sport's last remaining crossover superstar.

With the rowdy spectacle of Ultimate Fighting killing boxing in terms of pay-per-view sales in America and the proliferation of titles and champions showing no sign of abating, Mayweather-De la Hoya was never going to be anything but a short-term fillip for boxing.

Like a gravely ill man being administered shock treatment, the sport sprung up from his hospital bed, gasped loudly, and will now fall back into its slumber.

The stars were out in force in Vegas on Saturday, but by the time the next "super-fight" rolls round, there is a possibility Jack Nicholson will be watching it from a Hollywood nursing home and Michael Jordan will be four or five inches shorter.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted May 12, 2007

Ever been knocked out? Boxing belongs to the Dark Ages-to the world of the Aeneid, to mediaeval battles.
Skill is involved, but study motor accidents. The effects are the same.
I could have been a contender, but thought better of it.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 13, 2007

Finally got to view the fight with ODH and PBF and think it was very boring as predicted as neither fighter impressed.
If PBF is the best it shows that boxing is in deep trouble, as all this guy could do was dodge around an aging has been who has lost both speed and stamina to say nothing of timing.
Both should donate a large portion of their purse to charity at least Dick Turpin wore a mask,
A rematch DONT MAKE ME LAUGH.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by bjlover (U7512192)

posted May 15, 2007

the article is obviously written by someone who is campaigning against the very sport itself, trying to talk down the excitement, skill and flare of a big fight like it was. There seems to be a general consensus against boxing. I definately agree it's up to the promoters to cut deals with free view TV channels rather than pay per view, that way opening up the sport to a wider audience.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 19, 2007

I love a good fight and have watched many classic boxing fight over the years but i have been left very frustrated by a sport that has always been controled badley with the only decisons made in the favour of the peolpe making the most money,Im really enjoying watching UFC and MMA fight because there is so much to watch you have a much greater chance of at least seeing some entertaining fights every month but im already sceptical to some of the match ups being organised as it looks like they are starting to follow boxings platform of protecting fighters until they can make as much money as possible.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 19, 2007

to be honest when we have so may variations of a world title, it kind of fragments the brain and when we see supposedly world champions ducking other world champions who is deffo up for it and unify the boxing world.. barreas fantastic world champion, holyfield, mahn he has the heart of a warrior for sure, lewis, technically awesum, personally i think he was a bit audley if ya get me, chavez real go getter, and that Julio not hugo :D. too much hyoe in boxing, too much moly coddling going on which is bad for the boxer let alone us fans,

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 24, 2007

Promoters control boxing, they put the fights together that will make the most money and gie the most exposure to their boxer... Champions shoulf fight 3 times a year. One against the mandatory challenger,one against a champion in there own division and then if they want to step up a weight anc challenge another champion then they can. As much as I like Calzage I think he should fight Kessler next.. .Unify the Super-Middle division and then go chasing a figth at Light-heavy. Taylor is the example of a fighter who demands put him out of reach. Fans want to see the best meet up in proper super fights

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 31, 2007

bottom line is big boxers never fight each other whilst ufc top names meet on a rgular basis

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 31, 2007

the main thing is boxing is in serious trouble as UFC/others are taking over in popularity all across the world and this superfight had failed to stop the rot

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 31, 2007

UFC is just a fad and soon the novalty will wear thin and then fans will be drawn back to boxing as we have exciting fighters like david haye stepping up and hopefully bringing back some excitment for british boxing. It is only a matter of time untill a new era comes around and some big rivalrys are born and although not much could top the days of leonard and hagler and benn and eubank soon money will have to take a back seat and it will be fights that take centre stage because if it doesnt boxing would be finished and i dont believe anyone with a love for the sport would let that happen.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 5, 2007

Promters have and will continue to drain the sport to line there pockets. Maybe MMA is a fad (Though the fad has been running good profits and PPV sales for 5-7 years), but they are the only combat sport that is gaining in popularity. I will always watchboxing to a certain extent, but I do not get the sametype of action the MMA almost always gives. MMA fights can be short, but you get 9-12 fights per pay per view. The only thing that will save boxing is to get it out of the hands of the promoters. 1 Belt per division and mandatory fights. Unfortuantely I do not see Don King or Bob Arum giving up the loads of cash to save the sport.

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 56.52%
    13 votes
  • 4 13.04%
    3 votes
  • 3 13.04%
    3 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 17.39%
    4 votes

average rating:
3.91 from 23 votes