BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

970 comments

user rating: 4 star

McClaren no nearer credibility

International football
comment on the article

Steven Gerrard spared Steve McClaren from a humiliation that would have cost him his job as England coach, but left a man seemingly out of his depth with a new headache.

Frank Lampard's broken wrist allowed McClaren to make a decision he seemingly lacks the nerve to take himself - namely put Gerrard in central midfield.

McClaren has foolishly refused to play a man with claims to be the world's best central midfield player in central midfield.

And perversely, England's coach may have been glad to have his folly so brutally exposed in exchange for a win that stopped his dismissal.

Gerrard silenced the abuse of frustrated England fans and at least left McClaren in his post for a while longer with an inspirational driving display in the centre.

So what does McClaren do next?

Restore Lampard? The coach's lack of imagination suggests he probably might.

Take Gerrard and a bright debut from Preston North End's David Nugent out of the equation, and this was another desperate night for McClaren and England.

The first 45 minutes was as embarrassing as it gets as England were reduced to niggling with Andorra's selection of part-timers while their supporters heaped abuse on them from the terraces.

And for McClaren and the Football Association, they must have squirmed at the level of discontent that descended from the stands as England's torture increased with every passing second of the opening period.

John Terry suggested the fans should save their opinions until the final whistle.

Dream on John.

They had every right to pour vitriol on what they saw in Barcelona after paying good money to watch the dreadful fare that was served up.

This England team does not deserve blind loyalty - they have had enough of this in the past and there is no credit left in the bank.

And this 3-0 win, earned eventually on the back of Gerrard's outstanding display, will not dilute the feeling that McClaren has been promoted well above his powers.

Rarely has an England coach united the nation's opinion so firmly against him so early in his reign.

He has a public image problem in that he was an unpopular choice and is regarded as a purveyor of meaningless soundbites rather than someone of footballing substance.

And when the England team he sends out takes 53 minutes to unlock Andorra, his footballing credibility takes a bashing as well.

McClaren may still sit in Soho Square after this - but he will sit uneasily and with England's footballing public no nearer being convinced he is up to the job after another wretched display.

If Gerrard was the catalyst, what are we to make of the latest appalling effort from Wayne Rooney?

This great hope of English football was so unnerved and rattled by someone called Oscar Sonejee that he was effectively hauled off after an hour to avert the danger of a red card.

True Rooney was roughed up, but it seems he cannot respond with his talent.

He responds with his mouth and by getting involved in a succession of petty spats before a face-saving and ridiculous removal.

It has happened to Rooney with England before and says nothing good about his temperament.

If he is being taken off to spare him against the might of Andorra, you can bet that message will get around Europe for games ahead after he has served a well-deserved suspension.

Rooney has been cut plenty of slack on the back of his performances at Euro 2004 and for Manchester United, but it is time he got his head and his act together for England.

It is unlikely McClaren - who cut a lone figure when England arrived at the stadium and appeared ill-at-ease throughout - will find the headlines any more palatable after scrambling past Andorra.

Sadly, it is a verdict that will be justified as McClaren stumbles on, unpopular and lacking inspiration.

And if there was an extra gloss on his praise for Gerrard after the final whistle, it was because he is the reason he is still England coach.






Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Mar 30, 2007

Midlands Gooner - yeah, I DID have the miserable experience of reading what little b------- excuses that McClaren had in his new attempt to try and save his own neck from being wrung like a chicken at an abattoir. Makes for really good toilet paper, beacuse I'm afraid that is all it is good for. Utter rubbish!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 30, 2007

That's a terrible team. Nuggent is Division 1, you need your head testing if you think he s best than Rooney and Owen

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 30, 2007

The England national squad fans should understand that your team lacks the quality and determination to make an impact on the international level. The Premier League is one of the top leagues in Europe, along with Primera Division in Spain, but mostly due to the quality of foreign players.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 30, 2007

Yes, Scholes was a great player for England - but it's too late now.

You serious expect him to come back on the international stage now? He's retired, and probably made the right decision. I honestly can't see him coming back.

We've got to focus on what we do have - not think about the past.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 30, 2007

bothkennar, u are clearly missing the point, i am no hooligan, and indeed tennis is my first sport, however to congratulate the overpaid prma donnas is a disgrace, they lack pride passion and respect, they forget it is the HUMBLE fan who hjas put them where they are, i say go back to wage capping. They are a disgrace and deserve every bit of criticism until they smarten themselves up. Forget results, their general attitude and mentality, even their appearence when they get off the team coach was simply arrogant and disrespectful...They are representing their country, not their school team, i have been fortunate to do so in tennis, and was very honoured, and did not view myself above the country as these uneducated slobs do. Indeed i believe they threw a tantrum when they where not allowed out clubbing after the israel game! They should have been embarassed and ashamed...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 31, 2007

I shouldn't have said "Russian" linesman ... he was Soviet, of course. Major point. My mistake.

And of course, at 2-3 the German side obviously played exactly the same way as they would have (continued to do so) at 2-2.

"Most England fans were actually bewildered when the FA got rid of Terry Venables and Glenn Hoddle in quick succession, prematurely and for ridiculous reasons." - I don't recall the press being bewildered.

"With regard to Sven-Goran Eriksson -most fans were happy with him until Euro 2004 but then felt that his contract should not have been renewed after that." - The words "hunt" and "witch" come to mind when I think of Svennis and his time in England.

"Obviously 'the whole world' is unaware that England is not a 'little island' but is part of a little island." To everyone outside your little island, this is completely irrelvant - we simply don't care!

"No-one in England thinks that we have 'an automatic right to win every four years'. This could be a case of what psychologists might call 'transference'" - I think you have a word for this comment. It sounds something like the castrated male cow? Begins with a B, I think.

"When I was a kid in the 1970s England didn't even qualify for world cups - let alone think of winning them." I too recall a certain Mr Tomacewski! There was little justice that year, however.

"The final score was 4-2." Irrelevant, see above.

"Agreed. The Olympics are an expensive white elephant." Well, at least we agree on something!

"I support the bid of Australia 2018. That'll be good for the game." Ah, two things!

"Well a German manager might be good for England. Although I'd prefer someone like Jurgen Klinsmann" He should coach the diving team, not a fottball team! I hate cheats. You have a good word for him too. Something about little boys' habits in the bathroom, I think.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 31, 2007

"Most England fans were actually bewildered when the FA got rid of Terry Venables and Glenn Hoddle in quick succession, prematurely and for ridiculous reasons." - I don't recall the press being bewildered.



This is precisely the point. The UK media does not reflect the views of England fans.


"With regard to Sven-Goran Eriksson -most fans were happy with him until Euro 2004 but then felt that his contract should not have been renewed after that." - The words "hunt" and "witch" come to mind when I think of Svennis and his time in England.



Ditto the above regarding the difference between the UK media and England fans. Any scepticism from England fans towards Eriksson only came after Euro 2004 when his increasingly bizarre selection and substitution decisions began to raise concerns.


"Obviously 'the whole world' is unaware that England is not a 'little island' but is part of a little island." To everyone outside your little island, this is completely irrelvant - we simply don't care!



And there were the Scots and the Welsh believing that continental hearts beat warmly for them.


"When I was a kid in the 1970s England didn't even qualify for world cups - let alone think of winning them." I too recall a certain Mr Tomacewski! There was little justice that year, however.



Yes. And the England players in that qualifier against Poland literally played their socks off (unlike so many of their present-day counterparts). The Polish goal was under constant bombardment for virtually the whole match. God and Tomasewski, however, had decided that England would not be going to Deutschland'74.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 31, 2007

HortsRadisch - I can safely assume that you ARE German, and that the result of Wembley 1966 DID hurt you and your fellow countrymen a lot at the time, and there ARE still a lot of German fans who still say that the third goal did NOT go over the goal line...but the history books say it DID, the FIFA websites say it DID, and every English fan say it DID. If it had happened the other way around, don't tell me that you would not have said, "Yes, yes! We did it! We scored! GOAL!" It's a debate that will go on forever, but it is NOT GOING TO CHANGE ANYTHING - NOT NOW, NOT EVER! That's it! Over! History! The end! Good night!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Apr 4, 2007

comment by eh?
posted 6 Days Ago

skarocker,

Roy Keane was one of the best players to ever touch a football, his goal-scoring record was not as good as Lampard's. Its not all about goals, its what you do for the team....

Don't know if you've ever noticed but the whole point of football is to score the most goals & therefore win...Roy Keane was just a thug..but then again, most footballers would lose an intelligence contest up against a bag of minced beef

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 64.80%
    127 votes
  • 4 14.80%
    29 votes
  • 3 5.61%
    11 votes
  • 2 2.04%
    4 votes
  • 1 12.76%
    25 votes

average rating:
4.17 from 196 votes