BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in
Browse: Football

86 comments

user rating: 4 star

Standing is fun and safe, ask the Germans

by Matt Slater (U1647490) 17 March 2007
comment on the article

A few days ago I wrote a news story about the campaign for bringing back safe standing areas to top-flight football in England.

I also wrote a comment piece where I argued that I thought it was time - 18 years after Hillsborough - to, at the very least, discuss whether we should give fans the freedom to decide if they want to sit or stand.

The news story was read by about 250,000 people on Wednesday and well over 200 people joined the debate on 606.

The overall quality of the comments in that debate suggested that this is a subject a great many of you feel strongly about, for and against.

The comments also seemed to support recent surveys that have shown a large majority in favour of bringing back safe standing areas.

There was, it must be said, a sizeable minority (20-25%) opposed to any change to the all-seater requirement in England's top two divisions.

I understand their fears about safety and their reluctance to go back to what many described as "the bad old days", I only wonder if they have fully grasped what it is pro-standing groups the Football Supporters' Federation and Stand Up Sit Down are proposing. They don't want to go back to the bad old days again either, and neither do I.

They want choice. Those that want to sit can sit. Without somebody bobbing up and down in front of them all game.

Those that want to stand, make a bit more noise, move around a bit and do so without being scowled at by seated fans and stewards, can stand. And hopefully at a more reasonable price than they are currently being charged for their sliver of cold plastic.

And they don't want to stand in the caged pens of yesteryear - with their crumbling steps and insufficient crush barriers. They want to stand in properly maintained, well constructed sections with all of today's crowd control mod cons.

But I don't really want to go over the same territory as the initial debate again - if you have any interest in this subject please take some time to look through the comments.

The question I want to ask now is what you all think about Germany's experience with standing areas. They refused to follow the all-seater herd post-Hillsborough, insisting that standing was a vital part of German football fan culture.

As a result, Germany has a collection of fine modern footballing stadia all with at least 10% of their capacity reserved for standing. They have loud, passionate fans - of both sexes and all ages - who pay far less for their tickets than we do. And they also have a perfect safety record.

And to think that former Sports Minister Tony Banks was told by the FA to shut up about bringing back terraces during the bidding process for the 2006 World Cup as it would hurt our chances with Fifa. In terms of "intelligence" given to Labour ministers in recent years that is not as calamitous as the nuggets of information about Iraq's WMD, but it is almost as daft. Fifa, of course, handed the World Cup to Germany.

A recent FSF fact-finding mission to see how it is done in the Bundesliga came back with some interesting observations. But also some slightly depressing ones.

They pay less, they look happier, they don't get in each other's way, they make more noise and they have a closer bond with their team.

Why are they getting it so right when we're getting it so wrong?

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Mar 20, 2007

We cant bring back standing until the authorities come out and say who was actually at fault at hillsborough. The has not been a satisfactory conclusion to any enquiry into why it happened.
That aside I stood on the kop for years in the late sixties and early seventies and I can honestly say that I never saw more than 80% of a match. Even worse I Only ever saw about 30% of the goals scored at the kop end. No to standing.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 20, 2007

It really sadens me to see whats happening to english football and its once glorious atmoshpere. Where did all the great supporters go? Liverpool with its singing crowd now remains the only place that conservates what is known in germany as the english atmosphere - a term we used to use with great respect. When ticket prices went up in germany a few years ago and some clubs started reducing the standing areas, the standing fans started chanting songs like "you're just here to gorge yourselves" to the VIP "supporter" areas or "You destroy the clubs character" adressing the management. The clubs realized that they need to take care of the simple mans desires in order to keep football a mass-audience attraction with its special atmosphere as opposed to most other sports.

One thing that certainly helps over here is a law that a sports club is a sports club and not a normal company one can buy and rule over - the president is elected by the clubs members. Therefore, we don't have the abramovichs, berlusconis and glazers around here trying to turn clubs into toys or profit engines banning supporters who won't spend 50€ on food and merchandise each game and scaring of the event-crowds.

German football may not be competitive to the english, spanish or italian league financially, but at least it remains in the hand of the ordinary fan. When the league discussed the latest tv contract, the public pressure ensured that we would not spread match days to more than 3 kick-off times or adopt to asian tv prime-time to gain international revenue. National pay-tv had also long tried to pull football out of free-tv's hands (currently, free-tv shows 10 minute summaries of each game about 1 hour after the games) in order to increase prices and make football the catch-product for the rest of the crap they sell.

What I'm trying to say in way to many words here is: English football has sold its soul and it is time for the fans to take back what once belonged to them. Romantic? Sure! Unrealistic? Maybe! Worth a try? Definitely.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 20, 2007

ALL THIS TALKING ON 606 MEANS NOTHING WE NEED TO ORGANISE OURSELVES INTO A PRESSURE GROUP...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 20, 2007

marathon9

get on standupsitdown.co.uk and visit their forum

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Mar 20, 2007

CHEERS IRONMARVIN

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by owls05 (U7852612)

posted Mar 20, 2007

I think standing should be allowed i certain areas. The authorities can test these to see if the are safe. This would bring the atmosphere back to the stadiums. I am fed up at being told to sit down, its football and people are used to standing up. Seating should still be kept for the people that want to sit.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 15, 2007

Ref: glosterguy35
Don`t be a mug mate If people want to stand they should be allowed to...........you post `96 fans don`t have an idea about what real atmosphere`s were like back in the 70`s and 80`s. ther was nothing like it.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 30, 2007

OK, Lets look at it this way...why can you stand up in division 1 in England, but not in the championship?..
Why can you go to a new rugby ground such as Warrington, and stand on terracing?..
Why can you go and watch a concert at Man Citys ground ie Oasis and the week after be made to sit down?..
The reason is the middle classes have got into the working class game of football and used their contacts and influence to steal it from under our noses...ie the carve up of tickets for the FA cup final.
I'm one of the tens of thousands that hasn't renewed my ST at Man City next season (ok, forget about the rubbish football we were playing!!) If you ask any fan over say 30 why are they losing their interest in the game, the atmosphere has gone..the kick off times are forever changed at short notice..you can't just turn up and see a game with some mates as you are all sat in different places.
XMas and Easter my family from all over the country would meet up and go and watch a game, pay on the gate, stand together, go for a pint together etc...you try doing this now, its a logistical nightmare.. Now if I want to take a son, nephew,niece etc with their friends I can't do it.
One idea is unreserved seating..but if I'm right, you cannot have this in the Prem either, is this right?..can someone tell me?..
Cheers.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted May 30, 2007

I am not that old but i remember my first football match and it was Republic of Ireland Vs Brazil 1987 in the south terrace of lansdowne road. The buzz I got from standing there amongst men and feeling like I was part of it sealed the deal.

Over the last 8 years I had been a regular at celtic park and the only days the buzz was high was on European nights and Old Firm day and as for a Wigan Vs Charlton game at JJb. I thought I had gone to purgatory I was so bored.

I truly believe the way to get the games back to the fans is via safe and well maintained terracing. We now have the network in place to better manage ticket allocation and also the turnstiles have been modernised to cope.

My suggestion would be for the premiership max of 20,000 place terracing for home fans and an allocated space of a 5,000 capacity for away fans.

By the way welcometogermany06 great piece.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jun 12, 2007

Spoke to the Minister today who claimed Safe terracing could not be considered on the basis of a debrief in Stuttgart there.
As the Germans allegedly had hooliganism problems in their domestic fixtures? Does anyone know anything about this?!
Or would it be a sop.....

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 73.91%
    17 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 26.09%
    6 votes

average rating:
3.96 from 23 votes