posted Jan 10, 2007

Im sorry but thats a load of rubbish saying Dudeks had no action for weeks! He's been playing in the reserves for weeks, and that is by no means filled with the dros it used to be. Its got alot of quality in it, and has experience there occasionally too.
Yes I agree it isnt the same, but he is match fit. If he's still got it, then he should show it.

I think the biggest problem was his co-ordination with the defence. A few times he didnt control his box in the air when he certainly should have done. also the amount of gaps that showed from being stretched was un-believable! Reina and Carson both help the defence out, but its as if dudeks forgotten because he certainly used to do it!

I dont care what they say though. Arsenal will NOT be happy to have conceded 3 in return.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 14, 2007

this depate about dudek makes no sense to me. dudek always flobed on big games most of the times. u dont need anyone telling you that the both games were massive for dudek. hence he flobs.
about the young goal keeper. how can you be against that. i will tell you why we are buying him - because is is a young good goalkeeper. carson or no carson, liverpool always need quality young players and that includes goalkeepers. from from what i hear this guy is a great acquisition for the club and its not like we got great keepers too in reina, carson (good keepers but not great) and dudek. and one more thing- how many keepers would a club like liverpool need to have. most of u seem to think only two. i wonder why. is it because you see the new keeper as threat to carson (an english keeper) place on the squad. if carson has quality let him fight and earn for his place.
about banitez. everyone makes mistakes. his mistake was not selling dudek last summer.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 14, 2007

i think we should give valencia reina in the david villa deal and install carson as our number 1 with padelli, he has proved himself this season at charlton his performances have been outstanding, yes he might of let in a lot of goals but that has mainly been due to bad defending and if it weren't for him charlton would be on nil points, dudek is usless and has been for a long time, only reason he was number one 2 seasons ago was due to kirklands injury problems, carson has a bright future ahead of him and if he is giving the chance next season would claim the england no.1 shirt from robinson who is ot exactley world class.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 15, 2007

yeah this is a good signing

I like it when liverpool buy young players for the future and Daniele Padelli and carson is the future...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 15, 2007

I see that Reina is once again top of the premiership in terms of clean sheets. Just like last season. And he's still only what, 23? I'm sick of all these cleansheets, lets sack him off and bring in another keeper.

I'm sorry, but anyone who claims that Pepe is a 'poor keeper' is off his head. He's a great talent who suits our play style well, and he's still only young. Certainly one of Rafa's better signings.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 15, 2007

'he might not want to buy blacks for some reason,it's ok to some extent, infact i am not objecting that,but it may be helpful.'

Did i read that right?

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 16, 2007

yeah what you are saying it is true why do they bring in another one.Because now two keepers are on loan it dose not hlep at all. Bring a defender in not goalkeeper.let as wthat he is going to do on the weekend i hope it is not again 3 or 4 goals

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 16, 2007

Let's not turn this into another liverpoolfc.tv post. The fact is there is no reason Rafa should not be in the market for young talent. We could have a team of Fowlers or Carraghers - but then in a few years they'll all retire and we'll have nobody. Until any of you get your coaching badges and manage two top flight clubs - I suggest you leave the decision making to the professionals. Benitez knows exactly what he's doing. I think you all forget about the other signings he's made.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Jan 16, 2007

we got padelli because he is s ypung and cos he has alot of pottential and if riena gets injad dudek isnt good enough scott carson is at chalton and is doing not so good as he should be

add comment | complain about this comment