BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

37 comments

user rating: 4 star

WGS

Scottish Premier Celtic
comment on the article

If it were possible, could you make a tactically astute manager by combining Martin O'Neill and Gordon Strachan as neither of them had or seem to have any tactical awareness when it comes to taking the team away from home.

There have been times when players have blown it: Balde in Lyon, Varga in Munich, Valgaeren in Turin and Caldwell in Lisbon but all too often we have conceded 3 goals on our travels and put in very disappointing performances.

The situation has to be looked at. The players are responsible for their own individual performances but they have to be better organised. Other teams can go on their travels and keep a clean sheet. They may not win but they do not concede a goal. We cannot do that. Other teams can go away and perform to a high level. On too many occasions we have not done that and tonight is another example of that.

The bottom line is Celtic should not and must not be torn apart by a team that cannot qualify for the UEFA cup. Ok, we have qualified but the bigger picture is until the situation of our away form is rectified we are in danger of becoming laughing stocks.

I have said it many times before and I hate to go on about it but Balde has to go. The guy is very poor on the ground and for a guy his size he is average in the air. He is rash in the tackle and his decision making is bizarre at times. He puts his teammates into trouble with his passes and he looks very awkward.

I mentioned Zurawski recently as well but again he was poor tonight. Please give me your opinions.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Dec 7, 2006

Miller is not good enough to be wearing the Celtic No9 shirt, he is not a goalscorer.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

Stachan stated after Lisbon he knew what was wrong with the team and why they played the way they did. If that is the case why did he not solvethe problem, apart from the weather it could have been Lisbon again.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

mikeyj "you never know you may win a title bigger than the scottish league one day" Lisbon67 first team in the british isles to win the european cup, also with a team entirely of scotsmen. Check your facts before you open your mouth next time cos it just makes you look stupid.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

Despite Celtic's poor away CL record, you have to remember that last night's defeat came from a team that was undefeated at home in 3 CL games this year, conceding only one goal (to Celtic).
The real test of Strachan and Celtic's away form will come in the first knockout stage, when Celtic will have to perform well, or go out.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

I hope that those who diss Naka (are you listening Derek Johnstone??!?) can now see what people who know about football always could. Far from being a liability, he is the attacking fulcrum of the team and we don't have another player of his skill or positional awareness.

Graveson was MIA in Naka's role last night and the team lacked balance and cohesion as a result.

The fact that the defence was poor last night - Wilson got no help from Graveson and Balde was poor all game. Pass marks to Mick and kudos to Naylor for a good performance.

Combine that with being toothless up front - Magic was posted missing and Miller, for all that he brings a lot to the team, missed some real sitters.

With the full team out and motivated, we're not a bad side though...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

"What I don't understand is when we went to Old Trafford we played five in the middle and but for a dive and some poor passing by Gravesen we would have won.

To then change to 442 for Benfica and Copenhagen is crazy. "

+++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++

Totally agree with this. The starting line ups recently have showed a real tactical niavety.

Zurawksi should never have been played last night. A fron tw owas never gonna work, I dont think they won one header so it was always gonna be a case of packing the midfield and getting some balls in behind like Naylors to Miller.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

Opinions about Zurawski are strange, to me he was the best player on the field, only one who looked dangerous...
That remindes me one Celtic's game in Europe, Scotish press and some fans pointed him out as the weakest player but at the same time FIFA officials picked him the man of the match.

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by mikeyj1 (U6805701)

posted Dec 7, 2006

All I was saying was that it has been a while since a scottish team has qualified for the knockout stages of the champions league and all the comments were negative. you are meant to be celebrating and all the comments were complaining

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 8, 2006

Simple fact is your defenders aren,t good enough to compete in europe,they may well cope with Inverness Cally thistle but opponents in the Champions league have badly exposed your defensive frailty. Balde is physical but clumsy in every other department, Caldwell looks like a nervous schoolboy and your full backs have both struggled in the championship with Wolves and Saints respectively. Strachan needs to invest in two quality centre halves before you get turned over in the away leg.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 8, 2006

I must say you're being a bit harsh on the lads. They qualified for the last 16 didn't they? and as for Copenhagen they were in the champions league so they can't be that bad. I mean they beat man u in denmark n drew with benfica. Maybe you could say that they have the exact same problem as celtic. They cant win away from home. So you could say that it cost them a place in the last 16?

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article


RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 66.67%
    2 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3
    0 votes
  • 2
    0 votes
  • 1 33.33%
    1 votes

average rating:
3.67 from 3 votes