BBC Home

Explore the BBC

New visitors: Create your membership
Returning members: Sign in

43 comments

user rating: 3 star

SACK PARDEW

Premiership West Ham United
by spikeammer (U5803704) 06 December 2006
comment on the article

We have to sack Pardew quickly, while Alan Curbishley is still available, let him get into the seat and buy his own players in the tranfer window. None of Pardews purchases this summer have come off. There has been one good performance against Arsenal the other wins have been very lucky. Don't wait to long this time get him out.

Latest 10 comments

Read members' comments or add your own

posted Dec 7, 2006

How can you sack Pards when he's brought us this far? So what we've lost a few games no team can be perfect! I do agree that none of his signings have come off the only one that has impressed me is spector!!!!!!!!!!!!!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

Spector? Are you sure, is that a seasonal joke? biggrin I think a rethink of the captain would be a good start, maybe give it to Mullins?

add comment | complain about this comment

comment by lishloz (U3304717)

posted Dec 7, 2006

I've had enough of the man Pardew!! When will the blame ever lay at his feet?? I'm tired of the fact someone else is always to blame, first the argies then the take over, last night the players is this man never at fault himself?? I think he is just as guilty of expecting this side to just carry on doing well after the succses of last year! Did he not realise that because of this he would have to motivate his players even more this year to keep those standards!! It's becoming more apparent with the man that when things start to go wrong he has no clue how to change this. I would love to be shot down come the end of the season when we have mid table safety but I have to say with Pardew in charge I cant see this being the case!!

Here's hoping i'm wrong!!

Up the irons!!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

The only new signing that has come close to impressing me is Green. He's looked quite accomplished in the matches I've seen and apart from the Blackburn game at home its hard to fault him for any of the goals. Its not his fault he's had 10 donkeys playing in front of him.

The other signings have not quite worked out yet...

Spector: Tries hard and lots of energy but goes lunging in too often. Not very cultured. Missing Scaloni.

Bowyer: Past it. Looks no better than he was in his last spell for West Ham. Used to be influential at Leeds, he'll never get that back again. Slow, no ideas and passes are shocking. Only looked OK v 10-man Charlton.

Cole: Only had a few games to prove himself but looked very limited when he has played. Goalscoring record has been shocking wherever he's been, very over-rated. Career in Championship beckons.

Mears: The young lad looks woefully out of his depth in the Premiership. Can't remember any contributions apart from goalline clearance v Villa.

Paintsil/Panstil, whatever his name is: What's the deal with this guy's work permit? A bad recommendation by Yossi. Got roasted time and again at Watford. Say no more.

Mascherano: Anonymous. Couldn't tell you anything about the bloke. Ah yes, bitten by Defoe.

Tevez: Glimpses of skill and vision coming through. Undoubted talent. Needs to work on his shooting and shed a few pounds.

McCartney: Being asked to fill in at centre back eventhough he's a left-back, which has done him no favours. Should try him at left-back and drop Konchesky.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

I dont think sacking Pardew is the answer either, it is the players that are not playing. Al this talk about Mascherano playing in midfield?? are you kidding me, he gives the ball away all the time and shows no ability in shielding it from opponents at all!! Tevez is finally coming good but he's one guy in the team. Now i hear that were in for ANOTHER striker during january, maybe better defenders would be in order. Frankly ive always been amazed at how lucky our defence is, as all those players are well over-rated and certainly not premiership quality!!! A few years back, everyone said we were too good to go down and look what happened then... Dont believe that it cant happen, it WILL unless those players start turning it around and stop being the laughing stock of the premiership...

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 7, 2006

Well Pardew has a very serious battle to contend with and thats relegation. Neil Warnick has his Sheffield United team working like dogs and i believe theywill stay up. Charlton and Watford are definately down and West Ham have a right battle staying up. Pardew wont be grinning after losing anymore. The huge grin on his face after West Ham had lost 4-1 to 10 men Chelsea at the bridge last year has long gone. The next few games for West Ham are very very tough and a demoralising thrashing by Manchester United could really hit team morale and spiral a worser decline in results seriously affecting West Hams relegation survival.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 8, 2006

I think that the squad is just too young. There is no regular starter with the experience to pull things together, dish out cut tails and keep the lads in line. Nothing against NRC, he was in good form last season, but he's too young to be wearing the armband. A signing of a player similar to Kavanagh is what would really impress me now. He's no superstar, but at the same time you know he'd dish out a Keano-esque slap if need be.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 8, 2006

How can you judge players like Paintsil and Mears when they've hardly played and came into a team that was struggling from the off? Surely they're better defensively than Lionel Scaloni? Looks to me like some of the players who were already there are the ones in poor form: Harewood, Etherington, Benayoun, Konchesky, Reo-Coker. Give McCartney, Mascherano, Zamora, Bowyer and Dailly a go. Ok, maybe not Dailly!

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 8, 2006

I can only make a judgement on Mears and Paintsil based on what I've seen so far. Granted, they've only made very few appearances.

Clearly Pardew doesn't trust Mears or Painstil that much. They've not even made the bench recently and they've not been injured. I know Pardew has preferred to pick a more 'attacking' bench but Spector seems to be keeping his place at right-back and I wouldn't say he's been outstanding.

West Ham didn't want to keep Scaloni because they felt Deportivo were asking 'over the odds' and Pardew decided he'd rather get 2/3 cheaper right backs to bolster the squad. Sure we've got plenty of right-backs but the position is still a problem so I can't agree that ditching Scaloni has been a good move.

add comment | complain about this comment

posted Dec 8, 2006

Scaloni? Wasn't he the man who cost us the FA Cup Final? I thought Spector looked good when he first came in, but like everyone else he's suffering as the team as a whole looks shakey. It seems to me that everyone agrees Reo Coker needs a rest. I'd like to see Bowyer in there alongside Mullins. It's all very well criticising Bowyer but he's yet to play in his best position, in the middle. At least he's a trier. Anyway, I've just seen the squad for tomorrow and see he's ill, and with others injured it looks like the only changes will be the centre of defense - just where we don't need it! I'm still sticking with Pardew though. Have those who've been criticising his signings forgotten what a talented squad he's put together? - even if we're not performing at the moment. Anyway, from what I hear it could be all academic as two more losses could see us with a certain Swede at the helm!!

add comment | complain about this comment

Comment on this article

Sorry, you can only contribute to 606 during opening hours. These are 0900-2300 UK time, seven days a week, but may vary to accommodate sporting events and UK public holidays.

RATE THIS ARTICLE

Rate Breakdown

  • 5 35.71%
    5 votes
  • 4
    0 votes
  • 3 14.29%
    2 votes
  • 2 21.43%
    3 votes
  • 1 28.57%
    4 votes

average rating:
2.93 from 14 votes