BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page has been archived and is no longer updated. Find out more about page archiving.

28 October 2014

BBC Homepage

Contact Us

The Crouches

The Crouches

There is a scene in "Live and Let Die" where the CIA's Harold Stutter turns to Bond after rescuing him from a store selling voodoo goods and 'commends' him on his disguise: "A white face in Harlem, good thinking Bond".

Presumably it was just this kind of thinking that persuaded the BBC that its first all-black sitcom should be written by Ian Pattison, creator of Rab C Nesbitt and, just like Rab, both Scottish and very white.

Natalie, Lindy and Adele

Whereas no English writer could have written Rab – a drunken ne'er-do-well living off the social – without facing accusations of dealing in lazy and patronising stereotypes, so it quickly became clear that a white Scotsman, however well-intentioned, could not write about a south London black family without facing similar accusations: especially with paterfamilias Roly in a dead-end job on London Underground, daughter Adele playing tonsil-hockey with a local wide-boy "gangsta" and three generations of Crouches (including teasing grandpa and frighteningly sexually frank grandma) all squeezed into one house.

The BBC's defence that "It's a sitcom about a family that just happens to be black" convinced very few, especially when the comedy itself didn't hold up as well as it should.  One reviewer called for Pattison to be "dipped in honey then fed to a battalion of fire ants".

Ed, Bailey and Roly

The upshot was that when the programme returned for a new series Pattison had been dumped and a group of talented black writers, including "Desmond's" veteran Paul Mackenzie, brought in.

While the scripts now seemed to reflect reality much more closely, they struggled to find a consistent level between episodes.

In any event, the damage had probably already been done.  Despite having an excellent cast The Crouches was cancelled after its second series.


Robbie Gee
Jo Martin
Rudolph Walker
Grandpa Langley
Mona Hammond
Grandma Sylvie
Akemnji Ndifornyen
Aaron Shosanya
Ony Uhiara
Don Warrington
Jimmy Akingbola
Dennis Dutton, Dennis Ubakemma
Llewella Gideon


Ian Pattison
Paul McKenzie
Patricia Elcock
Liselle Kayla
Nick Wood
Paulette Randall
Carlton Dixon
Stephen McCrum
Kenton Allen
executive producer
Ian Pattison
executive producer
Ian Pattison

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites.

About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy