BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page was last updated in September 2002We've left it here for reference.More information

9 December 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
CambridgeshireCambridgeshire

BBC Homepage
»BBC Local
Cambridgeshire
Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Cambridgeshire

Leicester
Lincolnshire
Norfolk
Northampton
Suffolk

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Cambridgeshire crimes
The Cambridge cut-throat chorus
The Garrick Inn, Cambridgeshire
The Garrick Inn. Inquest with your pint, sir?

In 1876 Emma Rolfe met her fate at the hands of a drunken young tailor on Midsummer Common.

Why and how did it happen... and why was the inquest held in the local pub?

  see also  
 

Cambridgeshire crimes: burnt at Ely

Cambridgeshire crimes: the St Neots assassin

BBC Cracking Crime day

BBC History trail
BBC h2g2 ghost stories

 
  facts  
 

In the 19th Century, public houses were preferred as Coroner's courts because of their size and other facilities.

Coroners are required to hold an inquest when informed of any sudden death within their area of jurisdiction which was violent, unnatural or where the cause is unknown.

The power of a Coroner to find a person guilty of murder or manslaughter was removed by section 56 of the Criminal Law Act 1977.

 
  print this page  
  View a printable version of this page  
contact us - have your say

Murder - the bloodier the better - always made good material for the authors of the 'penny dreadfuls' the broadsheets published to mark interesting events.

One such publication told in rhyme the story of a dreadful murder on Midsummer Common, Cambridge, which read:

'Poor Emma Rolfe,
Thy fate was dreadful,
For vengeance now, your blood it cries.
We hope your precious soul's in heaven,
Far away
in your blue skies.'

No young lovers' meeting...

At 9.30pm on the night of Thursday 24th August 1876 Emma Rolfe, aged 16, met up with Robert Browning, aged 25, near Four Lamps in Maids Causeway, Cambridge.

But this was no young lovers' meeting. Emma was in the habit of selling her favours to anyone with a spare shilling.

Browning was employed as a tailor in Covent Garden, off Mill Road. He lived with his parents and a brother and seemed to have been in the habit of spending his evenings drinking and seeking the company of young women of easy virtue, for which pleasures he was to pay a heavy price.

quote Emma was in the habit of selling her favours to anyone with a spare shilling quote

On the fateful evening he had worked with his brother to finish a pair of trousers for local trader
Mr Ward, who had promised them five shillings if they finished on time.

The Browning brothers completed the task and set off to spend the money on drink. At about 8.30pm Robert Browning parted company from his brother at the end of Bradmore Street and went home for supper.

Go to bed instead

At this time he must have been brooding over something, for he ate very little and then told his mother he was going out. With perhaps a mother's instinct for his mood, she advised him not to, saying he had been out the three nights before.

quote Browning took the razor from his pocket and slashed Emma's throat from ear to ear quote

She advised him to go to bed, but instead Browning lit a candle and went and fetched a cut-throat razor, placing it in his overcoat pocket.

He then left the house and went to a public house known as Canham's in Fair Street where he had more to drink. He walked from the pub to Four Lamps where he met not only Emma Rolfe but another girl.

Browning later stated in evidence at his trial that he told them he didn't want two women. Emma's companion then left and Browning and Emma went onto Midsummer Common, in the area known as Butts Green.

He had promised Emma a shilling to go with him but no money changed hands.

A gruesome act

No sooner were the couple immersed in the darkness of the common, than Browning took the razor from his pocket and slashed Emma's throat from ear to ear, nearly severing her head from her shoulders.

quote PC Wheel... heard a dreadful shriek from the common quote

Browning then walked to the Garrick Inn and had a glass of ale, his appearance and behaviour causing some notice among the clientele. He left after only a short time and was walking in the direction of home when he came upon PC Wheel who was in the area, having heard a dreadful shriek from the common.

Upon seeing the constable, Browning promptly gave himself into custody, telling the officer that he had murdered a woman.

At first he was not believed, so took PC Wheel to where his unfortunate victim lay dead. He handed the razor to the constable and showed him his blood-stained hands. A man named Southall, a traveller lodging at the Garrick Inn, assisted the constable with his prisoner, who was taken to the police station.

A killer disease

Browning said at this time that he had killed Emma because she had robbed him of a shilling and he carried the razor with him as a matter of habit.

However, Browning later made a written statement confessing the true reason for his dreadful crime. He wrote:

"I went out of the house intending to kill the girl I went to Royston with and who gave me the disease."

Clearly, Emma Rolfe was not that girl and was merely an unfortunate substitute target for Browning's resentment.

A very public inquest

Emma's body had been taken to the Fort St George public house on Midsummer Common and it was there that the inquest was held on 25th August 1876. The coroner's jury returned a verdict that her death was as a result of wilful murder by Robert Browning.

On 29th August, Browning was brought before the Mayor of the borough of Cambridge and other magistrates and committed for trial before Mr Justice Lush, to be held at Norwich on 29th November 1876.

quote Browning was taken to the scaffold, which had been erected at the gaol quote

At his trial Browning made little effort to defend himself, and seemed resigned to his fate. He was sentenced to death with a recommendation of clemency from the jury 'on behalf of his youth.'

The judge held out little hope of the prisoner's life being spared. Browning was taken to Cambridge borough gaol from Norwich gaol, where he awaited his trial. He was seen by Dr Briscoe, Inspector of Prisons, who had been sent by the home office.

No clemency for the young killer

Browning was interviewed at length to see if there was any reason why he should not be executed. Dr Biscoe's report was sent to the Home Secretary, who replied that he could not see any circumstances that would justify his interfering with the due course of law.

At a few minutes before 8.00am on 15th December 1876 Browning was taken to the scaffold, which had been erected at the gaol.

The executioner, Marwood, had adapted the apparatus by having a pit three feet deep dug beneath it. He had allowed a drop of six feet ten inches, on account of Browning being 'of light stature.'

From Cambridgeshire Crimes
© John Bell 1994 ISBN: 1899558004

If you would like a copy of Cambridgeshire Crimes, you can contact John Bell, the author on tel: 01487 822123

line
Top | Features Index | Home
Also in this section

Planet Cambridgeshire

In pictures

Weather

Features


Newsletter

Out and About

E-cards

Contact Us

BBC Cambridgeshire Website
104 Hills Road
Cambridge
CB2 1LD
(+44) 01223 589837
cambridgeshire@bbc.co.uk



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy