BBC HomeExplore the BBC
This page was last updated in December 2007We've left it here for reference.More information

27 May 2012
Accessibility help
Text only

BBC Homepage

Local BBC Sites

Neighbouring Sites

Related BBC Sites


Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Have Your Say

You are in: Bristol > Have Your Say > Have your say: Talking CCTV in Bristol

CCTV camera

Have your say: Talking CCTV in Bristol

Bristol is to trail "talking" CCTV cameras where operators can warn members of the public about anti-social behaviour through speakers in the cameras - do you think they'll work?

The three-month pilot scheme, is being funded by the Safer Bristol Partnership and aims to reduce littering and improve public safety.

We want to know if you think the talking cameras will help reduce problems or is the idea a gimmick that people will eventually ignore?

The chairman of the Safer Bristol Partnership, Labour Councillor Peter Hammond, told BBC Radio Bristol that the scheme is a good way to keep a lid on bad behaviour.

"It's a useful tool. It gives a warning rather than having to take direct action if people don't behave sociably.

"When I was a lot younger than I am now sometimes a friendly word from a police officer stopped anything more serious happening.

"I think most people will find it reassuring to know that if there is anybody around misbehaving, or likely to escalate into anything else, they'll be happy to see this happening."

What's your view on these cameras? Fill in the form below and we'll publish a selection of the best comments here.

last updated: 11/12/2007 at 14:22
created: 11/12/2007

Have Your Say

The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

Matt Fuidge
Yes if the Operators actually do there job and have the local back up from the police which probally isnt the case, I wonder if they should train police to do a better job with the money.

Marc
Should have a camera on every cycle parking area in the city centre as the police don't investigate cycle theft anymore. They just give you a reference number and look at you as if you are wasting their time.

Mike Keen
Money better spent elsewhere

Paul
one set of numbers will explain all: 1984

Biccy
Surely no one is actually going to see these cameras as a threat? Plus for teens and drunks its great fun to mess about infront of them!

karina
that's going to be a jail this country! peoples will be controlled, and not only the problematic ones but everybody... why not install some special institutions for anti-behavioural childrens for a start.. in which they will receive some help and guidance... that's more social, it will help more than a machine.. you can't talk with a robot!

anonymous
that's going to be a jail this country! peoples will be controlled, and not only the problematic ones but everybody...

john lewis
its a complete joke....this country is turning into a police state where i feel i have no privacy what so ever....it needs to change

Dave
This is so silly - the kids and drunks will just find it amusing and 'wind up' the person manning the camera !!

Genie
"It's a useful tool. It gives a warning rather than having to take direct action if people don't behave sociably.And if they ignore that warning? What then? Nothing is my bet. Expensive, ineffective and all a bit 1984 really. I can think of much better things to spend the money on as I'm sure could most people.

sam
i agree with 'dave', youths are going to ignore the cameras and take the micy (i'd know, i'm 14)

Nick
What the public need, is the visibile reassurance of more police on the streets. Labour is good at not listening and wasting money so this no surprise.

Fred
I cannot belive what I'm reading. Not only will people be watched all the time they're in central Bristol now some anonymous operative (employed by ?) in a 'control' room will be able to offer a 'friendly word' on our behaviour. When was the Council vote on this? When was the consultation? Who controls the people in the control room? If this was in place in Baghdad before Saddham was overthrown it would have been used as an example of his tyranny. Stalin and Hitler would have been first in the queue for this technology. Slowly but surely we're giving away all our freedoms and privacy and if we don't stand up to this lunacy we're all done for.

Paul
Too late they are already here!

48/49
Er, why not just have more Police on the streets? At least then a group of trouble makers can be followed from one area to another, rather than congregating in areas off camera. It'll become the new craze to bait the cameras (or operators, if they aren't council robots that is) into a response.

Dave
can you picture the scene?.. a youth drops a bit of litter.. cctv : Dont do that, pick it up.. Youth replys with a one finger salute and walks off.

Barbara Crow
It is bad enough to know that we are the most surveyed nation in the western world without having the cameras actually speaking to us as well! No,no, no! Please do not do this. They will ultimately be ignored and are an invasion of one's privacy. Just get more police out there. That is what people want.

You are in: Bristol > Have Your Say > Have your say: Talking CCTV in Bristol



About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy