BBC HomeExplore the BBC

14 July 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
BristolBristol

BBC Homepage
England
»BBC Local
Bristol
News
Sport
Weather
Travel News

Things to do
People & Places
Nature
History
Religion & Ethics
Arts and Culture
BBC Introducing
TV & Radio

Sites near Bristol

Gloucestershire
Somerset
Wiltshire
SE Wales

Related BBC Sites

England
 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

Theatre

Gus Gallagher, Karina Fernandez, Katharine Rogers
When shall these three meet again?

Multi-media Macbeth

Review by contributor Steven Deproost
Bristol Old Vic Studio. Macbeth by William Shakespeare. Co-produced with Splice Productions. Starring Robert Gwilym and Katharine Rogers. Until 28 October 2006.

Confronted by a premium room in an up-market hotel chain, you might be forgiven for wondering whether you’ve wandered into the wrong show.

But the message on the large centre-stage plasma screen announces that The Royal Shelton Hotel at Dunsinane welcomes Lord and Lady Macbeth… and here is Lady M, casually switching on the TV.

This is a multi-media adaptation in which the early scenes – Macbeth’s victories, his triumphant return and the encounter with the witches -  are all mediated through news reports and music videos streamed to Lady M’s TV. 

Later scenes, such as Macbeth’s coronation and Malcolm’s final victory speech are also seen on film.

The witches seem to have Eastern European accents and later turn up as increasingly sinister chambermaids and porters, controlling not only the state of the room but also the fate of its occupants.

Although this is in many respects a fascinating production, it continually lurches from being clever and compelling, to being nonsensical and dull.

Casual Macbeth

Paradoxically, the news reporting works well, but seems at times too formal, whereas Macbeth, when we finally see him in the flesh, seems too casual, both in manner and in speech – as if infected by the banality of the hotel setting.

Bob Gwilym and Katharine Rogers at the Macbeths
A bloody prophesy for the Macbeths

Curiously, the minor characters are generally more successfully realised than the main protagonists. 

The hotel room concept works well for the witches, but it is surely important that Lady Macbeth is at home, on her territory; that Macduff’s family is murdered in its nest; and  Banquo’s murder seems to occur at the hotel, whereas the whole idea is to kill him in some isolated spot – not on the doorstep. 

The Porter at the Gate is amusingly reinterpreted and skillfully performed, by Christian Rodska, as a hired entertainer. But in moving it’s position from just after the murder to before, much of the impact is lost.

This is the major flaw: somewhere in the complex processes of collaboration and interpretation, in fitting together sequences filmed three months earlier with live performance and technical effects, the vitality of the relationship between the Macbeths has been lost, and we do not feel the tragedy of their sharply delineated disintegration.

There is a telling moment when Macbeth, having discovered that Macduff is not ‘of woman born’, still decides to fight on. 

At this point we should briefly glimpse the old warrior and feel a sense of loss… but in this production he never earns that respect.

Splice Productions was formed this year by Robert Gwilym (Macbeth and film director) and Katharine Rogers (Lady Macbeth and stage director) to create accessible productions of the classics, using multi-media techniques wedded to the ‘power of live performance’. 

The fusion of stage and screen has obviously been fruitful in many respects, but has left the central characters distinctly lacking in voltage. 

Despite my reservations, this is still a production well-worth seeing - and I guarantee it will give you plenty to talk about afterwards.

last updated: 09/10/06
Have Your Say
Seen the show - what did you think?
Your name: 
Your comment: 
 
The BBC reserves the right to edit comments submitted.

Becky
Setting it in a hotel room was an interesting concept poorly realised - the two central characters were not engaging and the film sequences looked like an amateur media studies project. The only character that convinced me was Banquo.

Marion Reed
A bold conception brilliantly realised;I'm afraid I cannot agree with your assessment of the central characters' relationship;utterly compelling and believable;very accessible to the many young people in the audience.

Ed
The first half was as painful as pulling teeth, and was not helped by the fact Lady Macbeth seemed keen to get rid of her words as quickly as possible, and had a complete inability to act. The chambermaid/witch/lady macduff was good but the star of the show was Banquo, the only actor who convinced in every role. The multimedia aspect, however, was a brilliant idea and was sadly underused.

Phil Saunders
Agree with much of the above. The main problem was the mediocre technical quality of the stuff on the telly. If it had been top notch, it would have worked really well - but it needed to look as though it really was BBC News 24 or similar! But, overall, an interesting version that worked very well for some sequences if not others. Quite a contrast with the Tobacco Factory approach, where speech/acting are all.

Andrew Sinclair
The production is well worth seeing. I agree with the review that some parts (even those key to the whole play) just don't work, but that's hardly surprising with such an ambitious attempt. The reporting of the battle, witches' song, the hologram of Banquo's ghost and the final prophesies all show how such a production can improve on many traditional versions.

Mike - Bristol
Like many, I have a 'shakespere hangover' from my schooldays, remembering Shakespere as an old fashioned and difficult text to decipher. This production cuts through that, and was most entertaining, cleverly designed and contempory, without loosing what the watcher could see underneath as classic theartre.

SEE ALSO
home
HOME
email
EMAIL
print
PRINT
Go to the top of the page
TOP
SITE CONTENTS
SEE ALSO

BBC Arts

External Links





About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy