BBC HomeExplore the BBC
Just to let you know, we're no longer updating this site. More information here

9 July 2009
Accessibility help
Text only
Bradford and West YorkshireBradford and West Yorkshire

BBC Homepage
England
»Bradford & West Yorkshire
News
Sport
Weather
Travel News

Entertainment
Features
In Pictures
Faith
Around West Yorkshire
Junior Football

Saving Planet Earth
How We Built Britain

Radio Leeds

Site Map 

Contact Us

Like this page?
Send it to a friend!

 

September 2004
Blot on the landscape or 'stunning'?
Huddersfield Market Hall
Queensgate Market in Huddersfield
Huddersfield's controversial 1970s Market Hall is one step closer to becoming a listed building - meaning it will be protected for future generations - despite being condemned by one local historian as 'dull and shabby'. Have YOUR say here!
SEE ALSO

BBC History

BBC TWO Restoration

Past and Present in West Yorkshire

Sense of Place

WEB LINKS

West Yorkshire Civic Societies

English Heritage

The Twentienth Century Society

Kirklees Council: Piazza Redevelopment options
The BBC is not responsible for the content of external websites.

PRINT THIS PAGE
View a printable version of this page.
get in contact

The Heritage Minister Andrew McIntosh has announced plans to list Queensgate Market, describing it as 'structurally innovative' and 'dynamic'.

The Market Hall was opened in 1970 and features a 'stunning' roof and abstract art on its walls which, despite attracting praise from the Minister, is not to everybody's tastes.

Huddersfield's Queensgate Market mural
Queensgate Market mural

Speaking earlier this year to the BBC West Yorkshire Website, Huddersfield Historian Lesley Kipling had little praise for the building: "The atmosphere is of a dark and dingy cavern. In summer it is unbearably hot and airless, in winter it is cold and cheerless. Low ceilings combine with a lack of natural light to make it the kind of place where you don't want to linger!"

On the other hand, West Yorkshire architecture expert and Huddersfield resident Adrian Evans told us he thought Queensgate Market is "A spectacular combination of architecture, engineering and art."

Huddersfield Market Hall roof and shoppers
Inside Queensgate

If these plans go ahead, Queensgate Market - together with the town's library and art gallery - will receive extra protection in the future. This would mean the end of plans which could have seen the Market Hall being demolished. Kirklees Council have been considering a number of diffferent options to redevelop the area around the town's library - some of these involving the Market Hall being knocked down.

Since 1995, the Government has publicly consulted on most plans to list buildings created after 1945 and local people and interest groups are now being given the chance to tell the Heritage Minister whether they think Huddersfield's Queensgate Market really merits the extra protection that listing provides.

Why not tell us what YOU think about these plans? Do you think the Market building really deserves being saved for the future...or should it just be knocked down? English Heritage describe it as 'the best surviving example of a retail market from the 1960s and 70s...'. But, be that as it may, would you rather see it erased from Huddersfield centre as a blot on the landscape? AND what else would you do to improve Huddersfield Town cetnre if YOU had the power?! Have YOUR say here!


YOUR COMMENTS
:

Tony,Halifax
It's a typical 70's concrete eyesore,which should be knocked down and rebuild a new market to blend in with Huddersfield's historic buildings.

STEVE, DEWSBURY
A stunning symbol of modernist architecture and sculpture...how can it be demolished just because it challenges peoples ideals of what is beautiful? I do agree that the interior needs upgrading though.

Simon, Halifax
This is from the decade taste forgot - obviously. Its interesting and we should keep some ,erm, 'odd' buildings from this era. But why list this building whilst knocking down truly beautiful victorian buildings?

CHARL, HUDDERSFIELD
it an eyesore always has been and always will be if its not demolished!

Sally Huddersfield
Keep it. Protect it. Open it up and let us have fun in it. Hold concerts in in.

LESLEY, HUDDERSFIELD
So much of the past is getting knocked down to make way for more modern airy buildings. We seem to have a mixture of the very old, or very new. How many of the 70's style buidins do we have to show to future generations? Most have been extended hidden or demolished. The Queensgate market looks different and interesting from the ring road and should stay as a piece of history. If people don't like the inside, just renovate the inside. Look how much difference changing the coffee shop in the centre made. A lot of chrome and laminate flooring would totally change the ambience, but the outside is a historic and architectural work of art, that sahould definitely stay.

TRACY, HUDDERSFIELD
Why can't the artwork on the outside be kept and re-used in more modern facility? The building itself it ugly and I'm sorry but the whole market interior is horrible. People see the shops as cheap and grotty even though some of them sell good quality goods. It is not a nice place to shop full stop.

EDGIE, HUDDERSFIELD
Huddersfield has one of the last remaining traditional stone town centres in England - the Library and the Town Hall being excellent examples of heritage - even the Ring Road view of the Queensgate Market is preservable but the townside is neither historic or modernistic so must go!

WENDY, LEEDS
I've been there a few times and it makes a pleasant change to all the pretntious crap we see in leeds all the time It might look a bit old but its like a time machine! Retrotastic!!!

STU, MIRFIELD
Knock the damn thing down - don't protect it. It just sums up Huddersfield as a throwback and its about time we started to look forward.


Fill in the form below with YOUR comments, then press 'SUBMIT':

Name and where you're from:


Your comments:




PLEASE NOTE:

*Your comments may be edited for legal reasons.

* We cannot guarantee that all comments will be published.
* The Editor's decision is final.

line
Top |Restoration Index| Home
GOING OUT going out image
What's on across West Yorkshire? From gigs to the top ten films, from clubbing to the theatre - it's all here!

divider Pubs/Clubs divider Film
divider Music divider Theatre

raw talent

films

competitions

student guide

lifestyle

Contact Us
BBC Bradford and West Yorkshire
National Museum of Photography,
Film and Television,
Bradford
BD1 1NQ
(+44) 01274 841051
bradford@bbc.co.uk
westyorkshire@bbc.co.uk




About the BBC | Help | Terms of Use | Privacy & Cookies Policy