Brand navigation


Weekdays 12.00pm

Radio 4's consumer affairs programme

Brand navigation

Archives for May 2011

Call You & Yours and the Volcanic Ash Cloud

Post categories:

Andrew Smith | 10:52 UK time, Wednesday, 25 May 2011

Comments (1)

Icelandic volcano
A rare newspaper review for Call You and Yours this week. It was a rather different kind of programme - we tried to capture the problems caused, mainly in Scotland, by another of those volcano ash plumes which wafted over the UK from Iceland. All our preparations had been for a phone-in on Mary Portas' brief to breathe new life into the High Street but with the ash making its way south and a backlog of cancelled flights building up, we decided to throw out our plans and go for the moving story - literally in this case. Our previous "volcano special" in April 2010 won a Travel Press Award so we know the subject and BBC Scotland promised us help with coverage and we decided to go for it. Producer Sally Abrahams did a brilliant job of holding things together even though we got far fewer telephone calls than for a phone-in reflecting a national debate. As Elisabeth Mahoney points out in her review, Julian Worricker is the perfect anchor to tackle an emerging story where the devil is in the detail. So were we right to follow our journalistic instincts? Or would you have preferred the debate on the High Street? I'd be interested to hear listeners' views - and just to say we are intending to run the shop debate now on Tuesday June 7. Get you comments on that to us now.

Andrew Smith is the Editor of You and Yours and The Media Show on BBC Radio 4.

Howard Schultz

Post categories:

Winifred Robinson | 09:43 UK time, Monday, 16 May 2011

Comments (2)

Howard Schultz - the man who built Starbucks from a single Seattle coffee shop to an international chain - has been on a brief tour of the UK. He's promoting his new book, 'Onward: How Starbucks Fought for Its Life without losing Its Soul'.You and Yours were offered the chance to interview him and we jumped at it.

'Onward' is a brisk 300 plus pages beginning with the story of how Howard Schultz, a boy from a poor background, wanted to build the kind of company his father never had a chance to work in. He is proud that Starbucks in the States offers health insurance to all its employees, even those who work part time. He describes how his father, who never earned more than $20,000 a year all his life, was sacked one winter after falling on ice and breaking his hip. The family was destitute. He was inspired to set up Starbucks to recreate the experience of drinking coffee in bars in Italy where people meet and socialise and the staff are friends. He quickly moves on to his main subject, how in 2008 - after eight years away from the helm - he re-took control of the company, convinced that it was losing its romance and magic in a relentless drive for growth.

What to ask? As a journalist interviewing Howard Schultz, you have to be aware that millions of people love Starbucks and wouldn't buy their coffee anywhere else. But because of the rapid expansion of the company - the very thing he returned to curtail - Starbucks to some is as insidious and the McDonalds Golden Arches, ubiquitous, uniform, unwanted. A couple of years ago on You and Yours we featured cases where the company had opened on small high streets, applied for planning permission retrospectively and met with sustained resistance from local people.

I really enjoyed the book. It provides - for a business outsider - a fascinating analysis of how a company can appear on paper to be doing everything right, increasing share price and growing profits and sales, and yet at the same time be undermining the very thing that made it a success; in Howard Schultz's terms, the romance of a custom-built coffee shop.

What I found hard to swallow though was the almost religious fervour with which Howard Schultz describes his work. The book is on sale in Starbucks branches with proceeds going to charity, so please have a read and let me know what you think. I decided to rib him gently about it (or so I thought) careful to point out that his lack of any trace of irony is probably what makes him a multi millionaire while I am not. I asked him to read what for me was a particularly schmaltzy bit, a collapsed into laughter as he finished reading it and it observed that the tone felt 'un-British' to me. I had eight emails telling me off for being so rude. I replied to them all in person. Tone is a very hard thing to judge in these encounters. I don't always get it right...The book is on sale in Starbucks branches with proceeds going to charity, so please have a read, have a listen and let me know what you think.

Winifred Robinson presents You and Yours on BBC Radio 4

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.