Montage
I've been stopping by a few other writerly blogs recently, good to read and I like the notion of a writing 'community' (I'm a fantasist I know), we need to keep in touch, talk to each other.
I used to go to my local writers group in East London once a week - we'd listen to each others work, drink tea, eat biscuits then sometimes retire to the pub.
Good times - it also gave me a deadline to write to, in the absence of any commissions. Some writers can be quite suspicious of new writing initiatives and training schemes, it seems.
I see my time as an Academy Writer as an apprenticeship - on the job training, and no you can't teach 'writing' any more than you can teach 'art'. But Da Vinci had his apprentices and he too was an apprentice himself once - there's a lot to be said for learning structure and technique, especially if you want subvert it, grow, become innovative etc.
So back to my innovative Holby episode that fell onto the doormat in DVD form recently. It has a title at last. I've posted before about how difficult it can be to watch my own episodes, it does get easier the more TV hours you clock up. I managed to get through this first viewing of 'We Said Some Things' without squirming too much or without having the script on my knee thumbing through the dialogue to see what they'd cut.
Holby City can be montage Heaven or montage Hell depending on whether you happen to love or loathe the device. Personally I prefer to montage at the beginning middle or end of an episode rather than montage twice or indeed in all three - there you can be heading for montage overkill.
Montages do have to be written, I don't just write 'Montage with music' after the scene heading and hope for the best. It is a compressed chunk of storytelling and needs to be planned and structured like the rest of the script. I always hope to marry certain lyrics with particular on-screen action, choice of music is very important. I did manage to get a Monkees track into my montage for one episode.
I'd really enjoyed constructing the final montage for this last Holby - it encapsulated my themes, it had some dancing, wonderful music, a period costume change.. (I kid you not).
My montage was cut.
True - my producer had phoned and warned me that once they'd come to filming they didn't think they could do my montage justice - given the budget and scheduling constraints. I had to make do with a trimmed down version and different music was used given that my overarching montage theme had been excised.
I was disappointed I have to admit, but the rest of the episode was really quite good - Hey ho, maybe it was just as well the ep wasn't upstaged by all singing all dancing montage madness.
Another problem with montages is that they eat up scenes. I'm writing a Holby at the moment that is quite pacy - lots of scene cuts, 4 story strands, lots going on - a nice meaty episode. I'd notched up quite a few scenes already by the time I'd finished. Then I found a wonderful place in the storytelling where I knew the only way to get the most out of the story was to tell it in pictures with music - I penned a montage sequence that promptly added another 6 or 7 scenes to my already bursting scene count. Granted each scene is probably only a sentence or two long .. but it may take some negotiating with scheduling.
Best montage? The end of Donnie Darko to 'Mad World'. Has to be.
~RS~q~RS~~RS~z~RS~48~RS~)
CommentsSign in
You need to sign in to contribute to this page. If you're new to BBC Blogs, creating your membership is quick and easy.
Hi Abi,
Well done on Holby episode. The story threads on Holby are brilliant. I like montages if there done well. Adds progression and emotion, especially with the right song/music. Good montage in Full Monty, intercuts of rehearsals/dancing and supermarket security guy.
Complain about this comment
Hi,
I'm working on a Holby episode at the moment (as a supporting artist - i have to make some money somehow) and we just filmed three montages for one episode. So made me laugh to read your blog!
Complain about this comment
Hi,
I've been following your blog with interest as I've just started the new OU Advanced Creative Writing course and we're about to start looking at screenwriting.
This is something I've always fancied but never had the confidence to try. After all scriptwriters are thought of as 'glamorous' and 'out there' Your blog helps me realise that you are just ordinary, albeit hard working and talented people, just like the rest of us.
Though I agree creative writing can't be taught, a good course can nurture what's there and involve you with other writers. Feeling part of a community helps.
As for Donnie Darko. I have to agree with you. I sobbed bucketloads.
Looking forward to your next instalment.
Complain about this comment
Hey Abi,
Got to love the montage. But can I suggest you split the category down into two: whilst a good montage is priceless (I totally agree with you that they're killer when you've got to cover a large narrative distance in a very short amount of time), all too often I fear I'm cheating whenever I use one (either because I don't quite understand the intricacy of a surgical procedure, for example; or because I'm not confident enough with the character I'm writing). In those situations I propose you reclassify the montage as a smudge (remember when you were in art class and you couldn't get the grading right between colours, so you used your thumb to smudge it all together - it's messy but effective and you end up getting pastels all over your clothes...? I do). I guess smudges are the quickest ways to polish over narrative chasms you can't quite get right, and in doing so convince your audience it's a justifiable fix so long as you cover it with a little Moonlight Sonata.
Looking over the Holby I've just delivered, I hope the two montages (at the beginning and middle) aren't smudges...I guess I'll wait and see...
Al
Complain about this comment
PS: Best montage ever - without a doubt "Team America: World Police"; best smudge ever - Van Damme's "finding himself" in "Bloodsport"...a horrific, cowardly celebration of one writer's attempt to justify retribution...
Complain about this comment
View these comments in RSS