Zimbabwe on the brink
I wrote here the other day that we journalists aren't very good at dealing with stories that move slowly, over a long period of time. Well, today I'm going to put that right: Zimbabwe has been slowly disintegrating for nearly a decade now, and it's time to put it back at the top of our agenda.
We've reported three times this week on the ever more appalling crisis there: on Monday we had a remarkable eye-witness report from Harare on how soldiers had gone on the rampage; on Tuesday, we reported on the worsening cholera outbreak; and last night, we had an interview with the Prime Minister of Kenya, Raila Odinga, who called on fellow African governments to "push Mugabe from power". (All programmes are still available via Listen Again on the website.)
If you've missed the latest developments, here's a taste: the central bank has raised the cash withdrawal limit from banks from the equivalent of 18p a day to about £34 a week. It's issued new 50 million and 100 million dollar banknotes (they're worth about £17 and £34 respectively). And remember, these are the "new" dollars that were introduced in August, when 10 zeros were knocked off the old ones.
No wonder everyone uses US dollars or South African rand instead if they can. The official inflation rate is now said to be 231 million per cent, although how anyone can calculate that is quite beyond me.
So let's forget the figures. The shops are empty, the hospitals, by the admission of the health minister himself, are "non-functioning". More than 500 people have already died of cholera, more than 10,000 others have gone down with the disease - and there's a chronic shortage of water-treatment chemicals so that for a period this week, the capital, Harare, was without water.
I'm not sure anyone ever really believed after the elections earlier this year that President Mugabe would agree to share power with the opposition MDC. But for months, as Zimbabweans struggled to feed themselves and their families, the diplomats tried manfully to come up with a deal that would save Zimbabwe from total destitution. They failed.
The MDC seem to have decided there's no point in continuing with the pretence. Within the next few months, Jacob Zuma will become President of South Africa, and they expect him to take much tougher line with his neighbour to the north than did Thabo Mbeki. We'll see what happens, if Robert Mugabe is still in power then.
When I was in Harare in 2000, to report on parliamentary elections, people told me: "Mugabe won't be here for much longer, he can't go on for ever." (He's now 84.) The so-called land reform programme was already well under way, and most white farmers had already been forced to leave. It was the beginning of Zimbabwe's long slow descent into economic collapse, as food production dwindled and investment dried up.
For years now, Zimbabwe's neighbours - and others - have waited for the country to reach a tipping point, a moment when the whole rickety structure that has kept Mugabe in power for so long comes tumbling down. After the first round of the presidential election last March, it looked for a time as if that moment had arrived. But his forces regrouped, reimposed their will by sheer brute force, and he survived.
Now is another potential tipping point. The army is restive, disease is spreading, and the very basics of human life - food, water - are disappearing. I wouldn't be surprised if Mugabe was gone by the end of the year.
By the way, our editor, Alistair Burnett, has written a piece on the BBC Editors' blog this week about how we try to balance our coverage of foreign and UK news on The World Tonight. Should we, for example, have done more about the Baby P case on Monday, or the Shannon Matthews story last night? You can read his thoughts here -- and we'd very much appreciate your view.


~RS~q~RS~~RS~z~RS~23~RS~)
Comments
Sign in or register to comment.
As a foreign listener, I do not even know who "Baby P" is or what the issue may be.
Would it be too off-putting to say: "Should the state do more about..."
and then enter into the specific example of Baby P?
All audiences are being conditioned to react only to short (essentially adolescent) sound bytes.
Rather than pander to this, one might try to gently encourage a little more thought.
Complain about this comment
Your slow response to the Zimbabwe crisis is no doubt because of the inability of the left wing media to acknowledge that a black revolutionary like Mugabe could transform himself into a brutal dictator and destroy his country.
If the BBC could get out of the habit of turning a bind eye to the glaring deficiencies of its heroes, it might begin to do some decent reporting on them.
The BBC should also try to broaden the scope of its sources of information about these matters. For example, it might like to try to get the viewpoint (shock, horror) of white former Rhodesians. What they've forgotten about the situation there the BBC has yet to learn.
Complain about this comment
Zimbabwe:
The solution for this country, is for Robert Mugabe to be willing to leave the country....
Complain about this comment
The problem with this tipping point is that the departure of Mugabe will not necessarily herald a peaceful handover to the opposition or indeed any kind of organised government. ZanuPF will continue to be a powerful force and Mugabe's successors will probably be just as tempted to use methods of terror to secure their narrow political ends. One can forsee complete chaos as the police and military seek to secure their unpaid wages by less than democratic means and western countries will not pour vast sums into a failed state unless there is some hope of an effective administration. The tipping point which casts Mugabe out of office may be near. The tipping point which casts Zimbabwe into utter chaos has, I am afraid been reached long ago.
Complain about this comment
With 3 to 4 million Zimbabwean refugees I don't know why South Africa, with EU & British aid, is not training an alternative police force and army which could assist with the transition which must come and could also be used to provide humanitarian assistance coupled with the NGO's.
Complain about this comment
#5 - saandyb
I would imagine that both the UK and the EU are anxious to avoid the old accusation that they are embarking on a form of 'new colonialism'. Also South Africa under Mbeke seemed very reluctant to interfere although there are signs of change.
Possibly you are correct if they were to do so covertly. Maybe they are?
Complain about this comment
#5 - saandyb
"Zimbabwe's presidential spokesman and Secretary for Information and Publicity George Charamba said "It is clear the command center which Brown is referring to has nothing to do with cholera. It has everything to do with the running dispute between Zimbabwe and Britain over land. It has to do with regime change politics. He is asking for an invasion of Zimbabwe." (China News Agency quoting The Mail).
Well there's a suprise!
Complain about this comment
View these comments in RSS