« Previous | Main | Next »

Billions of problems of billions people

Post categories:

Hamid Ismailov Hamid Ismailov | 15:54 UK time, Thursday, 27 October 2011

With the world on the cusp of achieving a population of seven billion people, issues of demography are at the centre of discussions.

One particular report from Russia caught my attention. Russia's population is shrinking and will drop by a third by 2050: from 142 million people to 100 million.

It was Yuri Krupnov, Chairman of the Monitoring Council of the Russian Institute for demography, migration and regional development who revealed these figures.

In his piece published on BBC Russian, making some allowances for unforeseen circumstances, he spoke both about the causes and the consequences of that grim situation:

"One of the key factors is a combination of a 'European birth rate' (on average 1.5 children per woman) with an "African death rate", especially among the men of working age - with the male average life expectancy of just 63 according to the latest official data.

"Russia is the biggest country in the world by landmass, and the decline of its population will mean that large parts of the country risk being abandoned."

But the point which I would like to discuss is the mindset of a nation which faces such a rapid decrease in population.

What happens to the demography of Russia will be unsettling in terms of the national spirit.

Being the biggest country in the world by territory Russia has in parallel developed a sense of being a great nation too. And historically rightly so.

Look at its conquests, the wars it has won, its history of invention and discovery, its great literature, art - all of these achievements would justify such a feeling of pride.

However most of these accomplishments are increasingly confined to the past.

I follow the intellectual life of present-day Russia and see that this feeling of greatness is currently hanging in the balance between a glorious past and a mediocre reality of the present.

I have recently reviewed a compilation of modern Russian literary pieces and was amazed to discover that the common denominator in the theme for all the pieces in the book is the dysfunction between expectation and the reality.

This ubiquitous disfunctionality peppers literature with frustration; and this frustration translates into a telling mood on the national level.

Insecurities - as it's well known - are the fertile ground for aggression. I've seen it in behaviour of juvenile Taliban members; Russian literature tells the same story about the adolescent Bolshevism.

Xenophobia also has the same roots. Since this year has not yet ended, according to Sova, the centre for information and analysis, which monitors cases of xenophobia in Russia, in 2010 there were 436 registered cases of racial violence, including murder.

So every single day of the year someone is killed or severely beaten up in Russia just because he is from somewhere else.

In my novel Mbobo which tells the story of a mixed race boy born in Moscow in 1980 in the year of the Moscow Olympics, his two step-fathers discuss this issue:

'Good literature is literature you can't make a film out of'. Thus spoke drunk Gleb at Belarus Radial station, to which his conversant Nazar replied:

'The Russian people had one chance - to overcome themselves in the Soviet Ubermensch, but you Russians fucked it up!'

I trudged along behind them in silence.

'Myths, I tell you, are the genotype of culture, while humans are the phenotype!' continued Gleb cleverly, tongue-twisted and swaying.

Nazar followed his thought through: 'You laughed at Brezhnev and by the way he was the crown of Russian-ness, it was he who expressed with his tangling tongue the Marxist-Nietzschean idea of the new communality of people, the Soviet Nation, grown on Russian soil... and what happened? You laughed him down, pissed and shat on him.'

I listened to them both in silence.

'You know, we are Slavs...' Gleb was off on his ancient Slavonic high horse. 'And now there's no communality whatsoever, now this plague of Central Asian, Caucasian, Chinese locusts like myself will simply swallow the Russian nation, chewing it and digesting it without so much as stopping to ask its name... Give it 50 years, or 100...'

I walked behind them dully through the station, and when they both for some reason asked me in unison: 'How about you, are you Russian?'

I answered bitterly: 'I'm a black Russian...'

Mr Krupnov says that Russia needs a demographic revolution to turn the unwanted tide of change and the key according to him is to encourage a higher birth rate in Russia.

But Mbobo's alternative is different - to redefine what it means to be a Russian.

Examples set bu America, India, Brazil and many other nations which are based on citizenship rather than ethnicity might help to find the answer to the challenges which Russians face.


Comments

  • Comment number 1.

    That is really food for thought. Planned migration might be a great idea, if only the regime and the society there were prepared for it (i.e. more democratic, less racist).

  • Comment number 2.

    Vladimir Putin recently directed his nation's parliament to develop a plan to reduce falling population. Putin called the problem of Russia's dramatically declining population: "The most acute problem of contemporary Russia." He called on parliament to provide incentives for couples to have a second child to increase the birth rate. Russia's population peaked in the early 1990s (at the time of the end of the Soviet Union) with about 148M people. Today, Russia's population is approximately 143M. The US Census Bureau estimates that Russia's population will decline from the current 143M to a mere 111M by 2050, a loss of more than 30 million people (decrease of more than 20%). The primary causes of Russia's population decrease - loss of about 700,000 to 800,000 each year - are a high death rate, low birth rate, high abortions, & a low level of immigration.
    Russia has a very high death rate of 15 deaths per 1000 people per year. This is far higher than the world's average death rate of just under 9. Alcohol-related deaths in Russia are very high. With this high death rate, Russian life expectancy is low - the WHO estimates life expectancy of Russian men at 59 years while women's life expectancy is considerably better at 72 years. This difference is primarily a result of high rates of alcoholism among males.
    Understandably, due these high rates of alcoholism & economic hardship, women feel less than encouraged to have children. Russia's total fertility rate is low at 1.3 births per woman. This number represents the number of children each Russian woman has during her lifetime. A replacement total fertility rate to maintain a stable population is 2.1 births per woman. During the Soviet era, abortion was quite common; the technique remains common & quite popular today. According to a Russian news source, there are more abortions than births in Russia. The online news source mosnews.com reported that in 2004 1.6M women had abortions in Russia while 1.5M gave birth.
    In 2003, the BBC reported that Russia had, "13 terminations for every 10 live births."
    Additionally, immigration into Russia is low - immigrants are primarily a trickle of ethnic Russians moving out of former republics of Soviet Union. Brain drain & emigration from Russia to Western Europe & other parts of the world is high as Russians seek to better their economic situation. Putin himself explored the issues surrounding the low birth rate during his speech, asking what is preventing a young family, a young woman, from prospering? Answers - low incomes, a lack of normal housing%

  • Comment number 3.

    Reading this article on the Russian way of thinking and ethnicity, what stroke me was this paragraph- “I follow the intellectual life of present-day Russia and see that this feeling of greatness is currently hanging in the balance between a glorious past and a mediocre reality of the present”.
    So I ask, is Russia losing her collective greatness? Or is it being lost individually?

    Dolapo Aina,
    Lagos, Nigeria.

 

BBC iD

Sign in

bbc.co.uk navigation

BBC © 2012 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.