BBC Cardiff Singer Of The World: Opera's next generation

Monday 17 June 2013, 09:02

Petroc Trelawny Petroc Trelawny BBC Radio 3 Presenter

Tagged with:

A towelling bathrobe nearly brought an early end to my time as presenter of BBC Cardiff Singer of the World.

An enthusiastic young producer had decided we needed to know how the competitors relaxed ahead of their moment in the spotlight.

A new hotel had just opened in Cardiff Bay, boasting the city’s first spa facility (this was 1999). So we presented a programme of highlights from there, with me introducing arias while lying robed on a deck-chair, fake red cocktail rakishly positioned to my side.

A colleague interviewed the singers as they were pummelled on a massage table. Not quite how we would style it today.

There are better ways, I have subsequently learned, to get to know the competitors.

The 20 singers that come to Cardiff are at the top of their games, brilliantly talented performers in their late 20s and early 30s, just on the edge of breaking onto the international opera circuit. Cardiff Singer Of The World The final 20 competitors were chosen from over 400 singers

Winning or even reaching final of Cardiff Singer can be the final push their careers need. My fellow presenters and I try to engage with them all during our 10 days in Cardiff.

Some are keen to talk, wanting to know about camera angles, audience figures, checking they will be able to have a DVD of their appearance to send to agents and promoters.

A few singers will express surprise at having been selected, others will be brazenly confident, making it clear they have to come to win – nothing else is of interest.

Some will happily navigate their way around central Cardiff alone, striding between hotel, Wales Millennium Centre (rehearsals), Dora Stoutzker Hall (Song Prize) and St David’s Hall.

Others wait for guidance, keeping heads low until interpreters and helpers come to the rescue.

The distinguished list of past winners – including Anja Harteros, Nicole Cabell, Karita Mattila, Dmitri Hvorostovsky and Katarina Karnéus - creates a sense of respect around Cardiff Singer.

In order to see this content you need to have both Javascript enabled and Flash Installed. Visit BBC Webwise for full instructions. If you're reading via RSS, you'll need to visit the blog to access this content

In 1983 Finland’s Karita Mattila won the very first Cardiff Singer Of The World

You sense that from the nervous energy at the welcome reception as the singers share stories of long journeys and forgotten phone chargers.

Rehearsals start the next day – with just minutes to establish the vital relationship with conductor. Then it’s heads down to work.

The next time I see them is in the make-up room on the fourth floor of St David’s Hall.

You need hairspray? Outside please – the chemicals it contains can play havoc with a singer’s vocal chords.

In order to see this content you need to have both Javascript enabled and Flash Installed. Visit BBC Webwise for full instructions. If you're reading via RSS, you'll need to visit the blog to access this content

‘You’re always looking for voices that give you that tingle’

The tannoy crackles – Miss or Mr XX to the stage.

Little over 15 minutes to entertain the enthusiastic, warm Cardiff audience and win over the highly experienced, all-knowing jury.

Quarter of an hour which can help launch a career.

Watching this rich showcase of opera’s next generation is never short of thrilling. Forget the bathrobes and the health spa – the Cardiff singers represent dramatic television at its best.

Petroc Trelawny will present the extensive coverage of BBC Cardiff Singer Of The World. He has hosted the event on TV since 1999.

BBC Cardiff Singer Of The World begins with Celebrating 30 Years at 7.30pm on Monday, 17 June on BBC Four and BBC Two Wales. For further details of television and radio programme times please see the episode guide. Full performance order details can be found in the 2013 schedule.

More on BBC Cardiff Singer Of The World
About The BBC blog: Marking 30 years of BBC Cardiff Singer of the World 2013

Comments made by writers on the BBC TV blog are their own opinions and not necessarily those of the BBC.

Tagged with:


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Shame that over the years the BBC coverage has shrunk. Nothing from the earlier rounds and just the Leider final. Perhaps it should be renamed Opera Singer of the World and the Leider rounds could be offered, and broadcast, from Leeds Leider.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    Please can you explain why round 1 of the main contest is still not available on iplayer despite it being 11.15pm on Tues, and the round took place on Monday. Why does it take SO long for it to be available on iplayer when it was broadcast at 7.30pm, and wasn't live? "Coming soon", but when?

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    Why do the competitors in Cardiff Singer of the Year have a microphone about six feet in front of them? They are competing as opera singers. There are no microphones in opera houses. If the competition were not recorded for television there would be no microphones in the hall at all. Presumably the microphone is relaying the sound for recording for the television programme and the jury and the live audience are hearing the singing direct. There is no technical reason why viewers at home should no hear the same sound as the jury through a microphone placed in the jury’s table. When a performance at Covent Garden is broadcast live or recorded for a later broadcast the television microphone is a long way from the stage, suspended from the roof.

    The Cardiff microphone distorts the sound. This was very noticeable when the first competitor, Sim, turned aside in Figaro’s aria, and the volume dropped. Moreover many viewers, accustomed to “The X-Factor”, “The Voice” and the like, will get a completely false impression from your programme of what real singing is.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Well done to Jamie Barton - deserved winner of Round 1. But do we really need the commentator to describe the Donizetti Aria in which the Chinese tenor unfortunately cracked on the high Cs as a "stupid piece of music"? Charming, engaging, humorous, fun, demanding, even lightweight - but NOT stupid. Likewise the Croatian's choice of "But who may abide" from "Messiah" may have been inappropriate, but "dated?" Nearly all classical music is "dated" in that it's written by DWEMs - that doesn't stop it being one of the greatest art forms there is. Come on commentators wise up a bit - we need to attract more listeners/viewers and this doesn't help.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    I agree with petersbear that it's a shame about how much the coverage has been reduced. What is also a dreadful shame is that the BBC doesn't edit out the tweets shown on the home page which give away the names of the finalists prior to the broadcasts. It is impossible to read the interesting tweets without seeing the ones from those who feel it necessary to be the first to tell the world the results.This is, after all, a competition and it should try to retain some element of tension. Is it feasible to put the 'spoiler' tweets on a separate link so that they are not immediately visible. A note for petersbear - The spelling of 'Songs' in German is 'Lieder' and, quite ironically in relation to the content of you comment, 'Leider' in German means unfortunately.

  • rate this

    Comment number 6.

    For the 2015 competition and beyond, could the programme planners consider a schedule which allows the recitals and concerts to be broadcast on the day that they actually take place. This would make for much more exciting viewing and listening, and also get around the problem of unwillingly becoming aware of the results in advance of the programme being aired. If a reason for not being able to have a truly live broadcast involves, for example, the time the technical team need to reduce the bits between each performer appearing on stage or to cut out part of the time the jury takes to make their decision, then surely it must be possible to have an 'as live' broadcast incorporating a 1-hour time delay for any necessary editing. I would appreciate it if someone from the BBC could respond, giving the reasons why the present system of a 24-hour delay has to be as it is and also about the possibility of changing it for future CSOTW competitions.

  • rate this

    Comment number 7.

    From beautiful Cape Town : I would have loved to attend this year's Singer of the World competition in beautiful Cardiff. I have attended two of these competitions in past years and I was so looking forward to watching and listening to the clips on the Internet. I appreciate the info about the competitors and all that is relevant about the programmes, but allow me to say I am disappointed that the clips are so short: a few moments of the performance interspersed every few seconds with a similar length of silence. Naturally one cannot expect to hear the whole, but surely a bit more continuity would be far more musically enjoyable? Perhaps there is a rule regarding this? However, being thousands of miles away I am most appreciative of the opportunity to at least enjoy what is presented. Thank you BBC and thank you Cardiff, one of my favourite places in Wales!

  • rate this

    Comment number 8.

    What a pity we are treated to truncated arias! I do hope that when the finals arrive we will hear the full performances.

  • rate this

    Comment number 9.

    You have kindly asked for reminiscences of former BBC Cardiff Singer of the World events.

    A feature of this magnificent competition which always amuses and moves me occurs at its very end.

    On the final evening, the entire complement of the hall rises to its feet and sings the Welsh National Song ("O Land of my Fathers").

    It is worth studying the feet and eyes of the contestants and jury-members who come from abroad. They visibly rock back on their heels and look amazed, as well they may.

    They had never in their lives supposed (I fancy) that a random selection of human beings making up a very large audience could all be so richly musical.

    The audience members sing in perfect unanimity, take to four-part harmony (in many cases) like ducks to water, and deliver a beautifully modulated account of that fine hymn.

    You can almost read in the faces of the Finnish, Chinese, American, Italian and other foreign persons present - themselves top-class professionals of course - the following thought: 'If they only had a chorus like this at the Met or La Scala, we really would hear some opera in this world, wouldn't we?'

    More seriously, it makes momentarily for the rest of us a little sideways squint into Paradise.

    We are given to hear at first-hand what an entirely musical world would sound like: everybody knowing how to sing and doing it beautifully.

    No Welshman myself, I lift my hat to a true land of song.

    This is why it is so right to have this competition in THIS capital city - Cardiff.

    Peter Scott, Buxton, Derbyshire.

  • rate this

    Comment number 10.

    Hello, I’m an interactive producer for BBC Cardiff Singer Of The World. Thank you for your comment about the official tweets giving away who the winner is before you’ve had a chance to watch. We’ve decided that we’ll announce the winner each night via a link to their biog, so unless you click on it, you won’t know who has won. We hope this works better!

  • rate this

    Comment number 11.

    When you compare the ludicrous amount of coverage of Britain's Got Talent or football or the Voice [whose contestants would kill to be able to sing like the Cardiff Singers] to the shockingly poor airing that our beloved Cardiff Singer has, well you take the tenor of the BBC. This is the most important singing competition on the planet. Why tell us that and prevent us enjoying it? Must the BBC dumb down such super stuff? Are we to be deliberately deprived of highly regarded musical programmes because cranked up management don't think we are fit to be elevated to such levels? Now to more dodges: if you are working in the evening, you cannot see the whole show on iplayer, you are given selected trivialised giddy-style titbits geared up with jittery hype. Let us judge what is good for ourselves,thankyou. Also, why does that presenter keep lying to us saying we can see the whole show repeated the next night when that is the timing for the next broadcast?.Thanks BBC for making trying to make fools of your serious audience: 'O for a muse of fire to ascend the brightest heaven of invention!' Remember your constitution-you owe us much better!

  • rate this

    Comment number 12.

    I would greatly appreciate an answer from someone at the BBC to my question of 19th June, please.
    Also, I am very surprised that it is still not possible to see round 3 on iplayer at 7pm on Friday; it is still "coming soon". What is causing the inordinate delay?
    Regrettably the coverage of the event is not extensive, despite it being entitled BBC CSOTW, and now it's not yet possible to see round 3 even though it took place as long ago as Wednesday. This is such a shame as I have been looking forward to CSOTW, and cannot (together with many other people) watch most of the rounds when they are broadcast.

  • rate this

    Comment number 13.

    So much of each programme from Cardiff is taken up with credits, doubtless enormously costly computer animations (all those stars whizzing around noisily) and empty chatter. In 2015, please eliminate the superfluous and just give us the full concert from start to finish. The BBC would save money and we would have more singing. Are these transmissions not serious music programmes and intended for opera/Lieder lovers? We don't need to be told repeatedly of the importance of the Cardiff competition. We, the TV audience KNOW it's important, that's why we follow the event on the (excellent) website, on Radio 3 when we can and on the truncated TV coverage.

  • rate this

    Comment number 14.

    Although I often agree with Mary King's opinions about the individual voices, I'm finding her constant emphasis on the singers' physiques very off putting. Her little video clip about how opera has changed and how looks are now so important was unnecessary and offensive. We all know how obsessed society is with looks and thinness; we don't need reminding. And we don't need our collective societal neurosis sanctioned by the resident "expert". I am a singer and a teacher of a singer, like Mary King, and I absolutely disagree with her with the notion that a bigger voice has no relation to body size. In my years of experience, it clearly does. Big, dramatic voices tend to come in bodies that at least have a bit of extra padding. And the fact that we now have a dearth of truly great dramatic singers out there has something to do with the stupid prejudice against largeness that is somewhat being presented to us by the Cardiff experts as a wonderful new thing. Sure, if I were a casting director, I'd be thrilled if a well, formed attractive singer with a great voice auditioned for me. But it doesn't meant that everyone needs to be a movie star. Dame Kiri Te Kanawa herself has lamented the pressure young sopranos are under to be overly thin. I don't think Cardiff Singer of the World needs to be feeding into the general neurosis. Furthermore, If we'd had this attitude in the past, we would been denied some of the most glorious singing we've heard, from people like Pavarotti, Margaret Price or Monserrat Caballe. In the past, there were all kinds of singers-some thin and glamorous and some large with fabulous voices. I think opera audiences like a wide variety of choice and mostly they love good singing. It is the administrators and directors that are insisting on limiting the choice for audiences and I don't see why Mary King is acting like this is a nifty new development.

  • rate this

    Comment number 15.

    Awj thanks for the spelling correction, my language teacher partner has a red biro for restaurant menus but has not found all my postings!

  • rate this

    Comment number 16.

    Giving the song prize to Jamie Barton's for her overcharged operatic performance in preference to Ben Johnson's beautifully judged song recital was perverse. Vote for Ben Johnson for the Audience Prize to Right the Wrong!

  • rate this

    Comment number 17.

    At least the audience got it right! Not convinced about the main prize winner either, can not see her dying of consumption! I know posters complain about size comments but in this day and age the audience does expect casting and acting as well as musicality, not the old stand and deliver style I remember in the 1950s.

  • rate this

    Comment number 18.

    petersbear, I think you can stand and deliver if you are delivering the kind of sound and artistry that Jamie Barton displayed. And she's not a soprano. She's not going to be dying of consumption in any role she sings. If you don't like largeness, you don't have to pay a ticket to see her. Plenty of people will.

  • rate this

    Comment number 19.

    While being happy that Ben Johnson won the Audience Prize as he is a class act, I do worry somewhat that people outside the UK could not vote in the online vote on the BBC website. This might well help the singers from within the UK as their friends and supporters vote for them en masse.


This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Horizon: The Secret Life Of The Cat

Thursday 13 June 2013, 09:21

Quick Cuts: Confessions from a hairdressers

Wednesday 19 June 2013, 08:55

About this Blog

Get the views of cast, presenters, scriptwriters and crew from inside the shows. Read reviews and opinions and share yours on all things TV - your favourite episodes, live programmes, the schedule and everything else.

We ask that comments on the blog fall within the house rules.

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?