BBC BLOGS - Betsan's Blog
« Previous | Main | Next »

No Show

Betsan Powys | 13:34 UK time, Monday, 17 September 2007

A long journey down to Brighton to the Lib Dems Federal Conference and half way between Southampton and the conference centre I started to think Assembly group leader Mike German had a point. He's staying away 'to prepare for the new term'. I did see a sign as I crawled through Sompting: 'GERMAN here' and got my hopes up but that was a shop selling European car parts.

Not that inappropriate, given the Lib Dem Assembly group has started to sound a bit like Team McLaren these days. Not sure who's going to end up cutting up who or on which bend but a friendly, non-Assembly voice outside the conference centre this lunchtime suggested that the only way forward for the leader now is to engineer a 'controlled change' ... in other words, how does he make sure he gets to hand over to his pal, Jenny Randerson and have the last laugh?

She has said consistently and for a very long time that she'd never stand against Mike German. But if here were gone, of course, there'd be nothing to stop her. And would she get it? As caretaker leader for 4 years perhaps? She might well.

By the way you might not have spotted this story but I did. It's from the Wales on Sunday and is about Ieuan Wyn Jones arriving at the Venue in Llandudno and ...

'... being greeted by a slightly lukewarm round of applause from a small gaggle of party activists. This of course wouldn't have made particularly impressive viewing on the evening news. So the BBC kindly asked if the whole entrance could be redone again, this time with the delegates whooping and hollering at Mr Jones' arrival as if he was all four Beatles rolled into one ...'

It goes on: 'This looks bad in the current climate admitted one Beeb man'. Quite right. If it had happened. There is a story about a double entrance from Heritage Minister Rhodri Glyn Thomas on Helen Mary Jones' conference blog and here it is:

Oh, but before I forget, I had the chance to greet Rhodri Glyn Thomas, the new Minister for Heritage, as he arrived at conference. There was a crowd of us waiting outside. It was kind of spoilt by the TV cameras asking us to greet him not once, but twice. Apparently we weren’t whooping and clapping loudly enough, the first time - and Rhodri was a bit embarrassed and went past us all too fast! On the second attempt, some people behind me resorted to screaming. Sorry, back to the serious stuff.'

Make of that what you will. But 'in the current climate' inserting 'BBC' and upping the ante to the Deputy First Minister? Yes, it does look bad.

Comments   Post your comment

  • 1.
  • At 04:10 PM on 17 Sep 2007,
  • Andy Godsall wrote:

Sorry, Betsan, please confirm. Did the BBC play any role in 're-shooting' the entrance shots of a Plaid Minister? I'm guessing by the 'sleight of hand' displayed in your post that you did. If so, do you not agree that this is 'serious stuff'?

Just to be clear the 'back to the serious stuff' comment didn't come from me Andy. That came from Helen Mary Jones' blog. The italics in my original entry ended in the wrong place for some technical reason - now corrected. If I didn't think there was a serious debate to be had about using shots that have been re-done - no matter what the circumstances - I wouldn't have drawn your attention to the story in the first place. But the implication of the WoS story is serious and wrong. Was it a BBC cameraman/reporter who asked Rhodri Glyn Thomas to walk in again? No it wasn't. Were they there filming? Yes. Why was he asked to walk in again? Because the organised arrival was so rushed the press photographers and cameramen present barely got him in shot. He turned on his heels, walked in again, this time in shot. The reason why we used the second shot and not the first was because viewers at home could clearly see the new Heritage Minister arriving and that was the sole point of using the shot in the first place.

This post is closed to new comments.

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.