iPlayer Radio What's New?

A response to queries over the closure of The Archers messageboard

Wednesday 13 February 2013, 18:29

Nigel Smith Nigel Smith Interactive Editor

Tagged with:

 Radio 4 Interactive Editor Nigel Smith responds to queries over the closure of The Archers Message Board.

Archers Logo

Thanks for all the comments and questions you've been leaving on my blog since Monday - we've been reading them with the team and wanted to address some of the key themes that have come up.

Wynkyn de worde and Country Squire, among many others, suggest that we are taking this step because we no longer wish to hear your thoughts. I want to reassure you that we'll still be listening to all The Archers fans and your feedback, both the good and the bad, will be shared with the team on a regular basis. We understand the message board has been there for you to discuss the ups and downs of the programme and we hope that you'll continue to do so both with us on Facebook and Twitter where we've seen our numbers grow. For those of you who prefer the message board format, there are lively discussions taking place outside the BBC's website such as Archers Addicts and Mustard Land/Peet's Place.

As I said in my earlier post, the closure of the boards reflects wider changes in the BBC's online services. Sites that have only a peripheral connection with our editorial purposes, don't significantly enhance our content or only engage small audiences can no longer justify the resources they need.

The Archers website is an important part of the Radio 4 online service and we will continue to produce varied and interesting content to our Archers fans online. Gnome de Plume of Dun Lissnin asked if this is to do with money and yetagainintimb also asked if we'll be making other programmes with the money saved by the closure. As with any other team across the BBC, we do have to prioritise what we do and we know that most Archers listeners come to the website to listen to the programme, download the podcasts and catch up with storylines and character profiles. The department that looks after the Radio 4 websites isn't specifically a programme-making department but we are always looking to innovate digitally and bring our programmes to the widest possible audience. So recently, for example, we've been directing our efforts into making available much of the back catalogue of Desert Island Discs, more than 900 editions of Alistair Cooke's Letter From America and creating special pages for the Woman's Hour Power List. We have also launched the Listening Project website, allowing listeners to upload their own conversations to be played out on Radio 4 and BBC local radio stations.

Nemo399 asked about how you can continue to access the message board. You'll still be able to view all the threads on the board once it's closed. It won't be possible to download all the threads but we will be providing a link to them in the Related Links section of the website.

We understand and respect the value some of you place upon the connections you've made with each other via the message board. We have given users two-weeks' notice so they can find alternative forums and it's great to see so many already doing so.

The BBC does take great care in trying to protect vulnerable audiences - such as children and young people - who are coming to us online. So we have clear house rules to help ensure that everyone is treated fairly and consistently when discussing BBC programmes. But we are not and never can be experts in providing specialist support and we would also urge those who feel they need help and guidance to consult organisations with the relevant expertise.

I've tried to cover the most common themes in the many comments posted on this blog as best I can. Please be assured that we do value your contributions and I hope in the future that even the sceptics among you can be persuaded to continue to discuss The Archers with us. 


Nigel Smith

Interactive Editor, Radio 4 & 4 Extra


Other places to talk about The Archers online

The Archers Facebook page – official page run by Tayler and Keri

The Archers on Twitter – official profile run by Tayler

#thearchers – Twitter hashtag

Archers Addicts Forum - fan forum

Peet's Place - fan forum



Tagged with:


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Thank you. Just one correction--I actually asked about the website, not the messageboard. I'm probably in a minority, but I like the blogs.

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    It's a great shame that you feel that helpful comments and corrections posted on the message boards "don't significantly enhance our content". They have done, in the past, and could still continue to do so.

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    This seems to be answers to very few cherry-picked questions. Nigel, what definition of 'interaction' are you using?

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Blitherblatherblitherblather.....how much are you saving, how many visitors do the blogs have, how much does it cost to run the message board? Are afew of the questions asked...
    I shall just go and talk to the wall, it gives as clear an answer as you do...

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Well, that was hardly worth the effort. Not exactly a wholehearted demonstration of how to interact with your audience, Nigel. You've only answered a couple of general points made to your previous blog, and in a manner that suggets you have either ignored the many excellent point made, or that you have failed to understand what people are saying.
    For example, you tell us we can still give feedback via Facebook and Twitter.

    Nigel - have you actually looked at your facebook page and seen how very few people bother to say anything there? A mere handful per day.

    As for Twitter: did you bother to read any of the comments to your previous blog? If so, how did you manage to miss all the people who say they have no interest in Twitter?
    Twitter has been rejected by most of the ML posters who prefer discussions that run to more than 140 characters. To mention it yet again demonstrates that you do not know how to interact with your online audience.

    I look forward to reading your response to all the many questions left unanswered, especially those concerning actual costs in running the boards.


Comments 5 of 262


This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Closure of The Archers message board

Monday 11 February 2013, 12:00

Ambridge ups and downs - 18 February 2013

Monday 18 February 2013, 08:27

About this Blog

Backstage news and insight into The Archers. Curated by Keri Davies.

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

The Archers tweets