iPlayer Radio What's New?
The Fabric of Each Other

Round-up of reviews

Wednesday 25 February 2009, 14:35

Steve Bowbrick Steve Bowbrick Head of Interactive, Radio 3

One of the reasons we started the Radio 4 blog is to draw attention to the huge variety of programmes that go out on Radio 4, very often with no attention from the professional media at all. Radio doesn't get the attention it deserves and speech radio is especially neglected.

Station Controller Mark Damazer has made a start by talking about programmes he likes (The Film Programme and The Moral Maze, for instance) and we're also going to do regular round-ups of reviews from the noble handful of journalists whose job it is to actually listen to speech radio and from the bloggers who do it for love.

In regular blog posts we'll capture as much of the net's day-to-day conversation about Radio 4 as we can - from Twitter, the blogs and message boards as well as from the mainstream media. We'll also welcome your suggestions and pointers to content and conversation we might have missed.

What's more, where we can, we'll link to the programmes' web pages so you can listen again if you're inspired to do so. Here's my first round-up:

Gillian Reynolds in The Telegraph loved Alan Bennett's dramatisation of his story about a homeless woman who lived in a van on his driveway:

...you could almost smell her, not an easy thing for radio to manage but, between Bennett's brilliant description, Adrian Scarborough's clever alter-Bennett, Smith's great performance, and Gordon House's sensitive direction, it did.

Listen to the Saturday Play, The Lady in the Van here.

David Smith, in his profile of David Walliams in The Guardian, makes much use of his Desert Island Discs grilling last Sunday

Kirsty Young asks the comedian outright: "Have you ever had a relationship with a man?" Walliams responds: "No." With unhesitating candour, Walliams says: "If I fell in love with a man then, yeah, I wouldn't say that could never happen..."

Islingtongue. North East London blogger John has been enjoying Book of the Week: Iain Sinclair's Hackney: That Rose Red Empire:

...the book will have a resonance far beyond that brilliantly blighted rotten borough.

Listen here.

In The Guardian, Miranda Sawyer refuses to review Lenny Henry plays Othello:

This is not current events, it's craven advertising.

Listen here.

Kate Chisholm in The Spectator thinks running a season of Sarah Kane's controversial plays would be a better tribute than Blasted: The Life and Death of Sarah Kane:

At half an hour the programme was far too short to explore fully the nature of Kane's troubled talent.

Listen here


Jump to comments pagination
  • rate this

    Comment number 1.

    Isn't it about time that Gillian Reynolds was brought into the Radio 4 tent ? Either as an 'exec' or maybe to do a 'feedback' style flagellation of execs who get it wrong ??

    Radio hasn't been the same since her dulcet tones disappeared when Parky gave up his Radio 2 Sunday show.

    Maybe you could syndicate a podcast of a weekly 'One 2 One' appraisal meeting where Mr Damazer has to justify his performance to GR with a gold star for good behaviour and a detention if he doesn't quite 'make the grade'..

    Just a thought..

  • rate this

    Comment number 2.

    "Radio doesn't get the attention it deserves and speech radio is especially neglected."

    Sorry, but methinks you doth protest too much - radio listener figures are on the up.

    Okay, I don't see the 'telly' people quaking in their boots, but the danger is that you might become the gorilla which commercial stations view as a threat to their survival, especially in Wales which is both a region and a nation.

    And I'm afraid trying to capture the public's view of Radio 4 by looking at fatuous 'twitter' messages is a bit like trying to find out what people think of opera by hanging out at the local skateboard park.

    Isn't the real danger here that by obsessing about what is 'in' or 'cool' or 'on-trend' or whatever other asinine 'yoof' adjective is currently being applied, that it will result in 'iPlayer' cherry-picking of the programmes people want to listen to.

    Coupled with a drop in people 'just tuning in' and finding programmes like 'In Touch' or 'File on Four' or even 'Woman's Hour' for which they might not be in the demographic [or even gender..] target market, but which they might benefit from listening to ??

    That said, I appreciate that just as with Marks and Sparks, you can't just rely on the 'saga' element to bring you future success.

    By the way - why isn't more being made of LIBBY PURVES DOING STAND UP COMEDY !?

    This is surely as close to unmissable radio as getting Count Arthur Strong to do the Today Programme ?

    It could replicate the 'car-crash-tv' of Bobby Pinstripe Peston going to Newcastle, but on radio for sheer 'I want to switch it off, but I just can't..' will she/ won't she crash ?'

  • rate this

    Comment number 3.

    "We'll also welcome your suggestions" - get rid of 'Quote Unquote'. It is the sort unbearably smug drivel that repels newer listeners and gives R4 a bad name. Catch it by mistake on your dial and most people wouldn't come back.

  • rate this

    Comment number 4.

    Great blog. Only just found it. I'm disabled and listen to Radio 4 almost 24/7. And if I miss anything I'm right there with 'Listen Again'.

  • rate this

    Comment number 5.

    Smoked Haddock - Unfortunately 'Quote Unquote', 'Poetry Please' and the execrable 'You and Yours' are the 3 'canaries in the mine' whose absence would send the Radio 4 Rescue Teams onto 'Emergency Alert' as the rest of the station may be under attack and the roof might be about to fall in...

    Which possibly also explains the fuss over the UK Theme and 'Thought for the Day'.

    Sometimes, though, you have to put up with a bit of dross to prevent other quirky stuff being zapped because they aren't 'cool' or 'yoof' enough....


Comments 5 of 9


This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

I'm Sorry I Haven't A Clue

Tuesday 24 February 2009, 18:01

Just a Minute

Thursday 26 February 2009, 10:02

About this Blog

Behind the scenes at Radio 4 and Radio 4 Extra from producers, presenters and programme makers.

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

Follow Radio 4

Follow BBC Radio 4 & BBC Radio 4 Extra on Twitter for programme highlights and interesting retweets. 

Woman's Hour Power List 2014

Identifying the top ten game changers operating in the UK today.
See the latest on our blog
Find out about this year's panel and theme
Woman's Hour Power List judges, 2014 Woman's Hour Power List judges, 2014


Identifying the top ten game changers operating in the UK today.


See the latest on our blog


Find out about this year's panel and theme