iPlayer Radio What's New?
Listen
On Now : 15 Minute Drama
Queens of Noise: Rip It Up - Episode 1

The Woman's Hour Power List: How we found our Top 100

Tuesday 12 February 2013, 09:02

Ruth Watts Ruth Watts Producer, Woman's Hour

Tagged with:

Editor's Note: The Woman's Hour Power List is announced on Tuesday 12 February. Listen to the programme and see the full list.

On Tuesday Woman’s Hour publishes its first Power List, chosen by an independent panel of judges, Priti Patel MP, Dawn O’Porter, Val McDermid, Baroness Oona King, Jill Burridge and chaired by Eve Pollard and guided by our listeners.

Woman's Hour Power List Panel Members of the Woman's Hour Power List Panel: Dawn Porter, Eve Pollard, Preeti Patel and Val McDermi

So how did we get here?

In October we invited Woman's Hour listeners to nominate the women who they thought held the most power in the country. The response was overwhelming. More than 4,000 listeners sent us their suggestions through email, Twitter and Facebook yielding more than 1,600 different names. The task of deciding who would make the top 100 was daunting.

There were prominent doctors, lawyers, scientists, artists and leaders from the public, private and voluntary sectors – many of them accomplished, respected and successful.

And so the panel of judges met for the first time in December at Broadcasting House to discuss how they would set about the task. I was in the room throughout watching them go about it.

The criteria

Stilettoes

The brief was simple: to compose a list of the 100 most powerful women in the UK at the start of 2013. We placed no limits on who could be on the list, other than to say that they must be British, or operating in the UK today. We asked them to think widely about where we find powerful women.

We also asked them to keep in mind a few criteria in making their decisions. They should consider what impact women have had on the country – political, economic, social, cultural or intellectual.

Could these women make meaningful decisions to bring about change? And did they have the financial resources to bring about that change?

We also asked them to consider the place of leadership, the ability to inspire and to act as role models. However, we left it to them to decide how to balance these factors.

Adele v Joanna Lumley: Measuring power

In addition to the suggestions from listeners, we consulted widely, taking advice from expert witnesses about some of the leading women in their field and about how they measure power, including Baroness Helena Kennedy on law, head-hunter Heather McGregor on business, and The Economist journalist Anne McElvoy on public policy. All of these recommendations were fed to the judges who were also free to bring their own names to the table.

There was agreement that political and financial power could not be ignored; that money can change people’s lives. But they also thought that power wasn’t just about money or legislation – power was about making a real and noticeable difference. Neither could they escape the overwhelming impact of influencers – those who could change the way we think. And then there were the celebrities and role models who were prepared to use their power… and the curious question of whether David Cameron would be more likely to pick up the phone to Adele or Joanna Lumley?

The Final 100

The final list reflects these competing views of power and the process of negotiating how individual women used their power. Persuasive cases were made for individual women including JK Rowling, Chrissie Rucker and Denise Coates. They listened, discussed and reached deliberate decisions. Weighing up the relative ability of women ranging across every sphere to make an impact was not a process for fine metrics. Comparing the merits of a FTSE listed CEO and an artistic director proved to be an art, and not a science. And in one sense what the women who have made it on to the list have in common is an ability to set the agenda in 2013 and to see it through.

The panel took the decision that given the breadth of talents and achievements they were comparing, it made sense to rank only the top 20 names. After that it was agreed that the distinction between one number and the next was less meaningful – particularly when you might be comparing the power of a chief executive with a leading scientist.

And who was left off the list?

Protest vs Lobbying: The Power List

The judges were keen to find women from every background in every area of life. There was disappointment that there were gaps where they did not find women in the most powerful jobs – in areas such as newspaper journalism, pharmaceuticals and the Armed Forces.

There was also disappointment that the list was not more diverse and that no woman from an ethnic minority had made it into the top 20. But there was a hope that the legacy of the list might be as a reality check; that it might open a conversation about what needs to done to change things.

In the interests of transparency they took the decision to withdraw themselves from consideration. And as presenters of Woman’s Hour, Jenni Murray and Jane Garvey were not eligible for inclusion.

More importantly there were nearly 1,500 women nominated by our listeners who have not made the list. There were women, whose careers have been dedicated to curing disease, entertaining people, running our schools and hospitals and leading our communities.

There were many brilliant women who the judges considered, but ultimately left off the final list.  But, in the end this was not a testament to the many amazing achievements of women in 2013 – it was an attempt to capture the women who have power now.

Follow the Power List Live Blog as it is announced

Listen as the Power List is announced live from the Radio Theatre

Hear the Power List discussions so far

Download the Power List podcast

Tagged with:

Comments

Jump to comments pagination
 
  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 1.

    I do wonder if women's hour wasn't on bbc 4 and was on at a time when most women could hear it the list would be different. Surely it is representative of bbc4 listeners, middle aged middle class white women, I can only listen because I'm on maternity leave. However it is a good start... I'm enjoying listening.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 2.

    Oh dear, I found the whole thing nauseating and self congratulatory. What a bubble of loveliness this lot are in. Is it so impossible to maintain some contact with the real world? Paying lip service to how they understand the struggles endured by the rest of the population has been exposed today.

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 3.

    The queen you must be joking!!!

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 4.

    With the missus the laundry is no sooner on her list-then in a jif, it seems, it's all reekingly and de novo fresh-as if a rinse and dry of the list did the same for the laundry stuck on it too whatever the pomp or down around your ankles numbers of them all.
    And since a preponderance of guys didn't determine how much power one not of them should have-ain't this real old gal power!

  • rate this
    0

    Comment number 5.

    What exactly was the point of this exercise ? Hardly taken the world by storm has it despite the Today programme presumably being forced to feature it on the News !!!!!!! Perleeze. Woman's Hour has such an inflated idea of its own importance. It's just 45 minutes of chat of a morning. Get over yourselves.

 
 

This entry is now closed for comments

Share this page

More Posts

Previous
The Trouble with adapting Orwell’s Nineteen Eighty-Four

Monday 11 February 2013, 14:19

Next
Saturday Review: A Life of Galileo at Stratford

Thursday 14 February 2013, 17:41

About this Blog

Behind the scenes at Radio 4 and Radio 4 Extra from producers, presenters and programme makers.

Blog Updates

Stay updated with the latest posts from the blog.

Subscribe using:

What are feeds?

Follow Radio 4

Follow BBC Radio 4 & BBC Radio 4 Extra on Twitter for programme highlights and interesting retweets. 

Woman's Hour Power List 2014

Identifying the top ten game changers operating in the UK today.
See the latest on our blog
Find out about this year's panel and theme
Woman's Hour Power List judges, 2014 Woman's Hour Power List judges, 2014

 

Identifying the top ten game changers operating in the UK today.

 

See the latest on our blog

 

Find out about this year's panel and theme