Ed's note: The Thinking Allowed newsletter gets sent out on Wednesday mornings and while its primary purpose may be alerting listeners to the contents of that afternoon's programme it's always a great read in its own right. In the newsletter this week Laurie Taylor paid tribute to his friend and colleague Robert Robinson so it felt fitting to share it here. There'll also be a special programme on Radio 4 paying tribute to Robert Robinson this Saturday. Details about this and subscribing to Laurie's newsletter at the end of the post - PM.
Robert Robinson, journalist and broadcaster in 1962.
In the week in which I learned with great sadness of the death of my old friend and colleague, Robert Robinson, it was perhaps inevitable that I should find myself recalling some of his wry observations about how life should properly be lived.
I particularly remember the day when he discovered that I lived in a flat. He told me that quite frankly, he'd expected nothing else. There was something about my bohemian posturing which suggested that I would be unsuited to a proper house.
In his customary manner he then warmed to his theme and suggested that people who lived in flats had a far more transient, nomadic character than those who preferred houses. Indeed, he would expect adulterers and libertines of all kinds to be over-represented in flats. For what flats and apartments lacked was any solidity or weight or sense of permanence.
If you lived in a house you always had the feeling that you were rooted to the space that the house occupied. Your foundations went down into the ground and your house grew up from the ground. You were part of an organic entity.
Flats, by contrast, had no such base. They were merely anonymous units coupled to other anonymous units. They had never been family homes for long periods of time. They had never developed a distinctive history. They had simply been residences for people who were passing through on their way to somewhere else.
I didn't argue with Bob.
By then I'd already learned that there was far more enjoyment to be had from allowing him to embroider a theme than from challenging him to an argument about its premises.
But his views stayed in my head and I often found myself constructing a counter - argument to justify my own continued occupancy of flats.
Couldn't it be said, for example, that the impermanence of flats was a positive virtue? People who lived in houses were surely more likely to develop static conservative attitudes to life than those who occupied more flexible and transient accommodation.
And might not flat dwellers also be far more sociable than house owners in that they were obliged to rub shoulders with those who lived on the same floor as themselves, with those they met in the lift, with those they ran into when they were collecting mail from the communal hallway?
And weren't those who lived in flats also likely to have a more heterogeneous collection of acquaintances than house-dwellers. For whereas a street usually only contained people from one socio-economic class, a block of flats could include rich penthouse owners as well as renters of lower economic status who occupied the basement or lower ground apartments.
Flats could also inspire a real sense of community as residents came together to further their mutual interests, to clean up the common parts, or organise a Royal Wedding party. They encouraged co-operation rather than individuality and privacy.
However, now that I've read a new book on a seventeen storey commercial and residential block in Hong Kong's tourist district, I realise that I've barely begun to understand the range of functions that such buildings can sustain. Chungking Mansions is home to a huge variety of people, but, according to author and anthropologist Gordon Matthews it is not a place of darkness but a beacon of hope - a wonderful experiment in living.
Also today: Is there any evidence that targeting the parents of gang members can reduce children's involvement in gang culture?
Laurie Taylor presents Thinking Allowed
- A Tribute to Robert Robinson will be broadcast on Saturday 20 Aug 2011 at 20:00 on Radio 4
- This episode of Thinking Allowed is available to listen to online or to download on the Thinking Allowed podcast page.
- This episode is also repeated on Radio 4 on Monday 22 August 2011 00:15
- You can find out more about the programme's partnership with The Open University and related features by going to their website.
- Find our more about this episode on the Thinking Allowed website which is repeated on Radio 4 on Sunday night just after midnight.
- Sign up for Laurie's Thinking Allowed newsletter.
- Follow Radio 4 on Twitter or see a full list of Radio 4 accounts on Twitter
- Join the Radio 4 page on Facebook