BBC Blog Network

User Profile

Kíllìnghölmê_Clá¥ (aka Charlie Cheesecake)

Listed below are comments made by Kíllìnghölmê_Clá¥ (aka Charlie Cheesecake) between Sunday, 22nd November 2009 and Monday, 30th November 2009.

«Newer
Older»

Moyes & Everton face testing times 12:27pm on 30 Nov 2009 39. At 10:59am on 30 Nov 2009, JPLegend wrote
For those that have missed it, Mr McNulty has joined a bandwagon of "reporters" in a continuous witch-hunt of Benitez ever since he put him on the pedestal of pre-season favourite for the title.

I’ve made much the same comments in the past about Phil McNulty’s barbed sideswipes at Benitez but, of course, he either ignores the allegation or simply denies what is plainly true.
I’m glad others are now noticing this unnecessary need to join the hoards of other Manchestercentric journalists in attempting to make their own Liverpool/Benitez headlines.

Good post mate.
Moyes & Everton face testing times 11:56am on 30 Nov 2009 A win in any shape or form will boost confidence. That's two on the trot and now the preferred pairing of Carragher and Agger is in place and will be the foundation laid for Liverpool to progress this season.
Despite the terrible season Liverpool have had, we find ourselves in 5th place and still in touch with everyone up to 2nd. (Its Chelsea's year, as I predicted).

I do sympathise with Evertonians. Their season has been decimated by injuries to key players and have also had to replace Lescott who moved to manchester, presumably for the weather. Its difficult to see them making any inroads on qualifying for European competition again this season and there is the spectre of being drawn inexorably into a relegation dog fight should the Christmas and New Year campaign go badly. Kenwright has a job on his hands to find suitable investors, but the biggest struggle is for Moyes who is having to replace people such as Lescott with players who I'm afraid are from the bargain basement.
Benitez under spotlight after Champions League exit 09:35am on 26 Nov 2009 I know from writing about Benitez that any criticism can provoke an angry response from many
-------------------------------------------------------------------

That's not the case. On the contrary, I agree with a lot of what you have said today, which was thoughtful and contained non of the usual unnecessary barbed comments. Rafa Benitez does have his work cut out and I'm sure he will have to produce something in the way of trophies within the next 18 months. (Did you realise that Arsenal haven't won a trophy since 2005? Nobody in their right mind would suggest that Arsene is on borrowed time).

However, I couldnt write a response to you without some sort of criticism. I'm sure you'd navigate away from this page with a feeling of disappointment if that happened.

There were three comments from you whilst at Old Trafford during United's loss to Besiktas. One about what Man Utd fans were singing about "Merseyside", Everton's bad news about their proposed move to Kirkby and, on seventy five minutes you managed to mention that Besiktas hadn't been out of their own half.
Now if that had been Liverpool.......
Will South Africa 2010 produce a new Pele? 08:17am on 24 Nov 2009 During Pele's era (which I was fotunate enough to witness) football was played for the love of the game. Greed has long since killed that romance. Sadly I dont think his like will ever be seen again.
Man City will regret lack of ambition 10:21am on 23 Nov 2009 @ 92. At 10:03am on 23 Nov 2009, Phil McNulty - BBC Sport wrote:

So I'm right then.
Uncomfortable as it may be for you, you've changed "being supportive of Benitez" to "not being unduly critical" because your claim was completely untrue.
Man City will regret lack of ambition 09:26am on 23 Nov 2009 Phil,

I take it that by now ignoring the issue, you now concede that there has been no evidence of you being "supportive" to Benitez.

(Tipping Liverpool for the title isn't being supportive. I tipped Chelsea and that cetainly doesnt indicate any degree of supportiveness on my part).
Man City will regret lack of ambition 09:09am on 23 Nov 2009 62. At 5:51pm on 22 Nov 2009, Phil McNulty - BBC Sport wrote:
Last word on the Benitez comments for today for poster 58. I do not think I have been unduly critical of the Liverpool manager at all. Don't forget I tipped them for the title this season - wrongly as it transpired. Honest opinion on the events of this season - are you satisfied?
_______________________________________________________________________

You said you had been "supportive" of Benitez. When challenged as to exactly what you have been supportive about you change the the claim to "not being unduly critical".

Doesn't this prove my point?
Man City will regret lack of ambition 4:52pm on 22 Nov 2009 44. At 3:09pm on 22 Nov 2009, Phil McNulty - BBC Sport wrote:
And to Kíllìnghölmê_Clá¥ (aka Charlie Cheesecake)...I thought I was rather supportive of Benitez and the situation he found himself in with injuries yesterday in the blog. I'm sure you'll agree.
______________________________________________________________________
My apologies if I missed you saying anything supportive of Benitez or Liverpool.

Did you mean this comment? "And while Liverpool could offer up some slight excuse for their lamentable display after early injuries to Daniel Agger and Ryan Babel halted momentum."

Maybe you meant something else, as this doesn't qualify remotely as supportive, more an illustration of the barbed sideswipes I have been pointing out.
Man City will regret lack of ambition 2:25pm on 22 Nov 2009 redthemadsheep2001
ive just read enough of phils blogs thats all. and i neither read the Sun nor the Daily mail, i detest them both
_____________________________________________________________________

Ok so if you get some time, go through his blogs and see how many don't have a Benitez or Liverpool sideswipe. His previous one springs to mind but it is a consistent feature in pretty much all of the others. Wherever there's a mention of Benitez or Liverpool, there's a barb and it gets tiresome. I actually enjoy reading Phil's blogs up unitl the point when he simply cant contain his need to stoop to the lower regions of bargain basement journalism. It always seems to be the opposite story when dealing with Ferguson or Man Utd.

Nice to have a decent conversation with you, Red. It really makes a change from the usual abusive prepubescent Man Utd fans.
Man City will regret lack of ambition 1:50pm on 22 Nov 2009 @33. At 1:00pm on 22 Nov 2009, redthemadsheep2001 wrote:

So you are completely unaware of the ManchesterUnitedcentric journalism ploy of build 'em up, knock 'em down? Read this blog or buy the Sun or Daily Mail- it's all the same fare seved up in slightly different guises.

Someone's a bit naiive.

«Newer
Older»

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites