Advertisement
BBC BLOGS - Nick Robinson's Newslog

Politicians, the press and the police

Nick Robinson | 18:00 UK time, Thursday, 9 July 2009

Comments (553)

Politicians, the press and the police.

Together they have become the Bermuda Triangle into which reputations have simply disappeared.

After cash for honours, came the arrest of a Tory MP who'd received leaks and passed them to the papers. After the scandal of MPs' expenses comes today's row about who knew what about the hacking of the phones of the great and the good and the merely famous.

John YatesBut today Yates of the Yard decided that he did not want another starring role on the national political stage.

His insistence that there was no evidence that John Prescott's phone was tapped, insufficient evidence to bring other prosecutions and that no new evidence had been produced by the Guardian, sounded pretty definitive but these waters are still treacherous.

There will still be a Commons enquiry and there will be calls for an independent investigation into the police's handling of this affair.

There will still be awkward questions for News International, for the Tories' Director of Communications Andy Coulson and for the man who hired him David Cameron.

This is a story fuelled by genuine outrage at abuses by the press and politically inspired protests designed to damage the Conservatives.

The Tory leader is hoping that beyond the triangle of Westminster, Wapping and Scotland Yard few will be paying too much attention and that he can hang on to the Director of Communications - the former editor of the News of the World - who he values so much.

Cameron standing by his man

Nick Robinson | 15:10 UK time, Thursday, 9 July 2009

Comments (78)

David Cameron is standing by his man.

The line coming from his close allies is that he is not even contemplating asking Andy Coulson, his communications director, to resign.

One source insisted that no significant new facts had emerged since Mr Coulson had been appointed by the Tories, and said, "The past is the past. Mistakes were made but he paid a high price for them. There is a world of difference between what he did as a tabloid editor and what he does for us."

The source went on to say that if Mr Coulson was called to give evidence before the Commons Media Select Committee "that wouldn't change our view of him at all".

Everyone is now waiting to see what Yates of the Yard has to say about why the Metropolitan Police did not extend its inquiry to cover all those whose voicemail was hacked into and whether he will re-open the original investigation.

For now, the Tories are determined to tough this out.

Becoming the story

Nick Robinson | 09:24 UK time, Thursday, 9 July 2009

Comments (278)

The police showed a list of names of targets for phone hacking to one of those whose voicemails were illegally hacked into by the News of the World. This happened in the lead-up to the jailing of the paper's royal editor and the private investigator he used. The individual, who I've spoken to, recognised the names of many familiar public figures and the stories that had appeared in the paper about them.

This revelation may add to the pressure for a further investigation into how widespread phone hacking was, and who knew about it. Already the Chairman of the Commons Media Committee, John Whittingdale, has said he may re-open his inquiry into the affair.

Andy CoulsonSo, is David Cameron right to be "relaxed" about the implications for his Director of Communications, Andy Coulson?

Certainly, he must have known the risk when he hired Coulson just months after he had been forced to resign as the editor of the News of the World. At the time Coulson said he knew nothing about what had happened, although as editor he'd taken full responsibility for it. The Guardian is clear this morning that it has no evidence to the contrary.

The Tories' first reaction to the Guardian story was that it only contained one new revelation - that the News of the World had reached a huge out-of-court settlement with Gordon Taylor, the leader of the footballers union, one of those whose phones it had hacked into. As this deal was reached after Coulson resigned they argued that this was a story not about politics but the media.

Their hope was that many papers would steer clear of this story since their own journalists are alleged to have indulged in blagging - paying to obtain private data under false pretences - if not hacking.

They argue that the interventions of John Prescott, Charles Clarke and Alastair Campbell should be seen simply as a politically motivated campaign to damage David Cameron and one of his key advisers.

This morning the Tory leader has sought to distinguish between what Coulson did in the past at the News of the World and what he does now for him by declaring:

"I believe in giving people a second chance. As director of communications for the Conservatives, he does an excellent job in a proper, upright way at all times."

The problem he faces is that new questions are now being opened about the past.

It is now clear that phone hacking at the News of the World was much more widespread than previously thought; that it targeted senior ministers not just celebrities and that, if the Guardian is correct, at least one of the paper's executives knew about it. This is leading to calls - not just from Labour politicians - for Andy Coulson to answer questions about what he knew and to questions about whether he should be at David Cameron's side.

That is why I am sure that David Cameron is anything but "relaxed", as was claimed last night.

Coulson has already broken rule one for any spin doctor - "Never become the story". He's good enough at his job to know that this story will soon become one about David Cameron's judgement.

Explore the BBC

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.