CommentsSign in

You need to sign in to contribute to this page. If you're new to BBC Blogs, creating your membership is quick and easy.

• Previous
• Next

• 1. At 2:40pm on 22 Oct 2008, Thorin98 wrote:

  I haven't seen Mama Mia, but I now feel I know exactly how the you felt the instant you realised Pierce Brosnan was about to start singing!

  Complain about this comment

• 2. At 3:50pm on 22 Oct 2008, adamwilcox wrote:

  For succintness, the review of High School Musical 3 could have stopped with "Here we have a profit and loss line..."

  Complain about this comment

• 3. At 4:06pm on 22 Oct 2008, WillOrpin wrote:

  So you liked it then?

  Complain about this comment

• 4. At 5:47pm on 22 Oct 2008, Narcelia wrote:

  You are a wonderful entertainer! (And a brilliant critic as well of course...)

  Complain about this comment

• 5. At 11:15pm on 22 Oct 2008, Arfa wrote:

  So, are you in High School Musical 3 then?

  Complain about this comment

• 6. At 12:49pm on 23 Oct 2008, Ian Robinson wrote:

  But I don't know if it's any good or not!

  Complain about this comment

• 7. At 8:05pm on 23 Oct 2008, repmar wrote:

  Well I suppose it does what it says on the tin....which is more than be said for a lot of films

  Complain about this comment

• 8. At 8:27pm on 23 Oct 2008, colinr0380 wrote:

  "For succintness, the review of High School Musical 3 could have stopped with "Here we have a profit and loss line..."
  
  Yes - they profit and we lose! Ba-zing!
  
  "Well I suppose it does what it says on the tin....which is more than be said for a lot of films"
  
  Wasn't that the tag line for a certain brand of wood stain, and insert your preferred joke about wooden actors here!
  
  Oh and Mr Kermode I now dare you to illustrate The Devils in the style of the film itself (It might make the blog X-rated though!)
  
  
  
  

  Complain about this comment

• 9. At 12:08pm on 24 Oct 2008, cineshaun wrote:

  You know what I'm glad that there are films like HSM 3 out there for kids.
  
  Yes, it may be sickly sweet and quite frankly a bit daft but hey its good harmless fun with morals and a heart. So what's wrong with that?

  Complain about this comment

• 10. At 4:31pm on 24 Oct 2008, AnthonyLane wrote:

  dr k
  this has nothing to do with high school musical part III but with today's show (oct 24). you wondered that one never knows what goes on behind the scences, when a movie is actually made (in reference to the Quantum of Something and its botched story line). let me combine this query with your dislike for mr apatow and refer you to this clip:
  
  http://www.funnyordie.com/videos/4882
  
  there we can see how mr apatow operates behind the camera (and what a jerk he is), as he clashes with a surprisingly forceful micheal cera (of Juno fame) during the filming of Knocked Up. since cera is not the lead in Knocked Up, it is clear that this exchange did not end in smiles.
  
  keep up the good work!
  
  patrick

  Complain about this comment

• 11. At 00:33am on 25 Oct 2008, baublebob wrote:

  A couple of years ago I had to help out at my 7 year old niece's HSM themed party and was almost driven to suicide by the incessant singing of 30 maniacal tweenies. Thank God I recovered just in time to enjoy this review.

  Complain about this comment

• 12. At 1:27pm on 25 Oct 2008, TGRWorzel wrote:

  Haven't seen it, or Mammia Mia, but I'm pleased this sort of harmless Poppins-esque film is being made. I'll happily endure the 30 maniacal tweenies anytime.
  
  This sort of movie makes a really nice change from people having their brains blown-out or having limbs hacked-off, drug-taking and alcoholism, wrecking cars and (how can I put this for the benefit of the moderators ?) doing naughty adult things with each other...

  Complain about this comment

• 13. At 01:45am on 27 Oct 2008, SirJessop wrote:

  That video was a billion times more enjoyable than the actual film. In all fairness, though, graphs in general are about a million times more enjoyable than High School Musical 3: Senior Year.

  Complain about this comment

• 14. At 2:38pm on 27 Oct 2008, G1lles wrote:

  This is what I call a Sight and Sound review.

  Complain about this comment

• 15. At 05:35am on 29 Oct 2008, Takethree wrote:

  Fantastic - just please, please, please don't go on Strictly.

  Complain about this comment

• 16. At 00:49am on 30 Oct 2008, duncanmccurdie wrote:

  You are quite beguiling in slow-mo

  Complain about this comment

• 17. At 8:02pm on 30 Oct 2008, tallScottishgirl wrote:

  In future, could all your reviews be done through the medium of dance?

  Complain about this comment

• 18. At 7:16pm on 25 Nov 2008, musichyper wrote:

  I never understood the point of musicals. It's silly to me to see and hear people singing for every moment. It looked well filmed and there seemed to be plenty of talent.
  
  I HYPED High school Musical 3 on EverHYPE and scored it 64%, which I think is very accurate.
  
  http://www.everhype.com/hyper/mikeborgia?X=M726
  
  If you get on there, rate me a 5 on it and request friendship.
  
  
  
  

  Complain about this comment

• 19. At 7:17pm on 25 Nov 2008, musichyper wrote:

  I never understood the point of musicals. It's silly to me to see and hear people singing for every moment. It looked well filmed and there seemed to be plenty of talent.
  
  I HYPED High school Musical 3 on EverHYPE and scored it 64%, which I think is very accurate.
  
  http://www.everhype.com/hyper/mikeborgia?X=M726
  
  If you get on there, rate me a 5 on it and request friendship.
  
  

  Complain about this comment

• 20. At 07:38am on 03 Jan 2009, coolkhush188 wrote:

  hsm 3 is a hit wen it realsed in india im glad that threr are movies like this that are made for children .......

  Complain about this comment

• 21. At 11:34am on 21 Feb 2009, kermodenutter1 wrote:

  High School Musical is a great film franchise, squeaky clean and perfect for younger viewers. Too bad that the older film critics don't understand the rather briliant films.

  Complain about this comment

• 22. At 11:40am on 21 Feb 2009, kermodenutter1 wrote:

  At least we have better singers in this franchise than batty brosnan in Mamma Mia!!! Maybe Meryl Streep should take the role as Miss Darbus and could beat out a rendition of Breaking Free in the classroom!

  Complain about this comment

• Previous
• Next

View these comments in RSS