BBC BLOGS - Betsan's Blog
« Previous | Main | Next »

The long fuse

Betsan Powys | 16:43 UK time, Friday, 4 September 2009

It's still oh so quiet in the Bay.

There's still more than two weeks until the AMs return for the start of the autumn term, or as one dressed down party aide put it to me, rolling his eyes, 'the children come back to school'.

But the silence is deceptive.

There's a background noise of a ticking clock - or the countdown to September the 29th, the self imposed deadline for the First Minister to make his intentions about his future known.

Has the decision been made? Yes. Those who were still talking 50:50 going/staying last week are revising it daily to 70:30, 80:20. The consensus is that Rhodri Morgan will stand down. There's no force majeure, be it an autumn general election or swine flu out of control in Wales which is leading him towards staying on.

So instead, thoughts turn to choreography.

September 29th - Rhodri Morgan's 70th birthday, in case you're not a regular reader - falls during Labour's annual conference. What better way to announce that he's standing down as leader of Labour in Wales than among comrades, basking in the warm gratitude of his party, from the Prime Minister downwards, for all he has achieved in a long and distinguished career. Mr Morgan is a party man through and through, after all.

But there are a couple of issues here.

The first among them, as the sharper eyed of you will have noticed, is that contrary to popular belief, Rhodri Morgan is not the leader of the Labour Party in Wales. He's simply leader of the Labour Group in the National Assembly and it's by that role that he is de facto the First Minister.

Secondly, the Labour conference is in Brighton. I spend regular family holidays in Brighton and I reckon I've sniffed out most of the local Welsh connections. It didn't take me that long. Wouldn't it undermine an announcement with such fundamental implications for the leadership of Wales that it was delivered in an English seaside resort, not in Wales, if not the Welsh capital? It doesn't feel ... statesmanlike somehow.

You can easily imagine that it's not exactly what a Prime Minister straining every sinew to ensure conference messages all drive towards towards the General Election would want either.

Here's where the choreography comes in though. Remember the ticking clock, and reach for the calendar. It would be impossible for Mr Morgan not to make his intentions clear at the conference - his own "on or around" deadline imposes that on him. Were he to say nothing, the speculation would run out of control that he's staying on.

He must either have said he's standing down by then - more of that in a moment or ...

Mr Morgan tells his colleagues in Brighton that he's addressing them as First Minister and as leader of their group in the National Assembly for the last time. There's a warm glow, a between-the-lines rather than an in-the-headlines bye-bye perhaps.

Then it's back to Cardiff. At 2pm on Tuesday Mr Morgan will face his weekly session of First Minister's Questions. It's likely that both Nick Bourne and Kirsty Williams will have already used their questions the previous week to press him on his future. They'll have watched his obvious discomfort over recent months at attempts to get him to show his hand.

It's likely, surely, that the Assembly authorities would be receptive to a request for the First Minister to make a personal statement to the chamber at 2pm as the first item of business. But his announcement that he's standing down as leader of a political grouping is surely a party, not a government announcement? It would all be in the wording, I suspect. There are a lot of upsides to this. It's statesmanlike, it would allow the other party leaders to pay warm and as I'm sure we all anticipate, sincere tributes to a man who has done more than any other to keep devolution in Wales on track.

The Labour conference, though, is late in the season, and the Assembly returns from recess on Tuesday, September 22, a week earlier. It's possible that Mr Morgan could make an announcement that soon, if he fears any reluctance to respond to the goading will simply fuel the speculation that either he's staying - or he still hasn't made up his mind.

A few days seems like a decent interlude before the battle for his job starts in earnest. Then we may all be reminded that "Oh so quiet" was a cover version - of a song called "Blow a fuse".


or register to comment.

  • 1. At 6:39pm on 04 Sep 2009, Notonationalism wrote:

    Who cares? It won't make one jot of difference who runs the Labour Party. The media seem to hold the bizarre notion that Labour members are bothered about Rhodri's retirement. The Party is fast being destroyed by the unholy and undemocratic coalition with the nationalists. None of the prospective candidates have stated that they are against either this coalition or further powers for the Assembly. Perhaps the candidates for the Welsh leadership should start speaking to True Wales.

    Complain about this comment

  • 2. At 7:50pm on 04 Sep 2009, Jack_Wilkinson wrote:

    What is wrong with Welsh Labour? Rhodri Glynn Thomas, whilst on Dragon's Eye, said 'Plaid would be happy to form a coalition with Labour, Rhodri ( Morgan ) is very popular with Plaid's language activists'.
    How can Rhodri, who appeals to the language crazed of Plaid, be anything but loathed by English speakers who totally abhor language enforcement. Know wonder Llafur's vote share is crashing, I don't see Welsh Labour as politicians, I see them as an army of occupation imposing THEIR alien language and culture.

    Complain about this comment

  • 3. At 10:22pm on 04 Sep 2009, Jack_Wilkinson wrote:

    This pre-moderation on Betsan's blog, is fine by me. The BBC, obviously has the finest IT whizz kids, and, a massive search engine? So if I tell the truth, Betsan's blog does tend to give it airspace, that's all we can ask for, a voice.
    When John Griffiths, AM for Newport east, made his assembly maiden speech, he did so in the most bizarre manner. Other AMs, started their speeches with..I'm so proud..or I'm so humble to represent the people of.....whatever.
    John Griffiths, started his maiden speech with this sectarian nonsense, his words verbatim!!...'I'm an Irish-Welsh Celt, my mother comes from the west of Ireland, and, my father is a real Welsh Griffiths'......?

    Complain about this comment

  • 4. At 12:46pm on 05 Sep 2009, Notonationalism wrote:

    Had John Griffiths been a German politician 70 years ago, he might well have introduced himself to the Reichstag as being of 'Teutonic stock' and saying, instead, 'My mother comes from German Sudetenland stock and my father is a real German Hess/Schmidt/Klein/Fleischer. Why is Celtic nationalism considered by so many to be not only acceptable but desirable?

    Complain about this comment

  • 5. At 4:32pm on 05 Sep 2009, christiancitizen wrote:

    "...or as one dressed down party aide put it to me, rolling his eyes, 'the children come back to school'...." and thats one of their own aides saying that!

    Complain about this comment

  • 6. At 10:14pm on 05 Sep 2009, Jack_Wilkinson wrote:

    Anyway, in the real world of us English speaking Brits, the vote share for Rhodri's EWPP, crashes out of sight! The game is up for Rhodri type, Cymraeg bully boy supremacy!!
    I just cannot imagine the British Labour movement, putting up with the vote losing sectarian idiocy of, Explicitly Welsh Patriotic Party? They sound like something outta N. Korea, maybe, Paul Flynn and John Griffiths, could be told to bog off and join Sinn-Fein?

    Complain about this comment

  • 7. At 1:06pm on 06 Sep 2009, Notonationalism wrote:

    I'm afraid the leadership of the British Labour Movement seems to have thrown in the towel on this issue.

    If I were a grassroots Tory, I would support the replacement of Nick Bourne with an anti-further powers AM.

    Perhaps a new Party which explicitly opposes the break up of the UK needs to be formed to house those of us who are appalled at the way that nationalism has infiltrated our own parties.

    Complain about this comment

  • 8. At 9:40pm on 06 Sep 2009, Jack_Wilkinson wrote:

    thankfully, the three Conservative MPs, want the demise of the parasitic edifice of eventual separation. They hold far more sway than a few parochial AMs, in the assembly that Conservatives never wanted in the first place.

    Saying that, can you imagine the anger in Labour politicians who never want devolution in the first place? I bet that Neil Kinnock, is thrilled too bits that the language crazed Rhodri, has renamed the party once known as.......Labour, into EWPP?

    Complain about this comment

View these comments in RSS


Sign in

BBC navigation

BBC © 2014 The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. Read more.

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.