BBCi Labs Blog

BBCi Labs is no longer updated. Please visit our new blog, Press Red, for the latest from the BBC's Red Button team.

The Removal of What's On on Freeview

  • TVP
  • 29 Oct 08, 10:34 AM

Farah Fahmy writes:

On Thursday the 9th of October, What's On was taken out from the BBC Red Button service. This generated complaints from some viewers, and we have responded both within the Red Button service and via this blog.

The decision to remove What's On wasn't one that was taken lightly. To understand why we took this decision, I'd like to explain the processes we went through to get to where we are now.

In October 2006, we started thinking about how the Red Button service should prepare for Digital Switchover (DSO). DSO, which will replace all analogue signals with digital signals, is being rolled out progressively throughout the UK. It starts next Thursday, and the transmitter at Selkirk will be the first one to be switched over.

A "side effect" of DSO is the demise of Ceefax, as this is currently carried only on analogue.

One of the first pieces of work that we needed to do therefore was to create a gap analysis of Ceefax content against Red Button content. We knew that Ceefax carries more content than the Red Button service and that whilst the Red Button service can accommodate most of this, some Ceefax services, like Share Prices and Flight Arrivals, use up a lot of bandwidth on the digital platforms.

This was a big issue for us. We are constrained by the amount of bandwidth that is available for the Red Button service on all digital platforms. For example, on Freeview the Red Button text service has a total of 700kb/s of bandwidth. That space is taken up not just by content, but also graphics, the MHEG application, templates and some video and audio. Yet here was more content that we needed to fit in.

It was very obvious to us that there was no way we could fit all this content and still hope that the service would remain as accessible as it currently is. To find out how much slower the service would be if we added all this content, we ran a series of tests. The conclusion was as expected - the service took a much longer time to load if all Ceefax content was added. We know viewers like the performance to be as fast as possible so this provided us with a challenge.

Our tests also showed that we could only add an extra amount of content before the service started to deteriorate. The question was, if we couldn't add all the content we wanted, what content should we have on the service?

Running parallel to the technical tests was a series of discussions between the TV Platforms Group and our colleagues in the BBC's Journalism division, who produce our News, Sport and Weather content. Obviously all Ceefax content is important, but if we couldn't carry all of it, which ones should we carry?

A series of research projects was carried out, aimed at finding out what content was deemed the most valuable by Ceefax users. The results helped us decide what we felt was the best of Ceefax content, and this in turn formed the basis of the content that we offer on the Red Button on all platforms. We also looked at what content was available elsewhere both via TV screens, in newspapers and online via websites.

We agreed that these pieces of Ceefax content were needed on the Red Button:

  • UK Flight Arrivals
  • Community content (which includes information from voluntary organisations and Read Hear, the magazine for deaf and hard of hearing people in the UK)
  • Farm Prices for the rural community

Now we had to find the space to fit all this content in.

This is not such an issue on the Virgin Media platform, as our space constraint isn't as great here. On Sky, we were broadcasting duplicate content on various transponders, so we took the decision to re-structure our content so that we avoid duplication as far as is possible. This meant that no content was lost, even if the journey to get to that content may change.

Freeview however was a problem. The service on Freeview was already as small as we could technically make it, yet we were still required to add more content. Was there anything we could lose on this platform?

Earlier in the year, we removed our Movies service. This definitely helped, but we still needed more space. After much debate, we came to the conclusion that the only service we could lose to make room for newer content was What's On.

When What's On was first launched, many Freeview set-top boxes did not include Electronic Programme Guides (EPGs). However, modern set-top boxes now do include the EPG. Therefore we felt that it didn't make sense for us to continue this service when it is available elsewhere, and when we need to use the space it occupied for other content.

We realise that some people are unhappy with this decision, but in our opinion, the experience of getting programme information alongside the broadcast and being able to tune to it is better via EPGs than the old What's On service.

As more and more of the TV screens become IP enabled then viewers will see more textual information being made available this way. Watch this space!

Farah Fahmy is a Development Producer for the BBC Red Button service.


  • 1. At 1:29pm on 29 Oct 2008, Frankie Roberto wrote:

    Interesting on a few fronts. Firstly, I never realised that the What's On information existed through the red button, even though I used to have a Freeview box that only showed now and next (no 7 day listing).

    Secondly, the idea that farmers are using Ceefax to gather pricing information is fascinating! Are they making business decisions based on this data (whether to go to market or not)? And are there no online providers of this service? If not, there's obviously a gap in the market...

    Complain about this comment

  • 2. At 8:55pm on 10 Nov 2008, normallyplacid wrote:

    The problem with EPG (electronic program guide) provided with most set top boxes is that they only give NOW and NEXT.

    This is fine provided the BBC have not moved a program more than one slot or changed channels - like Autumn Watch and Little Dorrit.

    Without an uptodate proper and complete program guide such as red button WhatsOn rpovided setting the DVD to record on of the things that BBC have arranged to clash. It is amazing how often BBC1 BBC2 and BBC4 manage to have simutaneous content that I want to watch.

    No point in buying a TV listing publication any longer as BBC keep moving programs at the last minute.

    Complain about this comment

  • 3. At 08:08am on 15 Nov 2008, Sue_Aitch wrote:

    The UK Wide Charity details Lifeline and DEC Emergency appeals are still niot available via the Red Button.

    BBC Cymru Wales Charity Appeals are missing too.

    The Radio 4 Appeal does appear on Freeview Chennel 704 on the Red Button Servce: surely these pages are ripoe fr migration too.

    If you are looking for bandwidth to takae these services, may I suggest Nev's Horoscopes could go: I think you might get less fuss form CBBC viewers over that bit of CBBC's Red Button service if you warned them a few weeks in advance!

    Complain about this comment

View these comments in RSS

The BBC is not responsible for the content of external internet sites