Advertisement
Listen to Jeff's shows on the iPlayer
« Previous | Main | Next »

Maybe I'm Too Old To Twitter

Post categories:

Jeff Zycinski | 18:00 UK time, Sunday, 24 May 2009

Twittering.jpg

The journalist and restaurant critic, Allan Brown, has written a very funny article for today's Sunday Times Ecosse section. I don't mean that to sound like a rare or unexpected event (he said quickly, fearing the wrath of the mighty Murdoch media empire) but I just wanted to flag it up before I move on to something else. Allan's funny article concerns an over-elaborate dessert trolley which he encountered in a Stirlingshire hotel. The newspaper cost me two quid, but it was almost worth it for that piece alone. (No problem Mr Murdoch, Sir.)

But, as I say, that's not what I want to talk about. I refer you, instead, to another Allan Brown article.

Also in today's Ecosse section and under the headline "Twittering should be made a cardinal sin" Allan describes this latest social networking phenomenon as "the most facile and otiose social trend since flash mobbing". He goes on to say that "only two types of people over the age of 30 continue to Twitter: braggart lawyer blokes and verbally incontinent professionally anxious women in the creative industries".

This worries me because, although I'm well over 30, I fit into neither of those groups. I do, however, have the horrible feeling that I am too old to Twitter. Let me try to explain in my customary manner by recounting a childhood memory.

When I was six years old, I wrote to Santa asking him to bring me a set of Meccano. On Christmas morning 1969 Mr Claus duly obliged and I remember spending a happy hour or so playing with the nuts and bolts not caring that I had no idea what I was doing. As it happens I have six older brothers so it wasn't long before they took control of the set and, like magic, turned the various metal panels into a small jeep. Then the jeep was dismantled and turned into a crane. Then a speedboat.

It was Easter 1973 before I got my hands back on that Meccano by which time the grown-ups (as I saw them) had sucked all the fun out of it.

Were I to prod you awake at this point, you might well wonder what that story has to do with the Twitter phenomenon. Well, until recently, the Twitter-sphere seemed to be inhabited by teenagers and twenty-somethings all keen to share their thoughts on music gigs and reality TV shows. It was the online equivalent of loitering on street corners talking about nothing much at all. In other words, it was a bit of fun with your mates.

Nowadays, too many Twitter friends and followers seem to be blokes like me; grown men and women keen to assure ourselves that we are not missing out on anything and trying to prove to our teenage sons and daughters that we are, well, "connected".
The trouble starts when we start to take it too seriously.

Last week, for example, blog reader Fiona MacBeath told me that she and her husband would miss the big Inverness game on Saturday because they would be flying across the Atlantic at the start of a family holiday. I, of course, offered to attend the game and Twitter updates live from the scene. Fiona thought this was a great idea and decided to subscribe to Twitter to take advantage of this unique offer. And yes, because I'm a grown up and aware of my responsibilities as an adult, I had to stick to my promise. That's why, yesterday afternoon, I spent a thumb-numbing ninety minutes hammering away at the keys on my BlackBerry. I described the pre-match atmosphere, I alluded to the BBC Radio Scotland commentary and I was right on the button with the kick-off. I was doing quite well, in fact, until the blasted thing slipped out of my lap and scudded down three rows of the family stand. Yes, if you were watching the game on the telly, I was that bloke bobbing around the crowd and annoying all the home fans by asking them if they'd seen my phone. I wouldn't be surprised if I also distracted some of the Caley players with my antics and maybe that's what cost us the game.

So, yes, maybe I am too old to Twitter.

Anyone want to be my pen-pal?

Comments

or register to comment.

  • 1. At 7:15pm on 24 May 2009, cvbruce wrote:

    Jeff, JZ, Mr. Zed,

    I'm an old-timer on twitter, almost 2 years now.

    I don't see the problem with twitter being the change by older people joining, but the move from social scene to vast commercialization. Whereas in the past a person might tweet that they were headed out to a movie, now we have companies telling you about their latest and greatest thing, and offering you a discount code.

    In that past I might tweet that I was headed out to get coffee, and my friends knew which store I was headed to, and might meet up with me there. Now I'm more likely to see someone slogging their latest DVD, and trying to get their followers to buy more copies so that they will get a higher rating on Amazon.

    I added a bunch of "popular" people lately, and found out that, I'm just not interested in what they have to say. So, I've been deleting people that I aren't really my friends. I'm getting tired of people self-promoting themselves every ten minutes.

    So it's not the older people, it is the concept that we must advertise on every medium that exists.

    Oh, and I'm older than you.

    CVBruce

    Complain about this comment

  • 2. At 07:24am on 25 May 2009, U13982173 wrote:

    you are not old~

    http://www.nowgoal.com/22.shtml

    Complain about this comment

  • 3. At 11:36am on 25 May 2009, Al Issner wrote:

    No, Zestful Mr. Z, you're not too old to twitter. I diagnose post-traumatic-game stress. However, you are apparently too old to remember how to spell Meccano correctly!

    Complain about this comment

  • 4. At 11:50am on 25 May 2009, Al Issner wrote:

    By the way, would being pen-pals involve my writing to you in Polish, and your writing back to me in Fife-ish, with each of us correcting the other's mistakes? And would we eventually visit each other's families? On second thoughts, maybe I'm too old to be a pen-pal!

    Complain about this comment

  • 5. At 1:04pm on 25 May 2009, JeffZycinski wrote:

    Thanks all...and Al, I will correct that mistake immediately.

    Complain about this comment

  • 6. At 02:07am on 27 May 2009, SpikeNesmith wrote:

    The man's a fool. And a pretentious fool, at that.

    I'm not 30 anymore, and I Twitter. Most of my contacts on Twitter are either over 30. Quite frankly, the article looks like just another hack "critique something popular" article, written quickly by someone who doesn't *want* to understand it.

    I Twitter in full English, as do almost all of my contacts. The sort of people who shrtn wrdz N USE CAPS N 1337-SPEEK probably shouldn't even be on his (or our) radar, unless they're relatives. I'm not sure who he added on Twitter to get this apparent torrent of "mistyped, grammar-free crossword clues". My best guess is that nobody he knows Twitters, and he just added a bunch of random accounts.

    That said, anybody who uses the words "facile" and "otiose" unironically probably doesn't *deserve* friends. =D

    Complain about this comment

  • 7. At 2:40pm on 27 May 2009, fionmacb wrote:

    Oh, dear. Did I start all this? Apart from Jeff's example and his stirling efforts on reporting the game, I don't really see the point of twitter other than a bit of fun. Perhaps I just don't consider things I do to be important to anyone other then me or the people I chat to anyway. So I don't think I could take it seriously.

    Would have loved to have seen that home stand scramble though, Jeff. Sounded hilarious.

    Complain about this comment

  • 8. At 7:31pm on 27 May 2009, JeffZycinski wrote:

    Fiona...I'm surprised it wasn't the highlight on Match of the Day. Worst of it was the woman who found my BlacKberry didn't believe it was mine and tried to give it to the woman in front of her. A right panto!

    Complain about this comment

  • 9. At 11:10pm on 27 May 2009, madmacfraeclydebank wrote:

    Something kinda like this JZ?

    Oh no it isn't!

    Oh yes it is... now give me it!

    Complain about this comment

View these comments in RSS

Explore the BBC

This page is best viewed in an up-to-date web browser with style sheets (CSS) enabled. While you will be able to view the content of this page in your current browser, you will not be able to get the full visual experience. Please consider upgrading your browser software or enabling style sheets (CSS) if you are able to do so.